IMPORTANT: To confirm your signature you MUST click on the link in the confirmation email we sent you.
If you did not receive an email from us, please check your spam folder for <admin@flywithdignity.org>.
——————————————————–
To
Janet Napolitano, Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security;
John S. Pistole, Administrator of the Transportation Security Agency;
We, the undersigned, petition the Department of Homeland Security's subsidary, the Transportation Security Agency, for an immediate, and indefinite moratorium on the usage of the Backscatter X-Ray Machines (also referred to as "Full-Body Scanning Machines" and end to subsequent unnecessary and unethical "pat downs" or physical body searches for the reasons listed below.
*Invasion of Privacy & Violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution.
Under the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, it is stated:
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." - The United States Constitution, Fourth Amendment.
By interpretation of the amendment, The Undersigned believe the BackScatter X-Ray Machine & subsequent requirement of pat-down searches following an opt-out is both unethical and unconstitutional. By requirement of the Constitution, a non-consenting search requires a warrant issued by a court of the United States Government, and to be conducted by an officer of the law of whom carries the qualifications and responsibilities of the position. We reiterate the act of body searches or usage of Backscatter X-Ray machines are unconstitutional and should not be conducted by any organization, especially a Department of the United States Government.
It has been found by several studies, reported by credible news organizations such as the NY Daily News (http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/2010/08/04/2010-08-04_feds_admit_they_stored_body_scanner_images_despite_tsa_claim_the_images_cannot_b.html) that the supposed imagery printed by the machine is not destroyed, and instead kept on record and used for reasons beyond the prevention of criminal activity. As a result, this in direct violation of the rights stated prior and the right of private, suggestive, and personal imagery created by the machinery to not be kept by an organization without consent of the individual.
Also, it is believed the resulting requirement of a "pat-down" or physical body search following an opt-out of a Backscatter X-Ray Machine scan is again unethical, as it brings upon the individual of an assumption of guilt and requirement of such an invasive search by individuals who do not have warrants or other documentation permitting the search.
*Lack of Knowledge in Long-Term Usage
Studies conducted by research universities across the nation are beginning to show signs of the possibility of long term ill effects, such as cancer, in the extended usage of the Backscatter X-Ray Machine. For example, the machine used in the Backscatter X-Ray uses the same radiation as other X-Rays in use at medical centers across the nation, however those machines shield the radiation from all areas that do not require examination, and therefore reduce the risk of ill-effects. The Backscatter X-Ray machine does not shield any of the radiation emitted, and subsequently leaves the potential for ill-effects from the machine to occur. No matter how the radiation exposure can be compared to other events or activities in our daily life, it does not justify the added radiation exposed through the machine, and the potential for there to be future ill effects from the machines' usage.
For these reasons, we petition for the immediate, indefinite moratorium until a settlement can be reached that is not invasive of privacy, nor have the potential of ill effects medically.
Sincerely,
The Undersigned
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself. Also, the TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening.
These genital searches and naked scanners do not increase security. All they do is deter people from flying. TSA should do the same as El Al Airlines, winner of the most secure airline in the world award (Global Traveler magazine, 2008).
Also, it's clear that most of the TSA procedures are not helping secure our flights, and that the expenditure *far* outweighs the thread. We are spending precious resources chasing ghosts, just like bin Laden knew we would.
I refuse to submit to unreasonable searches of my person. You will not see so much as a penny from me until this policy is rescinded. I'm willing to drive and take trains as necessary for my travel requirements.
isn't the TSA suppose to be the LAST LINE of defense in keeping the public safe?
Because of the TSA's invasive, humiliating, and dehumanizing airport security policies, I will urge all family and friends to drive or take Amtrak instead.
I idea of Body Scans, Cavity Searches and Body Searches is just downright unconstitutional and disgusting. This has got to stop!
As of right now, becoming a TSA screener is a pedofile or perverts dream job. They get PAID to MOLEST anyone who passes through the terminal and if they protest in any shape, manor, or for any reasion, they can get pulled asside for a strip search and further degredation. If anyone else were to do this, they would face sexual assult charges. TSA members who participate in this program should face manditory jail time for this abuse of power.
I will not board a plane until this is fixed.
STOP.
TSA has not stopped a single terrorist in 10 years. Stop defrauding the nation.
The current policies of the TSA make the United States an embarrassment to the global community and I am ashamed of their behavior.
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.-Ben Franklin
Enough!
The current policies of the TSA make the United States an embarrassment to the global community and I am ashamed of their behavior.
The pat downs are clearly just to discourage travelers from opting out of the scanner.
I plan to opt-out the next time and every time I fly.
Your methods are unnecessary and humiliating. They don't work and make a mockery of people's dignity.
Look you window over to Arlington. Look at those graves. They did not die so that you could defile the country with your actions. They did not die for someone like you.
This is date rape without roofies and in front of every one!
Enough with the security theater!
Bring back sanity to security. Right now, it's all about theater and reactive thinking.
I do not fear a terrorist attack. I want to trade some of my safety in for some of my liberty back.
Stop the groping and violation of basic human rights in the name of security.
Constitution first.
I will not fly until this changes. I will not stand for this degrading treatment. I AM NOT A TERRORIST, I AM A LOYAL AMERICAN CITIZEN, AND DESERVE TO BE TREATED AS SUCH!
This is complete bullshit that it's ok to treat civilians like criminals, and people will just lay back and allow it. I am going to be flying in december and am uncomfortable with the idea of going through a full body scan, because of the invasion of privacy and the fact that it's a fucking illusion of security. This does not stop hijackers or terrorists or criminals, it's just supposed tomake the regular citizenry feel like they're being taken care of by the government
Why haven't you gone through the screening Janet? How do you feel about them?
We are Americans, not terrorists, stop treating us like we are the enemy.
Unfortunately, the most determined terrorists will find ways to get around scanning and searching. Moreover, the hijackers on September 11, 2001 would NOT have been caught by scans or searches, because they were not smuggling anything onto the planes.
Defund the TSA.
One more freedom down the drain.
How many rights are we going to give up in the name of safety? These are not the principals that this country was founded on. We should not have to live in fear of our own government being unethical and unconstitutional.
"Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master." - President George Washington
Theatrical Security Administration
first they came for my belt, then they came for my shoes ...
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
Learn from Israel.
I'm now revising my travel plans for the next few months to make use of the train rather than flying. With measures like this in place the terrorists *have* won.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
TSA should use the expertise of El AL where no invasion of privacy is tolerated but security is far better that on any other airline.
If this change in policy is due to a "terrorist" threat, then the "terrorists" have already won: using our own security to molest, harass and endanger ourselves.
i am so tired of our liberties getting ripped away everyday. its ridiculous.
The 4th Amendment exists for a reason.
Unconstitutional, plain and simple.
Just because we choose to purchase a plane ticket does not mean we are innocent until proven guilty. We must keep out constitutional right against unreasonable searches.
It's unfortunate, but I will attempt to avoid flying as long as these molestation procedures exist. I will rather drive 2 days to get to my destination before subjecting myself to these barbaric measures. It's disgusting to see what we've come to.
I am a frequent flyer (150k a year) and I have long commented on how much I hate this horrible invasion of privacy. This has to stop!
I will fly much less until these constraints are removed.
This is absolutely absurd.
I absolutely will not support this economy by purchasing plane tickets and flying while this is in effect. You WILL not violate my privacy or my body, nor will I allow you to humiliate or dehumanize me. Shame on you.
Hahah! Oh it's fine just get some of of this xray radiation. So what? Your arm falls off? Atleast you're "safe" from terrorists. Ugh. this is outa control. People can't let their fear of terrorism let them be so easily controlled and let their rights as a human being be taken away.
big brother is coming
I don't think the safety is worth having every person's privacy invaded to this insane level.
Unconstitutional. Safety Not Abuse
Seriously, think of the children.
I'd rather have risk with freedom than peace with slavery.
The TSA is is illegal, unethical, & abusive. If someone gropes me in a way that I would consider a sexual assault it won't matter whether they're a governmental employee or not. I have refused free-to-me airline tickets because I won't be violated by the TSA. Security Theater is only a feel-good measure for the sheep; it does nothing toward stopping criminals.
I want *real* security, not security theater with the added bonus of skin cancer.
Operating without authority or oversite, the TSA exists only to support its own structure. And in doing so makes Americans less free and less secure. With true liberty comes risk, you can be 100% safe by being 100% non-free. I choose freedom and the ability to exercise my free will. While the TSA is violating the constitution, they are violating basic human dignity.
Obsurd and sad, all this is going to do is piss everyone off more than what we are, speak up people!!
How can the TSA so blatantly violate our 4th amendment rights? I thought the Bill of Rights meant something to every citizen, including those in the government.
Government is supposed to protect its citizens safety AND rights, not choose one at the expense of the other.
Until this is fixed, airlines will not be able to receive my business - plain and simple.
While I understand the motive, it is very undignifying to be patted down or have to walk through an x-ray machine completely naked. Where is the humanity in that?
As a survivor of sexual trauma and a mother, I'm appalled at this and afraid of the message it is sending, especially to young women.
I am not an American but when I fly through the USA I do not want to be treated like a terrorist. I will not be sexually molested, even to fly the Friendly Skies.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -- Benjamin Franklin
This are tactics to humiliate us and breed fear. To humiliate is to control. Fear is control. America is about freedom!
If any private business made it conditional to sexually molest the privates of anyone entering their premises, they'd be sued out of existence. This is so far beyond the line of rational security that it's astonishing. And as an aside, we already KNOW smugglers carry cargo rectally. If we accept genital groping, how long before rectal searches become "part of the procedure"?
No parent should subject their children to the sexual molestation being conducted in the name of "security". I will continue writing the airlines each month to tell them to point the finger at DHS and TSA for not seeing any of the cash I used to spend several times a month.
Option 1: Radiological scan to render subject visually naked.
Option 2: Stranger gropes subject invasively and aggressively on outside of clothing.
Option 3: Subject in small locked room, stripped, and inside of anus and vulva inspected.
Any of these three actions would be serious felonies if not done by the government.
I refuse to live in fear.
The TSA needs to adopt common sense policies that actually prevent terrorists from boarding, not ones that intimidate and shame lawful citizens without cause. An obvious and painful violations of our fourth amendment rights.
Feel my resistance.
I don't want my kids sent through those machines!
This is outrageous. The Nazi's made the Jews undress to humiliate them.
Pilot, fully support stopping this nonsense. A theatre of security solves nothing and for an agency with over 6.8B budget the public expect more brain and less waste in the effort of coming up with a useful security system.
In school I learned what America stood for. The TSA has become anti-American.
I will not fly, spend money at any airport or airline as long as the TSA continues to use these methods that violate the rights of American Citizen and sexually assault men, women and children with their so called enhanced pat downs or nude body scanners.
What happens if you deny them. http://johnnyedge.blogspot.com/2010/11/these-events-took-place-roughly-between.html
Those who would sacrifice a little bit of freedom for the illusion of a little bit of safety deserve neither.
I worked for the FAA fro 25 years before my retirement 4 years ago; I never intend to fly anywhere again. I fI can't get somewhere by train, boat or automobile, it's not worth going there.
I refuse to submit to unreasonable searches of my person. Body scanners and the new revised pat down procedures are neither constitutional, proven safe or morally sane. I whole hearty support taking this before the supreme court. Prepare for battle.
Security theatre is not security. You're not fooling anyone that's paying attention. This bullshit needs to stop.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons...against unreasonable searches...shall not be violated"
I would feel much safer with a few highly trained agents scouring the lines and parking lots at airports, rather than on a complete reliance on the bottleneck at the checkpoints. Spend the millions training TSA employees, not on digital anal probes.
We Native Americans should have had weapons checks at our boarders in 1492...fuck you white bastards!
I am appalled. I will not fly under these conditions. STOP THIS OUTRAGE.
These devices and alternative searches are unreasonable.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons...against unreasonable searches...shall not be violated"
Unless we step up for our rights, and I mean all of our rights not just a select few, the government will try to out step its bounds in order to convince us they are preserving "freedom". In reality they know not what they do. End this trend now, unless you wish to see the abomination of other civil liberties.
I stood in a backscatter machine and was directed to hold my hands up as if I were a criminal. It scanned me and I felt disgusted, ashamed and afraid, imagining who might be "checking" my naked body. After I walked out, I felt exactly the same as I did once when a man groped me on the street. I felt sick and violated.
I will be contacting both my Senator and Congressman about this issue. The use of back scatter x-ray and subsequent requirement of pat down including touching of genitalia is a CLEAR violation of our 4th Amendment rights.
Please stop this useless theater and continue improving *security* by scanning all cargo and luggage, increasing impediments to unwanted cockpit access and briefing passengers on aggresive physical tactics in case of hijacking.
Our rights are null. Terrorists winning.
This behavior must stop.
Increase airport security: ride Amtrak.
I'm glad that the TSA wants to see me naked and touch my penis but honestly I'd rather them not. These procedures are just ridiculous. Then the TSA actually catches a terrorist, I might be impressed but in the almost 10 years of service they're provided, they haven't caught anyone.
Enough of the "security" theater that accomplishes nothing but harass us, frequent travelers.
It's honestly pretty sad it's gotten this far.
Ridiculous rules for the sake of security... What would they find by touching my penis? To what do I owe this discomfort? What do they win by making me subject to these stupid rules?
Gotta love the innovations of Homeland (In)security. I dread every time I have to make a trip to the airport to travel somewhere.
so wrong
I don't fly regularly, but I believe very strongly that people I don't know shouldn't touch or see anything I don't want them to.
Lets all do our part to end this terrible injustice.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a Temporary Safety, deserve neither". Ben Franklin
Wouldn't simply blocking off access between the passenger compartment and the cockpit prevent hijacking from being possible? It would probably cost a lot less in the long run as well.
I'd rather drive now than so much as remove my shoes for this futile, demeaning, criminal treatment, security "show" at the airport.
The use of demeaning and violent physical contact with passengers' genitals to increase the use of irradiating devices with no published safety data is appalling but not surprising. This new high in the trend of exchanging vital liberties for illusory gains in safety must be rejected immediately. Show us the outcomes that justify such measures; show us the gains that are worth surrendering our freedom.
Not to mention this is a breach of the 4th amendment, simply the amount of X-rays a frequent flyer is submitted to are not acceptable and can't be healthy regardless of what the 'experts' say. Pregnant ladies are told to stay away from X-rays so how could this possibly be a good thing in any way?
Stop trying to pump fear into the minds of Americans.
Stop these ridiculous intrusive body searches and start getting serious about hunting down terrorists abroad. I'm sick of my country playing defense and losing all of its liberties!
As a professional airline captain I find these procedures un-American and do not see the TSA improving safety aboard my aircraft. Security has to start before the terrorist reach the airport!
I will never fly with the intrusive, unnecessary, and immoral security measures in place.
I will not allow my family to fly should an attempt be made to apply either of the mentioned tactics. I will make other arrangements and inform the airlines of why I canceling my current and future travel plans.
Fear is not acceptable.
This is Illegal search and seizure.
I have a metal implant in my hip and have been subjected to those new invasive pat downs and gropings.....just horrible. I always tell the TSA agent before going through the detector that I will set it off as I have a metal implant, they don't listen, wave me through and then when I set it off body block me, bark at me to stay where I am and yell for female assistance. I know I am not the 1st traveler to have metal in my body.....whay do they make such a scene, make me feel like a criminal when I already told them that I will set the detector off and why.....and yes, needed a cigarette after the last 2 gropings....and by a minion representing the governement...scary.
These unreasonable, ineffective and intrusive searches are a disgrace to everything America used to stand for.
This is outrageous. Is this really the best you can come up with?? Don't you think a terrorist would simply hide a weapon/device in their rectum/vagina? This is completely ludicrous..at what point have the terrorists won? I would rather die of a rare terrorist attack than to live as a constant suspect.
We cannot live our lives based on fear and we should not allow the government to treat us all like criminals. I will not fly until security checks become reasonable.
Wher is the freedom that I spent years in the military to protect?
I understand a need for safety, but this is blatant abuse of power. I wish to Fly With Dignity, not with a violation of my groin.
This is an invasion of our privacy and degrades us as human beings.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
fuck the police
Strip searching everyone only to make terrorists cache explosives internally? That's not just un-American, it's stupid.
This is completely unconstitutional, a theoretical safety increase is not worth our rights and freedoms. I'm veteran and I'm ashamed to have served a nation that would justify actions as such!
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
These new "security" measures along with other methods employed since 9/11 have time and time again been demonstrated to be infective at making air travel safer while repeatedly violated basic constitutional rights. Such practices cannot be allowed to continue.
As stated in a quote attributed to Benjamin Franklin: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
Yesterday prior to boarding my flight, I was physically assaulted while submitting to a pat down, I was groped in a very private place in a public area in full view of several children and their parents. At the time, I was silent, but from now on, my recording device will be on and I WILL Not Submit!
ZERO is the amount of Terrorists or their plots that the TSA has caught.
100% is the amount of travelers you abuse in the name of safety.
VIE on you TSA..
The final step before forcing us to fly naked.
Our founding father knew what was ahead for this great nation.
"He who would trade liberty for some temporary security, deserves neither liberty nor security." Benjamin Franklin
I am so mad about all of this. What will it take to stop it? Someone in a comment asked "where are all the lawyers?" Well? They seem to be able to follow every ambulance, what about this?!
Three cheers for those working to defeat the scanners, friskings and other violations of our Constitutional rights. In time, the people will prevail!
I will not be flying until I these invasive, humiliating and disgusting policies are rescinded. I have no problem taking the extra time to drive or ride a train.
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security. I won't fly until you take the power away from your goon squad TSA.
I should not be required to make a decision between seeing my family for Christmas and avoiding sexual harassment.
They should reserve this kind of advanced screening for non-citizens. US citizens have rights that should not be tromped on for percieved security.
Stop the illegal scans and searches of passengers' bodies.
The TSA has over-reached and must be stopped! We value our liberties MORE than our lives!!!
I will fly only when I am no longer treated like a criminal because i have decided to fly.
I'm not flying if I'm getting groped.
Dear TSA, Get ready for lawsuits. I just made a large donation to the ACLU.
Stop violating my 4th Amendment Rights. You have no right to search me without probable cause.
I don't live in the USA but I am traveling to Orlando this summer. This, I believe is an extreme invasion of privacy and I think human rights activists should be all over this.
Use of these scanners and pat downs is in direct violation of our 4th amendment right to protection from unwarranted searches.
This is sick and a violation if privacy, where are the human activists?
Many things in life are risky. The risk from terrorists does not justify these invasive searches - indeed they are a victory for the terrorists and an abrogation of the Bill of Rights
Humiliation + Subjugation = Tyrannical Control. Ask any Gitmo prison guard. I will not fly and others need to refuse, as well.
Pilot and military veteran. Completely aghast and now driving a car or taking a train for my travel needs.
Sick of feeling like a criminal because I purchased a plane ticket.
I fully support security in the air; however, these privacy violations are not the way to achieve that.
Please, there has to be another way to get the job done.
Invasion of privacy is not a substitute for incompetency.
Cavity searches and "anatomically correct" scanners are am abomination and an affront to common decency. I refuse to fly until the TSA is stopped!
Will only fly in an emergency, or at a private airport.
Unfortunately I already have a ticket to fly in December, but following that, unless these unacceptable practices are stopped, I plan to fly only when absolutely necessary.
Please prevent this massive sexual assault.
I will opt-out of the body scanner on Nov 24th, and I will never fly again unless this insanity ceases!
I can't believe what is happening to this country. We need to continue to fight to regain our independence!
This policy is perverse and appalling. I will only be traveling on the ground until it is changed.
I refuse to fly until TSA starts granting me my rights as American
I oppose the reckless expansion of government that exists in the form of the TSA and the "department" of homeland security.
this is an invasion of privacy like I have never seen. absolutely insane that the TSA can get away with this.
www.tsa.gov leave comments under their contact page as well. I did.
I've spent years in the Middle East defending Freedom, only to come home and see my own government and it's agencies instituting treasonous searches and policies. I'm appalled, disgusted, and betrayed. TSA should be disbanded entirely.
The government will continue to impede our liberties for exactly as long as we continue to let them. Stand up for your rights!
STAND!
I have no choice but to fly for my job, so I will opt out of the AIT scanners. However, the open hand and fingers enhanced pat-down is utterly humiliating and degrading. Every single TSA Agent should be ashamed of themselves for participating in this violation.
In addition, leading and reputable biophysicists have found flaws in the government's own safety analysis of the backscatter (Comptom) X-ray machines. Claims of safety are thus inaccurate if not outright lies.
I am with you, and I'm fed up with this bull sh*t! Let the resistance begin!
What ever happened to the 4th amendment?
"Don't touch my junk!"
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
Enough already! This is the last straw!
This has to stop: the terrorists continue to win with every scan and grope.
Respect the 4th amendment.
And TSA does this to children also.
I will not fly until the scanners are gone and the feel-ups are ceased.
I feel this is the most patriotic petition I've ever signed.
I didn't stop flying because of terrorism. I stopped flying because of the TSA.
I will never submit to such a procedure.
Read Bruce Schneier
Is the TSA supposed to protect the flying public from terrorists or to protect the non-flying public from the flying public?
This is unconstitutional and ineffective.
9/11 did not give the Government the right to take away a person's rights, regardless of what the Government might think. And as we are now seeing a shift towards the use mail-bombs, are such over-reaching security measures still needed?
I will not fly if the only way to get on the flight is to submit to a high-tech strip search, or sexual molestation.
I WILL NOT FLY TILL YOU STOP THE NAKED SCANNERS AND/OR GROPING!
When did it become okay to treat people as if they are guilty before they are proven innocent? And since when did our government subsidize sexual assault in the name of security?
This is another liberty being pushed to the side.
The "enhanced pat downs" are humiliating, offensive and intrusive enough for someone who isn't a sexual assault survivor. They are cruel and damaging, to say the least, to someone who is.
This is just one of the ways that my civil liberties have been infringed upon by the US Government recently.
I vaguely recall that one of the amendments to the constitution is supposed to protect us from things like this... 4th?
Odds of a terrorist attack: less than 1 in 1,500,000. There are lotteries that have better odds... Please use some common sense and stop pretending to protect us against something that is so slight a risk to be laughable.
Considering how many threats have been mitigated as a direct result of this increased "security", I cannot endorse its use. It is a violation of our rights and will not be tolerated.
When I fly with family I don't want anyone to look at my son naked, or touch his genitals.
These genital searches and naked scanners do not increase security. All they do is deter people from flying. Also, TSA has not stopped a single terrorist in 10 years.
Deadly terrorists existed long before 9/11... we were just more calm about it.
It's tough to draw the line between security and invasion of privacy, but touching my genitals and porno x ray machines are a good place to start!
I have been shocked by the ways airport security has become invasive and dehumanizing over the last nine years. Many of the changes to airport screening have not materially improved airport security; they certainly have not decreased the society-wide risk of terrorism. Instead, they have aggravated, humiliated, and worst of all dehumanized us. We risk becoming a society which expects nothing other than waiting in lines, presenting our papers, and being brutally searched for contraband. This is America, and it is long past time to remember the Constitution that originally defined what that means.
This is a clear and blatant violation of a person's rights, demeaning, and incredibly triggering to victims of sexual abuse. These procedures are not going to secure flights, but rather violate the privacy and rights of American citizens.
Stop this abuse now... before it becomes accepted by the masses!!!
I believe that the federal government is over stepping its boundaries. It does as it pleases with no morals and no respect for the American people. There once was a document called the BILL OF RIGHTS.
I will not fly until the naked body scanners and the enhanced pat downs are stopped; I will tell my family and friends not to fly as well
If you opt out and feel sexually harassed by the enhanced pat down, make sure to tell the TSA agent; the TSA has sexual harassment guidelines concerning customers.
This is ridiculous, surely there is a better option that can save people emberassment and not cause such an uproar. You should be ashamed of yourself: Allowing terrorists to shape our country is out of line. Don't you see they are winning by forcing us to place these initiatives in place? I will not be flying anytime in the future, not so long as these standards are in place. You have no right to assign people to grope me, my family, friends, or any of my loved ones. You will not have that luxury of groping me, I don't care what the reason is. You will not subject me to xray scans either. I have worked in a clinic doing xrays before, I am aware of the dangers of xray waves. You think you have the right to decide what is in the public's best interest? I am done with this, if I continue I will start to become irrational and start using harsh language. Have a nice day "big sis".
You force us to waive our rights because you know we HAVE to fly. We now have "no choice" choices. Complaints to the TSA about their horrible, rude, humiliating treatment are ignored or ridiculed. Each time i fly, some TSA goon yells at me or another citizen for not obeying some command fast enough, sitting on the wrong chair, asking an innocent question, having the nerve to be old or sick, etc. How long will we stand for this?
We should not have to give up our rights to be able to travel.
I refuse to fly until this bullSHIT is done with. I'd rather walk to LAX than ever fly again.
If it wasn't the government that was doing these things, they would be illegal.
Do not treat us like criminals.
I have stopped flying within the US until these disgusting policies are ended.The TSA is a bunch of sex perverts.
I used to fly on commercial planes a few years back. Now our company only uses private jets for business travel. Our problem seems to be the private fight attendants grabbing our 'junk'.
The utter, humiliating behavior of the TSA must stop. The stats say airplanes are more safe than automobiles and trains. Airplanes have stayed safer WITHOUT these new invasive procedures.
This is nothing short of governmental tyrannny.
Abolish the TSA, and get Janet Napolitano out of the DHS.
I will not fly until common sense is restored.
Electronic strip-search or random groping? If the bad guys get as close as the checkpoint WE'RE ALREADY HOSED! More LE work to catch the vermin in their spider-holes and less molesting of passengers, please.
As others have said, I will not be flying while these invasive, unethical and unconstitutional searches are in place.
I quit flying when I was forced to remove my belt and shoes in order to catch my flight. I refuse to be treated as a criminal without just cause. The TSA is a fraud and anyone who submits themselves to their out-of-control, so-called "security measures" is a part of the problem.
The whole process is directed at a large number of incompetents keeping their jobs from Janet Napolitano down to the lowest groper.
Will no fly until this ends.
There HAS to be an alternative
The TSA is a outrageous waste of my tax money. Somewhere, Bin Laden is laughing.
I don't understand why our personal freedoms have to be violated just to travel. I do not have to do give up these freedoms in any other mode of transportation, so why should I give them up to fly?
The line has been crossed. At some point we have to stand up and say enough!
There is no good reason to enforce ridiculous security theater. It's wasteful and disrecpectful.
The scanners are the straw that broke the camel's back. I am too old to go through the TSA-stress and have to cut down on flying.
I will not fly with my family until the invasive pat down procedures for opt-out's stop.
Call your congressman and senator today. The answer to this abuse of your rights is not to give up your freedom to travel, but rather, to regain control of this government gone wild.
This is about the government asserting more control over the American public. It has nothing to do with protecting us from terrorist threats.
I will not fly on US arilines until reasonable non-invasive security procedures are put in place. I fly over 15 flights a year and we all need to stand up and get in the opt out line and shut the airlines down as TSA is out of control.
Abolish the TSA.
This civil rights incursion is more evidence that the enemies of the US are winning. Our government violates our own Constitution in the name of security.
Nobody has the right to touch me without my permission. This is an outrage.
I will be driving until my privacy is restored.
This is sexual assault, plain and simple. I will not fly again until I can do so without giving up my right not to be assaulted.
Thanks to the TSA, I now have now had to make the choice to drive my family 1600 miles for the holidays rather than take a 3 hour flight to avoid molestation, even though the flight, without any security screening, would still be safer than driving.
As a survivor of sexual assault, I don't believe I should have to choose between the threat of sexual harassment and the threat of sexual assault. I cannot bring myself to fly under these conditions, despite the fact that I will not be able to see my family.
This is a farce. This only gives the illusion that we are safe when we fly. Quite wasting money and resources on this facade and do something that will really help the security of this country and close the borders!
I will not be sexually assaulted by the people meant to protect me.
Time to boost the GA industry and fly ourselves hassle free!
Bring back the Constitution of The United States!
As a rape survivor the last thing I want to happen before going on vactaion is to get triggered.
Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither.
The TSA has gone too far in the name of 'safety'. I refuse to be sexually violated by a scanner or a pat down. I am an upstanding citizen that will not be treated like a criminal. I definitely will NOT fly until this issue is resolved.
"Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither."
Will not fly until the incompetents running this side-show are replaced by an agency with multiple layers of oversight to prevent abuses.
Please be reminded that government exists to serve the needs of the people and not the reverse.
Stop violating my rights and my Constitution.
Please stop this harrassment.
I will not subject my daughter to this.
It should be "power to the people", not "ridiculous power to a few select people."
I'm disgusted by the new TSA regulations, this is WAY too intrusive!
This policy is not Constitutional. The Fourth Amendment states: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
No scanners, no pat downs!
I should be stripped by a machine with possible ill effects on my health, or felt up by a stranger? No Way.
This is outrageous. I will not let anyone but my husband and my doctor see my naked body as a free woman. Is this America? Or is this Orwell 1984?!?
I refuse to be subjected to this on the grounds of mystified "safety" concerns.
I made it to adulthood without being molested. So why would I pay the airlines to be groped by a lowpaid governemt employee?
The TSA has not caught even 1 terrorist in its almost 10 years of existence. The only line of defense we have had with the "shoe bomber" and "underwear bomber" were the passengers on the planes who took action.
Act now to preserve what little rights we have left. Not just for us, but for future generations.
I do not consent to the TSA's agenda of "security theater as replacement for actual security." Ban the porn machine.
I have rights, whether you choose to believe it or not.
It's important to also know the TSA position on this matter regarding the 4th amendment. Search for "amendment" on this page: http://www.tsa.gov/what_we_do/optout/spp_faqs.shtm
Sexual assault in airports part of a 'normal' procedure? Seriously, USA, take a better look. This is a major violation of my personal rights.
I will not fly until these are gone.
The government should not be able to do in public to me what my girlfriend would be fined for doing to me in public. Namely, feeling me up.
If they touch my junk they should be arrested
no way am i gonig into an airport
I can not imagine subjecting my wife and two young children to this sexual assault. We will be driving until this is changed.
In addition to the concerns detailed in this petition, my experience with airports using this device is that it is absurdly slow, and results in long, slow-moving lines where there wouldn't ordinarily be.
How does humiliation make us safer?
Clearly their methods are not working if terrorists are still getting through!
I am a US expat living in Australia since 1996. My parents, who remain living in the USA, are elderly- and I expect to have to visit them sometime in the near future. I haven't been on an international flight since 1999. I cannot conceive of having to choose between seeing my parents one last time and being either sexually assaulted, photographed naked and/or exposed to ionising radiation by backscatter body scanners. Being an airline passenger is NOT probable cause for invasive searches. I'll happily walk through a metal detector but I will NOT tolerate anything more invasive. Stop this madness NOW.
Employing people who know how to think like terrorists, or checking the contents of every shipped box or piece of luggage, yes. This? This is disgustingly invasive, not to mention insultingly inefficient.
I will not fly until these machines are gone. Even more, I will not fly until our proper rights have been restored.
Driving is more enjoyable anyways.
The scanners are not proven safe and would not have caught the underwear bomber. The patdowns are little more that sexual assault. THESE PRACTICES NEED TO END.
Cancer has been linked to excessive exposure to Xrays it is unconscionable to force people to pass through these scanners.
I too refuse to submit to unreasonable searches of my person. The airlines will not see so much as a penny from me until this policy is rescinded. I'm willing to drive, take trains, ride buses, motorcycles, bicycles or walk as necessary for my travel requirements. Americans, stand up for your rights, quit being such quivering sheep!
I am more than happy to go through metal detector or have a "light" pat down. But I will not allow ANY government branch or official (unless it is a licensed medical physician) to view my body or feel my genitals in any form. In any other sense this would be considered Sexual Assault and I will not be subjected to such so help me god. I am not a prisoner nor will I be treated as one. Israel doesn't need these machines in their international airport, and they have the best security on earth. TSA agents need to be better trained.
Those who trade liberty for security... I'd prefer liberty.
TSA is doing this with the full cooperation of the airlines. Make the airlines suffer, by boycotting them, and they will make TSA stop!
As a young woman I will NOT allow anyone of any "authority" to give me a full body "pat down" just to visit my family, nor will I allow any machine to take an x-ray picture which will be kept on file. My body belongs to me, not the government!!
I will not fly until these scanners are removed and the searches are halted. Invest in the sniffer machines. They actually work.
I am not willing to sacrifice my personal freedom for a system that hasn't done one thing to make travel safer.
I am a pilot, and this offends me on behalf of everyone who flies.
Enough is enough.
The only way I will go through one of these scanners is if I am provided with the full name and home address of the TSO manning the scanner screen, the full name and home address of that TSO's immediate supervisor, and a slightly blurry full-length nude photo of both of them. There will of course be no guarantee they won't be posted publicly. They have no business making demands on me that they wouldn't be willing to comply with.
Fuck you TSA. You've made flying unbearable.
This is a total invasion of our privacy. This entirely makes me reconsider flying entirely until this is no longer an option.
I will not submit to unreasonable searches - period.
Please end the pointless security theater. Everyone invloved knows its a waste of time, money and resources.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -- Benjamin Franklin
We need our rights back. Choice to fly should not equal choice to be humiliated or debased.
1)The moratorium should also include Millimeter Wave Technology scanners.
2)What about a one-day "NO FLY" Protest, where the goal is for as many people as possible not to fly on a specific date?
this procedure is disgraceful.....
I will not fly again until these unconstitutional acts cease. I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, groped, irradiated, or numbered. I am a person. My life is my own.
Either let me freely walk naked into an airport or stop the scans.
I will NOT be flying until these machines and pat downs are no longer part of the process. Either option is an unreasonable search by an agency of the government.
I have cancelled my travel plans for Thanksgiving and until I know I can fly without my privacy being violated, I will not fly.
I will not be flying until these policies are revoked. What the TSA is doing is beyond horrible.
This over obsession about safety has totally discouraged me from flying ever again. I appreciate security, but this is going too far!
What would they do if everyone opted out?
Groping is awful. But cancer is much much worse.
This security theater must end.
I am not guilty until proven innocent. I will not fly until these measures are repealed.
I repeat again what S. Greathouse quoted "Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master." - President George Washington
These new scanners do little to enhance security and will be ineffective at stopping those determined to cause harm.
They subject all who fly to a gross violation of privacy, an unreasonable, invasive search and unknown health effects over the long-term.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. -Ben Franklin.
Although in this case, it is merely the illusion of safety.
stop wasting our tax money and do something right! Plain stupid!
Stop violating our dignity! We are upstanding citizens flying for our jobs, and to see our families-these unreasonable searches do not deter real terrorists, they violate US!
And please stop 'randomly' selecting my Dutch husband to be searched. If he wanted to blow up a plane I'm sure he'd plant the bomb on his American wife who isn't getting extra screening.. DUH?
A family with small children visiting other family is hardly a threat ok?
I do not want to experience higher levels of radiation, or the shame and embarrassment of being groped by a stranger. Considering how triggering that feeling can be of survivors of sexual assault, I cannot believe that this is even being considered. I can't imagine TSA employees really want to assault several hundred people a day, either. Dignity is stripped from everyone with these measures in place.
Buying an airline ticket does not mean you give up your 4th Amendment rights. I hope everyone opts out.
Give us back out rights. If this is what we demand, how can a government by the people take them away?
How has this country gone so far off the deep end that now the following scene from Airplane II: The Sequel is REALITY now:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F5zuhjl5sF4
All other valid arguments aside - we've just lost. Is it possible for 310,713,976 people to all *facepalm* at the same time?
The world is laughing at us!
The implementation of the backscatter x-ray machines and enhanced pat-downs is completely outrageous. It breaks the heart to see the land of the free being subjected to a government agency driven by fear.
Please, on behalf of the nation, and as a therapist who works to help heal people who have been sexually molested, stop the pat downs and excessive X-ray machine use and LEARN FROM THE COUNTRY OF ISRAEL. Profile and question. Keep security high and still protect our privacy!
It is easy for a person that does not have to abide by these restrictions to stand by them. If you feel they are necessary please start to profile, airlines have done it for years, poeple and you will see the same results.
Never thought U.S. "security" would be more invasive than that of China. "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." (Ben Franklin)
I'm not against security but this is not the best, or only, solution. For instance, I'd be more than happy to change out of my "street" clothes to wear TSA approved flying attire if that were such an option.
Hey TSA, how many terrorists have you caught at your security checkpoints?
Consider the words of Benjamin Franklin, "Those who would sacrifice freedom for security deserve neither."
The backscatter x-ray, "pat downs", and strip searches are a gross violation of our 4th amendment rights.
Blatantly unconstitutional and just plain inhumane.
This is just another way that the federal government stomps on our rights and liberties for the supposed "War on Terror"
Stop sexually assaulting me while exercising my RIGHT to travel!
this is the TSA overstepping their boundaries... where does it end? I wouldn't be as upset if this was actually the right kind of technology for finding the kind of weapons/devices we are currently dealing with, but it's not.
Fewer do-nothing theatrics, please. I'd like to not be assaulted if I ever choose to fly.
I agree that these issues violate my constitutional rights.
Screw TSA
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
I will never get another airplane until these invasive security measures are rescinded.
If the airlines won't put a stop to the molestation of their customers, the can all go bankrupt, as far as I'm concerned. I'll drive, thank you very much.
We are tired of our privacy and personal rights being taken away !!!
The TSA has gone to far, we refuse to fly until things change !!!
The TSA is not finding the persons they need to find, they are just humiliating and embarrass the average person.
I wouldn't want this done to my mother or my wife or my niece and nephew so it shouldn't be done to anyone.
These measures are completely invasive and unnecessary. I'm sure given the choice, a vast majority of passengers would rather take the risk than be subjected to this.
You know that this is not right.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
if such a blatant invasion of privacy is allowed, this certainly sets a very dangerous precedent going into the future.
Envision a future where everyone is required to go through these x-ray machines before entering an Federal building or major transit system of any kind.
This behavior is NOT acceptable. Our government is supposed to work for us, let's remind them of that.
I hate to travel because of the TSA.
Ben Franklin would be ashamed of this country
www.InfoWars.com and www.WeWontFly.com and www.AbortionNo.org
the only thing exceedingly invasive TSA procedures are able to stop is my ability to arrive at the gate on time.
I do not want to have to feel sexually harassed because I want to travel home to DC to see my family. I'm not flying until something is done about this.
I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.
I will not subject myself to an irrational, unconstitutional, and disgusting display of fearmongering. I do not have to fly. It is a luxury. I will do without it as long as these appalling measures are in place.
This is illegal and must stop.
I will never allow myself to be subjected to one of these searches.
These searches are clearly over the "reasonable" line.
This is disgusting. I have basically stopped flying. The airline industry should be lobbying against it.
Terrorists have already won. They're laughing at the abuse we put up with in our daily lives because of them.
I believe recent TSA screening policies violate privacy, do little to prevent terrorism, and cost our society dollars, time, and liberty.
Will no longer fly until the scanners are removed.
Myself and family will not be flying this holiday season or any other until these procedures are discontinued.
We all need to petition our recently elected {or re-elected} politicians and government officials to stop this nonsense. Secure the cockpits with double steel doors that cannot be opened, and the hijacking issue is solved. Metal detectors and non-genital external pat-downs of occasional passengers is as far as TSA should ever go. Remember we pay them! We all need to fight back for our rights!!!! Plus, terrorists aren't likely to use aircraft as a weapon again anyway, unfortunately I'm sure they will find something else.
I will not fly until this disgusting invasion of privacy is dismissed.
The fact that I fly the plane and have been through a background check to get this job isn't enough for me not to have to be treated to additional radiation besides that I encounter at 35 000 feet. I think it is ridiculous that pilots should have to go through this machine or go through the pat down if you opt out. We are on duty flying the plane.
I'm outraged.
TSA employees have talked about the procedures of the enhanced patdown as being designed to coerce most people into walking into the AIT scanners. (Read Jeffrey Goldberg's story "For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance" in the Atlantic, for example.) AIT and the patdown are both invasive and ineffective. Is the TSA trying to bankrupt the airline industry? Don't they realize that when people stop flying, they'll have no one left to search?
My family and I will not be flying until this policy is revoked.
I am against sanctioned molestation.
will opt out of xray..will not be scared down by groping hands
At this point the government has overstepped its boundaries to the point of sexual molestation while trying to fly is perfectly okay in fact its the LAW now. We have to come together to fight this Big Government to make them realize that we the people will not tolerate this anymore. Government to a degree is great. When they start overstepping basic civil liberties we have to stand up and firmly state that we will not stand for this!
I refuse to choose between dangerous radiation and sexual assault just to board a fly.
STOP
I shouldn't have to choose what form my sexual assault comes in if I want to fly. Parents shouldn't have to choose it for their children either. Ban this invasive, immoral procedure.
When will we stop being sheep and stand up to this tyranny? The line is drawn here!
Why are you asking for my age? WTF?????????????????????????
I teach my daughter not to let anyone touch her body without her permission. Really, Uncle Sam? Must I amend this to include any holier-than-thou jerk in an airport with a superiority complex?
I want the constitution to be respected.
I will no longer fly commercial airlines domestically and will fly non-U.S.A. flagged carriers for my overseas travels.
TSA provides the illusion of security... nothing more.
My choosing to travel by air is not my implicit consent to be molested.
Please stop eroding our 4th amendment rights. They're rights for a reason, you shouldn't be allowed to just arbitrarily decide to take them away.
Thank you for this
There are no words for how depraved and unnecessary these machines are. The TSA has truly become the iconic despised police unit of our time: unaccountable, brutal, stupid.
I understand we need to protect our security, but I'm fairly certain that bomb sniffing dog's cost less and produce better results then these new screening methods
II do not feel safe, I feel insulted and violated. I am not a threat to anyone and resent being treated like a suspect. STOP this nonsense! Americans deserve better.
I will not submit my 16 month old child to un-needed radiation or groping from a government agent for a false sense of security for others...
It's bad enough passengers are subjected to this, but crew members are also now molested on there way to work!
Hey. We dirty old men can save the country a lot of money. We'll do it for nothing!
Respect the 4th amendment.
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety. -BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
I will not fly until the sexual assault is stopped!!!
I am utterly outraged about the use of full body scanners.
As a frequent flier I am being forced to either pose for naked pictures and incur dangerous radiation several times a month or be sexually assaulted if I want to board an aircraft to do my job.
If I take my wife and kids on vacation I have to let some person off the street view and keep pornographic pictures of them or consent to have them molested.
I doubt that any politician or TSA higher up or any airline exec would put themselves, their wives or their children through this utterly violating process.
I WILL BE FLYING AS LITTLE AS POSSIBLE AS LONG AS THIS GOES ON.
..and will consider filing a criminal complaint against any TSA employee who gropes or otherwise sexually molests or assaults myself or my family.
My children and I will not be flying into any airports that utilize these machines. We will resort to alternative and more private methods of transportation if necessary to enjoy what the world has to offer us.
Simply outrageous this practice. And are they scanning our motor vehicles too when entering the USA from Canada?
A good deal of tyranny goes by the name of protection.
The rights of the few should never be trumped by the security of the many.
Please refrain from "protecting" my rights by removing them.
I am all for security, but this is an invasion of privacy and I will not see my daughter, or other modest women subjected to this kind of violation. You impede on religious conviction and general sense of privacy that many hold dear as Americans.
Molesting children should not be part of a job description.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.-Benjamin Franklin
I'm flying, not visiting the state prison. And, by the way, I've been flying for OVER 50 YEARS - BEFORE THERE WERE JETS. If you, the government, don't know who the long time and regular fliers are, it is the government's fault. Don't burden me with your incompetence.
I will not go through one of these scanner for health and privacy reasons.
The machines also do not make us any safer - we're succumbing to security theatre instead of doing real security work. Rafi Sela, the president of AR Challenges, a global transportation security consultancy that has worked with the RCMP, the U.S. Navy Seals and airports around the world, on Israeli security:
"'First, it's fast — there's almost no line. That's because they're not looking for liquids, they're not looking at your shoes. They're not looking for everything they look for in North America. They just look at you,' said Sela. 'Even today with the heightened security in North America, they will check your items to death. But they will never look at you, at how you behave. They will never look into your eyes and that's how you figure out the bad guys from the good guys.'" That's the process — six layers, four hard, two soft. The goal at Ben-Gurion is to move fliers from the parking lot to the airport lounge in a maximum of 25 minutes."
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
The TSA treats us like prisoners. I love visiting the US, but now I hate traveling in it. Please restore civility to your airports.
My life isn't worth living when I've compromised what I believe in. This isn't what our country was founded on. Don't pretend that human life is sacred when we send men and women in to pointless wars and use them as disposable pawns. It's not about safety. No one can ever be completely safe. It's about taking away people's civil rights and freedom.
The person in front of me kept making the metal detector go off and so I was swept toward the X-ray machine. Since I wasn't really interested in a stranger seeing me naked I opted out and was then subject to a full grope. I requested a specific TSA agent I had been talking to and felt comfortable with and was denied. I really wish I hadn't agreed to it. I feel violated now. How is this legal and going unquestioned?
Please give us the choice to die with liberty, than live with this tyranny.
These machines also are creating child porn.
The TSA is a bunch of thug perverts and sexual predators ! You're using my tax money for this outrage ? !
In particular, it is the "lack of knowledge" that concerns me— the possibility of long-term ill effects.
I have a flight booked in december. This makes me really nervous.
I will refuse to fly again except under the most urgent circumstances until these illegal and infernal searches are ceased.
This sort of "security" at the cost of passenger's mental security is uncalled for. I won't be flying until it's scrapped.
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
I'm not going to fly.
From reading the news of late it is hard to tell that we live in a country that used to be free. I would rather chance death in a "terrorist" attack than have my liberties stripped away and live in fear.
We should not let the bad action of one person turn us all into suspects. Security is important but so is dignity. These policies are important and they set a precedent of how we would be treated in other realms of society.
Unfathomable.
I will do whatever I can to avoid flying until these machines are removed.
It is imperative that we draw the line here, or cavity searches are next.
This is completely outrageous. Where have our liberties gone?
It is unethical and unacceptable for a government agency to behave in such a grossly invasive manner. National security is important, yes, but so is my personal security, and I refuse to submit to an act that is against the Constitution of the United States of America whether it is attempted by an agency associated with the government or not. Please return to a logical system of checks and balances instead of violating my body and my freedoms.
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
This has just gotten so ridiculous, these procedures aren't making us safer and are obscene.
Why have you let the terrorists win? The terrorists have successfully destroyed air travel in the US. We are better than these obvious violations of privacy and the US Constitution.
Any agents of the state who touch me will be charged with assaulting a disabled veteran (a federal offense). Any agents of the state who touch my wife or child will be assaulted by me, and then charged.
I've been traveling at least 2-4 times a month for the past 12 years. The last 5 years I've traveled the same flights & route twice a month. Yet I'm still treated like a criminal at EVERY flight. If you're going to implement this gross invasion of privacy, at least operate some kind of CLEAR initiative for those of us who have to go through it every week.
This security theater is not helping anyone.
No flying until this is done away with. If that means I never fly again, I'll live. Not when the skies are so darn unfriendly.
I find it absolutely deplorable that the government would suggest that either the naked pictures of myself and my child or patting us down is anything short of molestation and a gross violation of our rights.
Stop this ridiculous invasion of our privacy.
There is NO way that I'm going to pay for an airline ticket in order to be treated like a criminal. FORGET it! The only people happy about this are the ones making $$$ from the scanners.
These policies were put in place on the possibility that they might save American lives. The fact is that thousands of American service men and women have already died protecting the rights that the TSA has taken from us. Not only is the total disregard for our human rights unacceptable, but so to is the disregard for the sacrifices made by the members of our military.
Ben Franklin was right!
Risking our health is wrong... not matter what your experts say. Also, that pat down borders on actual sexual assualt in my opinion. The American people ask you to do what you MUST know in your heart is right. A soldier said something very poignant to me. He said, everytime people give up their RIGHTS, it's a slap in the face to every soldier that has sacrificed to defend them! I couldn't agree more.
I want my America back and you are taking us further away from that goal!
Each year I fly more than 100,000 miles. Repeated X-rays (full body scans) can serve no logical purpose. I pose no threat to anyone yet I am treated as a criminal each time I choose to fly somewhere. What has become of our rights and our government?
Enough is enough. If this doesn't stop, expect the people to rise up and reclaim their rights through any means necessary. You are NOT deterring terrorists by stealing away every last shred of privacy.
The terrorists have won. The TSA now holds me hostage to its fears, whether I choose to fear or not. Isn't that exactly what the terrorists want? I am ashamed of my country for the first time in my life.
This goes against the will of the people you are trying to protect.
Our family of 5 will not be flying until this ridiculous screening is put to an end. At what point did I agree to give up my rights when I choose flying as a mode of transportation across the country? I will NOT subject myself or my young children to a potentially hazardous screening machine OR to being groped by strangers in order to fly.
Malo Periculosam Libertatem Quam Quietum Servitium ("I prefer liberty with danger to peace with slavery").
I want secure air as well. Follow Israeli procedures, not Hugh Heffner's procedures!
I will drive 3,000 miles rather than allow anyone to photograph my children naked or feel them up.
I urge you to honor the request of We the People, for whom you work. We Will stand together against this violation. Thankyou for your attention to this imperative issue of personal rights and freedoms.
As a commercial airline pilot, I must say the TSA is completely out of control and must be stopped before our civil liberties are lost permanently.
This is terrifying to me. It needs to be removed.
"Those that would sacrifice freedom for security deserve neither." Ben Franklin
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
The terrorists and those that wish us harm have won when the TSA and the powers that be decide to fight the war on terror by waging an assault on the American people by stripping them of their rights.
Our founding fathers are surely turning in their graves.
Very sad to say the least.
I need to fly with my kids to see my family. However, if I have to choose which indignity to subject my kids to, I will choose neither and accept the consequences.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
- Benjamin Franklin
I am a Mom of two military sons, both stationed on the East Coast, who travels frequently from Colorado to visit them. Unfortunately, I am now forced to seriously reconsider my routine trips to Camp Lejeune and Oceans NAS, due to the thoroughly degrading and unconstitutional new security procedures which have been implemented by TSA.
Will not fly until these policies are revised.
I will not be molested, nor allow my family to be molested or exposed to unnecessary radiation by anyone. Has my government forgotten that I have lent them my authority in a sacred trust which is all too often violated?
The TSA's new procedures are unreasonable.
I believe that the TSA will go down in US history as the biggest waste of taxpayer dollars in history. And that's really saying something since our government has been pretty wasteful.
they haven't caught any of the 911 terrorists yet. let's throw money where it's really needed
Its an invasion of privacy, and health hazard. Someone please sue the TSA for 4th amendment infringement.
We're not even 100% sure that the radiation from the backscatter scanners are safe for our bodies and yet we are being subjected to something potentially hazardous. We do not deserve to be treated like animals in order to fly.
I am canceling my flight to Florida in February and instead driving the 2200 mile round trip for a planned vacation. I encourage everyone else to do the same until these measures change.
The new scanners and the "optional" crotch-grabbing procedure are a humiliating invasion of privacy for every air traveler. The TSA feels the only way to protect the United States is to punish its citizens by subjecting them to these procedures. What will they have us do next? Walk naked from the ticket counter to the jet way? I agree we need security, but bombarding us with radiation or feeling up every traveler is only going to piss off the very people you are trying to protect.
Treating everyone like a terrorist is WRONG!
Individual "pat-downs" are a violation of an individual's rights to safety. Many people are survivors of sexual violence and these "pat-downs" are triggering and can be emotionally damaging in the short- and long-term.
These new regulations are a gross violation of our privacy and freedom. Also they do not add any additional security measures or prevent possible terrorist actions from occurring.
Furthermore, this new imaging system, to be used on women and children leaves a lot of possibilites to be abused. Are the TSA screeners checked to see if they are Registered Sex Offenders?
Furthermore, I'd like to hear how the Airlines are going to respond to these scanners. Likely this will just deter people from flying altogether and hurt the travel industry, and push our economy further into a recession.
Me and 11 other people who were going to CES just after Christmas cancelled our flights. You will not see a dime until this madness stops.
I'm sick of this. The US is becoming everything we have stood against. The TSA's polices are ridiculous and don't make anyone safer. If you're trying to stop people at the gate, you've lost already.
I think it is wrong that we are asking people to be viewed naked thru X-ray and if we decide to not go thru a TSA agent gets to feel us up. How do we explain to our children that its not ok for an adult to touch us in private parts but its ok if they are at the airport?? And how do we know that the TSA Agent doesn't have a sexual offender background?
As a young woman, this feels invasive, unhealthy, irresponsible and it sure as hell doesn't make me feel any more secure. Please get rid of this highly offensive tactic. Find safer ways to screen passengers.
Families everywhere are scared to fly now. Not because of terrorists, but because of the TSA. These scanners and pat-downs must be stopped.
Enough is enough. There's safety and then there's abuse of power
I unfortunately was subjected to a hi resolution body scan before I know exactly how much the screeners were able to see. This is a disgusting invasion of privacy, and I will not submit to another scan.
Contents of emails sent to various senators for the upcoming Transportation Security Administration Oversight Hearing
---
Dear Senator:
To quote one of our founding fathers, "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin.
The situation with the TSA vs. the traveling public has become intolerable. The onerous, invasive and dangerous precedents being set today, all in the name of safety, will provide none such safety and deprives citizens of this nation their guaranteed rights under the fourth amendment.
The fact that these new backscatter machines are not considered safe by a host of experts yet are being deployed across the nation shows just how powerful lobbysits are in shaping public policy at the expense of our consititution and the citizens it is supposed to protect.
These machines have many names, but should ultimately just be called sex-ray since it shows a fairly accurate depiction of the subject's naked body. Although the TSA claims that no data is stored (read: imagery) our US Marshall Services has already claimed they have kept said data.
Ultimately, however, these machines offer nothing that a trained professional could not spot. If someone is so committed to blowing up a plane, they could defeat this machine by simply hiding the explosives in their anus, vagina or other body cavity. A trained security professional, using the proper interviewing techniques like our friends in Israel, would be able to spot the tell tale signs of a potential threat.
Furthermore, these new physical searches, for those that choose to opt-out of the backscatter machines, are tantamount to governmental sanctioned sexual assault. Are we now a government like Sudan that uses sexual assault and humiliation to enforce some msiguided doctrine in order to line the pockets of fat-cat lobbyists and their corporate patrons?
The biggest insult, however, to the American people is that these assaults are now appoved on children. What kind of message are we sending to our most vulnerable citizens when we claim, as a people, that as long as an adult is wearing a TSA badge it's OK for them to grope your genitals? How can we as a people accept this affront? Generations of parents before me have had "that" talk with our children on what is acceptable and unacceptable touching from strangers, yet here we are with a governmental-sanctioned child molestation.
As a husband and a parent you can be certain that I will never let my wife or child be subjected to such a clear and present violation of our rights afforded to us by our constitution. Until some reason returns to the travel industry I will no longer use air travel, which is quite a statement since I am in the destination tourism business.
I beg you to stand up as a voice of reason in this matter at the Senate Subcommittee on Aviation Operations, Safety, and Security hearing on the Transportation Security Administration Oversight. I urge you to do what is right for the American people and stop these assaults on our freedoms and the very constitution.
best,
mg
He who would trade liberty for some temporary security, deserves neither liberty nor security.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
I will absolutely not fly until these scans are halted and all detectors removed from airports immediately.
I pray I never have to see these scanners, and have to resort to a pat down where people might touch me in intimate locations... just so I can "protect my privacy" (by having it further impeded on?!)
The recent changes do very little to increase security. They simply violate the constitution, violate our privacy, and endanger our health.
REMOVE THE SCANNERS!
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
I will not subject my family to naked scans.
I will not sacrifice personal rights for the illusion of safety.
If Israel doesn't need it, neither do we. TSA will not touch my kids, or see beneath their clothing.
I think we need to look to Israel for how they run security... They do a much better job than we do!
I will not be flying again until our rights are routinely violated all in the name of a false sense of security.
The new TSA regime has been a knee-jerk reaction to 9/11 and does nothing to make anyone safer.
When flying with my children, I now have a choice between subjecting them to radiation or having them molested by a stranger. Ridiculous.
Don't treat me like a criminal when you're the ones who belong in prison.
Legalizing and requiring sexual assault is essentially what you are doing to all of those who have been traumatized in the past! You are perpetuating their victimization and it is appalling.
I will not raise my children to fear their government more than terrorists.
As a US Sailor I find it deplorable that my sacrifices for the freedom and protection of the American people are so easily thwarted- by our own agencies. I hope I am asked to be scanned when I fly in my uniform- I look forward to defending myself.
Buying train tickets instead of plane tickets.
Security theater, plain and simple. The simple act of purchasing an airline ticket to exercise my rights of freedom of movement should never imply consent to the forfeiture of my 4th Amendment rights. Ever.
These searches are obscene, help no one, and have never caught a terrorist. Shameful.
The attitude of the TSA top to bottom shows how the terrorist have already won.
Stop, thanks.
What happens when some idiot sticks a bomb inside their rear? Cavity searches for all?
It's time to reduce the level of paranoia. Think smarter.
TSA should be replaced with the hundreds of thousands military personnel across the globe; just like EVERY other country across the globe. Eliminates wasteful spending
The TSA has never caught a terrorist. The fact that we are subjecting our own citizens to this treatment shows the terrorists are winning.
"Those who surrender freedom for security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one."
— Thomas Jefferson
This policy needs to go. Unbelievable. Where is the proof that this works? And where will the line be drawn after this? I'm modifying my personal and business plans to not fly if possible until this is repealed.
I will stand with the rest of the undersigned against flying until this madness is halted.
What ever happened to our rights?
The system in place does not make us more secure, it just makes security lines more interesting attack targets. The FBI and the CIA are doing better detecting threats before they get to the terminal, cockpit doors are locked, and passengers are more aware and will fight back. Security theater at the terminal is not helping. Groping pregnant women and 3 year olds is not helping.
I have never been stressed about flying. Now I have to decide whether I want to be seen naked by a stranger or groped by one. This is unacceptable.
I'm not looking forward to flying for the holidays. If TSA has to pat down my 3 year old daughter I'll cry. You are not making me feel safe.
The TSA is out of control. I'm sick of being undressed, prodded, delayed and exposed to X-rays. We aren't any safer, our civil liberties are just being raped.
We shouldn't have to give up any rights when we fly. I plan to not take any more trips until this policy is changed. The TSA is pure security theater that doesn't make us any safer. Look at how Israel does it and they have far more security concerns.
I recommend the TSA take a look at what Israel and Germany do for their airline and airport security. I never feel safer than when flying through Germany.
Get the Govt off our backs!! I refuse to fly with Big brother watching.
I consider the TSA's behavior to be blatantly abusive. It's unconstitutional and #TSAbuse must stop.
Over the line!
hose who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin
Stop the Security Theater; it does nothing to increase security and everything to invade the privacy of every passenger...
boycott flying until these practices are stopped.
I won't vacation in the states until this is changed
There should be no "constitution free" zones
"The US is becoming everything we have stood against."
The TSA does not provide security. It simply provides the illusion of security. It's security theatre.
Won't be flying until they remove the machines and stop groping.
These devices and policies are a despicable breach of 4th amendment rights. Additionally, we look foolish compared to nations like Israel that have more imminent threats and are able to secure their air travel without the "security theatre" that we see here in the USA, and with a minimum of inconvenience to their citizens.
As an airline employee, I find these measures to be intrusive! Bomb sniffing dogs do a better job!
This is one more reason, and one huge reason, why I will always drive rather than fly when I travel. The airline industry will never get another dollar of my money until choosing to fly no longer means giving up my dignity and constitutional rights.
No amount of fear on your part warrants exposing me to potential carginogens. Keep your paranoia off my body!
I am appalled that anyone in the TSA thinks this sort of abuse is acceptable.
When we fear absurdly improbably attacks this much, the terrorists have by definition won.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
- Benjamin Franklin
It is bad enough that you are doing this to adults when it is a clear violation of their Fourth Amendment rights, but there is no excuse to do this to children. It is pedophilia and child pornography and it is a disgrace to our country.
We will not stand for security theater.
Please do not allow sexual assault to be institutionalized in our country. Nobody touches my children except my family and their doctor. Certainly not the TSA drones.
The TSA has grossly overstepped it's bounds. First, eliminate these invasive and unconstitutional searches, then eliminate the TSA. http://www.myvidster.com/video/600891/Video_of_TSA_Screener_Accosting_3_Year_Old_Child_at_Security_Checkpoint
This is tyranny, pure and simple.
As Ben Franklin said, "He who would trade liberty for some temporary security, deserves neither liberty nor security."
This is an egregious violation of our rights as US citizens, and it must be stopped immediately.
The scanners and groping make us no safer, cost millions, and rob us of our dignity and Constitutional rights.
This ridiculous increase in security theater has no real impact on improving our national security. The backscatter scanners present real health risk to passengers and especially to pilots, flight attendants, and even TSA agents who all work in constant interaction with the machines. And if anything, the additional "opt-out" pat downs only harbor TSA agent pedophiles and perverts looking to cop a feel or see people naked.
Our national security needs to take a cue from the Israelis airport security and look for actual _terrorists_ instead of searching and restricting people's goods and person in an attempt to find weapons.
As a father of two girls I am horrified that they would be treated in such a manor for the simple act of traveling by air. It is unacceptable that the TSA can do something to an American citizen that US military personnel cannot do to a member of the Taliban. How much freedom do we forfeit for a false sense of security? My family and I are staying home this Thanksgiving and Christmas.
The use of these machines, coupled with the highly unconstitutional "full body search" is a violation of everything the United States of America was founded upon. While I applaud the desire to take measures to avoid terrorism and ensure safe travel, there are better ways to prevent terrorism at 30,000 feet other than groping paying customers, no less by many people who may not even have a high school diploma, or any candor or courtesy.
Stop eroding my rights in the name of fighting terrorism.
I refuse to allow my family members to be molested or pedophile-grade photos be taken of them, so we will not be traveling until these horrific practices are stopped.
I am Canadian, but part of the GEOS program and frequently travel in and out of the US. The risk of 1 in 20 million of dying from radiation emitted from these machines, versus the 1 in 30 million chance of being blown up by a terrorist really has me questioning these particular security measures. If it doesn't decrease the odds of dying, then it's not a good thing.
The damn scanners are pricey and they don't even work!
Ask yourself one question: Are these security measures really helping, at all? Or do they just make you feel more powerful?
Stop compromising our freedoms in the name of poor security practices and do something -EFFECTIVE-.
I should not be required to make a decision between doing business with the USA and avoiding sexual harassment.
Perhaps we should arrest the operators of scanners who are looking at our children naked.
This is sickening: http://www.myvidster.com/video/600891/Video_of_TSA_Screener_Accosting_3_Year_Old_Child_at_Security_Checkpoint
At what point do we stop tolerating our freedoms and rights being abused? NOW, that's when.
I will not fly commercially until "enhanced" pat-downs and Backscatter X-Rays have been eliminated from all airports.
It’s gone way, way too far.
I've already cancelled trips because I don't believe the TSA is doing anything to actually provide safety or security. They are only making travelling difficult for the general public.
How about instead of groping the public or endangering them with x rays, you actually scan and secure the cargo that is being shipped on flights?
How about being a bit more human?
How is it that you constantly seem to out moron yourself? It's rather ridiculous really. The facade does not fool anyone.
The TSA needs to justify its existence or cease its existence.
It is unconscionable that such procedures, methods and devices would be employed on minors — that, alone, is enough reason to immediately cease their use.
Please make me proud to be a US citizen and cancel this lose/lose policy. It is OK to make a mistake as long you are willing to face up to the reality and correct the problem.
While the intention of greater security in airports is admirable, this is the wrong system. We should be focused on finding terrorists, not weapons.
4th Amendment, read it...
I will not fly again until these scanners are removed and less invasive techniques are used.
I have a wife and a 21-month-old son, and there is no way I will let either of them be put through the indignity of the back-scatter scanner or a pat down. We simply won't fly until these methods are gone.
"Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security." - Ben Franklin
Will not fly until the scanners and gropings have stopped.
As a male Sikh who wears a turban, I am routinely "randomly selected" for additional screening. Though I understand the need for additional security, at what point do we say enough is enough?
TSA screens are unconstitutional, easily breached, and nothing more than security theater.
I suspect that a reasonable and proactive protest to government is the most effective way to pull backscatter machines from airports. I think this petition is a great start.
I want my privacy back.
The comments from the TSA Secretary suggesting that travelers who do not like the new procedures find different transportation show the ridiculousness of the TSA administration.
Air travel is a required part of life for many working individuals, and these are precisely the people who are most at risk from this technology due to the frequency of their travel.
I plan to delay flying with my family until these machines are removed, and invasive searches are discontinued. I believe the current course of action is unconstitutional. Moreover, the search process sends conflicting signals to our children, whom we are teaching to raise alarm if adult strangers touch them.
The infringement of our privacy has signaled that the terrorists have won.
Congratulations, the terrorists have gotten the U.S. government to force every person who steps on a plane in this country to submit to an invasive body scan or to be patted down (including the groin area) by a government official. I would qualify that as them winning as they have significantly affected our way of life for the worse.
I'm not flying until this stupidity stops.
The TSA must be stopped. I am sick of people who make an hr. making the rules in this country. Thanks to them, the terrorists have already won.
Plus these scanners do NOT help anything, they just make money for the stock holders in the company that manufactures them. Now thats one list I wouldn't mind being on.
Unreasonable, abusive, and ineffective. Stop the TSA from abusing our dignity. Stop subjecting us to untested radiation. Stop wasting our tax money on security theater.
The biggest threat to our nation and freedom is not terrorists, but the continued erosion of our privacy and rights in the name of safety.
Veterans sacrificed for our freedom. Now we have to sacrifice our freedom and dignity when traveling. Thanks, TSA.
It's embarrassing that our country even let it come to this.
This government policy is appalling and an affront to human dignity.
We can do better than this in the United States.
The intrusive backscatter x-ray debacle smells of excessive government lobbying for profit, and it has made safety a lower priority. The x-ray dosage may be hundreds of times higher than stated (as the radiation is absorbed by skin rather than being diffused through the entire body). Furthermore, these are doing nothing to enhance security, would not have caught the "underwear bomber", and continue to present ripe targets for BOMBING - namely, the lengthy security line itself.
Take a hint from Israel, already.
I like the fourth amendment!
Security theatre is not security. We need to return to pre-9/11 levels of security and train in behavior profiling.
Of course passenger safety is the primary concern of the TSA and just about anyone who boards a plane, but the extremes to which we have taken the charge of protecting our flights are simply too far. Rather than focus on making flying safe, quick, and enjoyable, the TSA has followed a path that violates passengers' privacy and and is not especially effective. Thank you for bringing this matter to the attention of the public and those in charge, hopefully we will soon travel with dignity once again.
Scanners are nothing more than a symptom of the bigger problem.
I fly 100+ times a year.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
I certainly will not ever fly again until the ridiculous security theater the TSA has created is removed. They are not making us more safe, they are making everything worse.
Your search techniques are un-American and frankly will not keep us safe. Please implement security that actually has been proven to prevent terrorism, like what Israel uses.
I opted for one of the new pat-downs instead of a backscatter x-ray. Though I did not have an experience that was as harrowing or abusive as the ones we've all heard about by now, I think it's important to note that this search, even when performed promptly and courteously by a polite member of one's own gender, is humiliating and intrusive. I don't think my goverment should make me feel that way. It's difficult to say where the line is where protection and vigilance overstep into my freedom, but I think it's fair to say that my genitals represent one of those lines.
Flying today is miserable enough without enduring assault.
For the love of pete... Can we start with proper profiling?
I will not trade my actual security, freedom, dignity nor health for the illusion of safety. Other countries (such as Israel) have found ways to accomplish all these tasks, so it's possible. Lose the arrogance, and gain success and safety for American travelers.
Guilty until molested innocent.
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety
Not flying until this harassment stops
Please act now to stop unwarranted searches.
I, as a taxpayer, do not wish to fund the TSA's involvement with screening air travel passengers. They have continued to increase restrictions without merit, and they have now crossed a line.
Because part of the ticketing fees are used to pay for airport security, doesn't this constitute prostitution (transacting money in exchange for sexual touching) for all those that opt out?
Pretty soon we won't need the Megan's Law website to find sexual predators. All we'll have to do is visit our local airport where all the pedophiles will be waiting at the security checkpoint dressed as TSA agents to "pat down" our daughters and sons for the sake of national security.
I am concerned about the safety of my child both from poorly-tested X-Ray equipment and from unethical pat-downs. None of these activities are making us more secure, but rather invading our persons. Real security comes from trained personal profiling of every flyer and solid investigative police work *before* a potential terrorist ever enters the airport.
Absolutely appalling what people will allow in the name of "fighting terrorism". These hurt nobody but the average citizen.
Stop the nonsense TSA.
Because terrorists don't have body cavities, right?
It's time to take a long hard look at our security protocol an institute a truly risk-based system instead of falsely claiming that the one we have is in fact risk-based.
http://goo.gl/xn2g
Serious questions have been raised by knowledgeable people regarding the safety of the so-called "naked-body" scanners. To make matters worse, there is no evidence that either of these DEGRADING "options" (AIT scanning or the groping/molestation) do anything to make us more safe. Shame on you all!
The cost of this type of security in terms of dollar to purchase/operate/maintain and in terms of personal violations and hardships outweighs the threat that it is combating.
Already not a fan of flying nor the old-style security checkpoint protocols. I know it's no easy job but then the TSA needs to smarten up, modernize their methods & stop hiring fast-food employee rejects. Surely our safety can be ensured without molestation or risk to health.
Dude, where's my constitution?
I'm a frequent flyer and have contributed greatly to the economy of states other than my own. I will NOT be flying until some sanity and dignity has been restored to our broken security system.
I plan to opt out of both full body imaging and this 'enhanced' pat down. If my request isn't granted I will choose not to fly. These new 'security measures', in my opinion, are either pornographic or sexual assault.
Stop wasting our time and money on security theater. The real threats are defeated before the checkpoint - or in rare cases by marshals and passengers on board.
You want us to believe that the dose of radiation is negligible, but we know you've been wrong before. I will opt out every time I fly.
This TSA security theater has gotten out of hand. If a terrorist wants to take out a plane, there are many other ways that it could be accomplished. The TSA is not making anyone safe, it is simply spending billions of taxpayer money to enrich large corporations. People just need to realize that nothing is completely safe, but air travel is still one of the safest methods of long distance travel.
As a recently arrived "Alien" with a work visa, I strongly object to the "presumption of guilt" which seems to pervade my interactions with the US government and corporations:
- I am not a terrorist and do not appreciate being treated as one
- You have my fingerprints on file - this just increases my chance of being arrested for something I didn't do
- I have never been in default of payment on a bill in my life. So why can't you trust me to pay a a month bill?
Let’s not forget that former homeland security secretary Michael Chertoff is the founder of the Chertoff Group, a security consulting firm whose clients include manufacturers of full-body scanners.
Chertoff’s group represents Rapiscan, a California based firm “which until recently was the only company qualified to sell full-body scan machines to the TSA.” Last summer, “TSA purchased 150 machines from Rapiscan with million in American Recovery and Reinvestment Act funds." We have been Rape Scammed again by Congress!
Google "Michael Chertoff and TSA" Let's start the rebellion and close down Air Travel!
Enough is Enough!
This free-born Englishman would dearly love to visit America but objects to being treated like a potential terrorist by the TSA et al, so regrettably shan't.
This is just more of the security theater and there has to be a point where enough is enough.
Thank you, veterans, for helping to preserve the right of the TSA to perform illegal hazardous searches and commit sexual assault in the name of "safety". Is this really what you fought and died for?
Please, no more security theater.
If it was anyone else touching me like this, it would be assault!
The first time I refused to go through the scanner and received the "enhanced pat down" I couldn't believe the horrifying sense of violation I felt. I am encouraged by this movement and I hope we can put an end to this.
You know these scanners aren't really working, there's far more effective ways of doing this 'security'. To be honest, with the amount of pain you're causing every person who travels through the USA, the terrorists have already won.
Look to Israel - they offer far more protection with far less intrusion.
I have been groped 3 times inappropriately. This is all complete theater. Please stop the madness!
The scanners are bullshit, so is having to take off my shoes
We need *real* security, not "security theater" who's only benefit is the manufacturers of the "new" "technologies".
At what cost this so-called "security"?
Groping and naked scanning of American citizens CAN NOT be a requirement for flying in this country. Stop this invasion of privacy NOW.
I've stopped flying because TSA makes the screening process so uncomfortable. There *must* be a better way.
The TSA should be abolished altogether. We need to end ridiculous security theatre.
Let's end the sacrifice of privacy, especially for the mere illusion of security.
Enough Security Theater!
By using these machines, the terrorists win.
I will never fly again until our constitutional rights are given back to us. I will not be a victim to your "terrorism" prevention schemes. We are not the terrorists. Terrorism is nothing more than a buzzword the TSA uses to manipulate and control us at will. We will prevail.
Any other business, government controlled or not, would be sued or closed down for such shameful representation. As a Massage Therapist, I take client/customer privacy extremely seriously and there should be no exceptions to the rule.
I'm convinced these methods do not make us safer.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty
to purchase a little Temporary Safety,
deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
Oh, and keep your damn hands off my "Junk", TSA!
I shouldn't be afraid of my government. It should fear me.
This isn't even done for security - it's about treating us like cattle
Stop screening for weapons. Start screening for terrorists. End the victimization of America.
This is an affront to the idea of personal liberty in America. This is an affront to the Fourth Amendment. This must stop.
Will not fly under the scanners and intrusive strip search are halted.
Unconstitutional!
Abolish the TSA
TSA hires anyone who can put on a uniform. I don't think makes one qualified enough to exploit others on a hunch.
Such qualification doesn't exist.
this really is a bigger deal that you are all making it. please give us our privacy back!
things are really getting out of hand.
It makes me sick to think that my girlfriend will either be forced to pose naked for some guy behind a screen, or be groped by a TSA officer when she goes to visit her family in California this weekend. It's absolutely disgusting, and totally unwarranted. Stop this now!
I've been subject to a "search" like this before, only it was considered sexual assault. I didn't give my permission then, and I certainly won't subject myself to it now.
Unreasonable search is unconstitutional, and unnecessary! Compare the odds of dying in a terrorist plane attack to other ways of dying. The risk does not justify the costs here!
You may think you're keeping America safe, but in fact you are letting the terrorists win by changing everything anytime they attempt anything. They have you by the balls.
I'm concerned about the backscatter x-rays, not merely for myself, but also for airline employees who will have to use them daily, and also for the TSA staff who are being exposed throughout their workday. When the alternative is groping in a way only my husband should touch me, is there really an alternative? As you drive the public away from the air, I expect our tourism industries will feel the pressure even more than their already feeling from our weak economy. If any of this made me safer as a traveler, I'd understand, but I don't see it as effective either.
TSA: Security of the Absurd.
Will not fly until these unnecessary and ineffective screening practices are gone.
I want to visit your nation without being treated like a criminal.
In many parts of Alaska, there is no alternative to air travel. Sometimes "just don't fly" isn't an option. So, in order to attend a wedding, get a medical procedure, or travel for business, travelers will HAVE to be subjected to these measures.
This practice limits my interstate travel and interstate commerce because it puts undo burden of proof on me to prove innocence. It's a travesty.
This needs to be stopped immediately. Enough civil rights abuses have gone on in the name of terrorism avoidance.
I, too, will not fly until these scanners and the invasive "pat-downs" are done away with.
This needs to end.
Restore Liberty and Freedom! We allow the TSA to degrade american citizens while not following our Constitution!
The current TSA policies violate our 4th Amendment Rights and only make people *feel* safe, instead of actually keeping them safe.
There are plenty of examples around the world of better security systems. Let's study those procedures instead of crawling through the process like infants until we finally realize that those systems were better to begin with and eventually adopt them anyway. We're reinventing the wheel, and we still only have a square.
This is a perversion of our rights. The TSA is completely ineffectual.
Security Theater is not security. I don't care if it makes weak minded people feel better stop violating our rights in the name of "security".
Has a terrorist EVER boarded a small passenger jet flying point-to-point in the United States? The TSA is the most lazy and stupid bureaucracy the US has ever created.
I will not be flying until these measures are repealed.
Just because you can, doesn't mean you should
We should take a look at how Israel handles security -- less intrusive searches, but with better behavioral analysis.
This is overdue.
This is truly a disgusting invasion of provacy! What happened to the 4th Ammendment?
Please stop these hazardous and unnecessary searches.
Please learn from the example of other countries who have not adopted such practices.
No confidence in TSA's mission to provide security. Their methods are an expensive joke.
I'm from the UK, and I can guarantee that I, and many like me, won't be coming anywhere near the U.S. until this mess is cleared up.
The TSA and related agencies have lied at every turn in deployment of this equipment. We were told the information was to be anonymous and transitory. Now we find that it can may very well be stored in databases. Only question in my mind is, "Will this be for the gratuitous perverse satisfaction of anonymous bureaucrats or for use as the country continues its sad descent into a police state?"
I won't be flying until the use of body scanners and physical assault pat-downs are discontinued.
Fear the indifference of decent people.
"those that sacrifice a little liberty for a little security deserve neither."
Tell me this is not convincing: http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
I am a pilot. I find this not only distasteful but also a waste of time. There are other, proven ways of keeping our country and our airline traveling passengers safe. One quick look at the Israeli method will tell you that profiling is needed. It is not and need not be racially motivated.
Why aren't we using Israel's model?
I consider the use of this technology to be an illegal search as defined by the Constitution. I will not fly until these policies are revoked.
Buying a plane ticket is not probable cause
This is wrong. It needs to stop.
We are finally seeing the limits of the public's tolerance to the security theatre that is the TSA. Take my shoes, okay; Touch my genitals, not on your life.
These searches and their cancer-causing alternative are clearly unconstitutional and therefore illegal and unethical violations of the 4th amendment protection from unreasonable searches.
I fly routinely for work, and I've traveled a good deal internationally, and I can tell you that our security procedures are far more invasive and time consuming than any other nation's that I've experienced.
Security is necessary, but not at the cost of liberty.
This is a digusting policy. I do not want to be exposed to a full body scanner, and I do not want to be touched by a TSA agent. It's degrading. Unfortunately I may have no choice as I haven't seen my family in years and the only way to get there reasonably is to fly. I've never dreaded going home for christmas before like this. Flying used to be pleasurable, or at the very least tolerable, now it's frightening, and it's not because I'm worried about the plane being hijacked, it's because of the TSA
These searches are a violation of my right to privacy and in no way make me feel more safe.
I am a person.
I understand that security vs. freedom involve tradeoffs. The Backscatter X-ray machines and extended physical pat-downs are an unacceptable tradeoff of violating our rights for little real gain in security. We as a nation need to choose the freedom we have stood for again and again, and not the illusion of security at great expense.
This violates the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution
People willing to trade their freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both. - Ben Franklin
why is a citizen with no outstanding warrants who wishes to fly subjected to more scrutiny than a convicted felon being transported to prison?
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." as published in Memoirs of the life and writings of Benjamin Franklin
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Ben Franklin
Adding a backscatter x-ray machine increases our exposure to radiation but does not make us any safer. If you remember correctly, the 9/11 hijackers did not use weapons to take control of those planes. Perhaps we should stop searching for weapons and start searching for terrorists.
This is assault.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Please reevaluate the TSA policies. If Israel doesn't require passengers to yield liquids and shoes (and they have much more visible threats), then why do Americans?
Don't touch my junk!
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." - The United States Constitution, Fourth Amendment.
Stop making it an unpleasant experience to fly!
I opt out!
The TSA is nonsense, everyone knows we're no safer just more inconveienced.
I will not fly unless this goes away.
I will not send my salesmen on business trip either.
Be reasonable, and keep your hands (and X-rays) off my body.
Are we to choose between exposing our children to harmful radiation and being groped by a stranger? No flying for us until this ridiculous policy is rescinded.
I have a Fourth Amendment right not to be searched without probably cause and a First Amendment right to call “Bullshit” when I see it.
I will not fly anymore until some sanity and reason is restored! Let's see Janet Napolitano scanned and groped in a public terminal ....
Security is important, but personal freedoms are what this country is based on.. when did we trade so much away?
The TSA provides "security" in name only. Security theatrics and scare tactics only weaken the USA.
What DHS is doing shows the terrorists have won. We are living in fear, our rights have been eroded. Please fix this.
I WILL NOT FLY AGAIN UNTIL THESE SCANNERS ARE REMOVED AND THESE "PAT DOWNS" IS STOPPED "HAVE YOU NO DECENCY MAM" next a terrorist will put a bomb in his anus and we will all be forced to do anal cavity searches.
We live overseas, fly frequently and have a young child. Please help us not have to explain why she must expose herself or be groped if we want to go home for Christmas.
I support real security, like the Israelis have, not the bureaucratic waste of billions spent on the pretend security we currently have.
As an American who has had problems with skin cancer and tumors, I have no desire to be blasted with radiation in order to travel.
I will not fly until the TSA are banned from airports. A person with half a brain or a single brain cell for that matter can see where all this is heading.
We are trading our essential freedoms in the guise of safety. This is wholly unacceptable. Our freedoms and liberty are what make us different from those that attack us. If this means we will be attacked again, so be it. I will not fly, for work, or for personal, until this is remedied.
I'm particularly upset about the impounding and searching of personal computers and electronic devices. This is incredibly intrusive and airports are not the place to do it. If they want to search my computer, get a warrant and come to my home.
Why not follow the same security protocol that Isreal uses?
Stop the lobbyists from controlling EVERYTHING in our world. We already have to pay to bring clothes with us when we travel, and now you want to be able to see us without them?!?!
Stop this nonsense.
Have found renewed interest in rail and road travel.
Stop touching me & keep your eyes out of my pants.
Stop the security parade, and stop treating citizens like criminals.
The airlines better start putting pressure on the government, as we won't be flying until this clear breach of trust and law is stopped.
Status quo is:
1) My daughter gets molested
2) My daughter gets nude pictures taken of her
Anything would be better than that.
Please stop this.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." – Benjamin Franklin
I will be taking viagra, eating re-fried beans, and drinking a quart of milk before i get in the line. I will then DEMAND a pat down.
enjoy TSA
This illusion of security will not keep anyone safe. These new procedures do nothing but infuriate the innocent public. You are violating the basic dignity of every person you subject to this process. Shame on you! Shame on all those willing to participate in such a system whose only purpose is to further erode the Constitutional rights we are guaranteed under the 4th Amendment.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
It's bad enough that this is going to happen to me. The idea of my wife and daughters being subjected to this kind of assault is abhorrent. The TSA is terrorizing me far more than any hypothetical terrorist ever had.
I refuse to fly as long as it involves violating my privacy, insulting my intelligence, surrendering my freedoms, and admitting defeat to the terrorists whose goal is attained by TSA policies. I'm ashamed that Americans with a 235 year legacy of defending freedom would meekly submit to this atrocity out of fear. Anyone who surrenders their proud birthright with a "Better safe than sorry" should be banned from ever again waving an American flag.
I will not fly as long as these invasive and unconstitutional policies and procedures remain in place.
I'm not convinced this is helpful or will increase security at all.
Don't want nude photos of me taken, seen or saved. Where is the personal liberties line? When are they going to implement body cavity searches?
Enough Already!!!
Travelers are not being told that they can use the scanners but if "something" shows up they will still be subjected to the pat down. TSA can see me naked, touch my genitals yet TSA does not screen domestic cargo?! What about a woman who is on her period? Will I be required to remove the pad to prove I'm not a sporting a bomb in underwear?
These scanners and the pat downs are outrageous! The Terrorists have won - can't they see that? They have managed to send the government scurrying around, restricting our liberty and wasting millions on security and war. Add to the insult and injury, these scanners have not been fulling tested for health risks. I refuse to fly.
Getting ridiculous. What's next? No thanks!
TSA needs to drop it's persecution of the man from San Diego as well.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." We are US citizens and we will stand up for and fight for our rights.
Even Israeli security experts agree full-body scanners are a waste of money. Don't let the threat of terrorism - which has existed for decades - degrade our air travel (vital to our economy) and our individual rights. It's time for an overhaul of the TSA.
Because of these enhanced procedures, I will not be personally flying anywhere until these machines and procedures are removed. They do nothing to deter terrorist activities and are strictly security theater, paid for by us as taxpayers through the lobbyists paying off our representatives. Nobody will stand up to these intrusions because they do not want to be labeled as "against security."
Stop wasting taxpayer money on theatrics.
It is because of the TSA that I am trying to cut down - if not eliminate - flying. It is ironic considering the terrorists would find this outcome desirable and the TSA is doing what the terrorists could not.
This invasion of my civil liberties only represents a minimal gain in safety and more or less represents the terrorists winning. They've made us liver in fear and terror and accept violations of our liberties in name of "safety". We need to stick it to them, not have it stuck to us.
I have no intention of subjecting myself to any TSA groping, scanning, wanding or patting down. I won't opt out of the foregoing, I'll opt out of flying altogether. Hit the airline sin their pocketbook and I guarantee this foolishness will come to a halt.
If the TSA really believe they need to feel up or take nude photos of children and adults as part of the "war on terror" then really the war is over, and the other guy won.
These security measure are ridiculous, ineffective, and a GIGANTIC violation of our rights as US citizens. Put an end to this madness. These measures do absolutely nothing to ensure the security of airline passengers.
Imagine George Washington agreeing to be scanned; I don't think so.
It's a violation of privacy as well as direct violation of 4th Amendment (when no cause exists). Just because I fly doesn't make me a criminal or a potential criminal.
I would rather risk a terrorist murdering me on a train or a bus than submit to sexual assault by my own government. Listen to reason.
Give us back our rights please.
Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither and will lose both.
I will seek out alternative means of transportation as much as possible until these machines are removed. I will continue to exercise my right to "opt out" when I do need to fly. These machines are a blatant violation of our privacy rights.
Unethical, Unconstitutional, Unamerican
Why not follow this proven approach: http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother ?
Our approach in the U.S. to security and our general mindset in regards to terrorism is fundamentally flawed. Our security processes should resemble those of modern day Israel. Our collective attitude should mirror that of WWII Britain.
We will not consent to these gross violations of our civil liberties.
This is deplorable and needs to end immediately.
I will also not fly until the scanners and invasive body searches are halted.
They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. -- Benjamin Franklin, 1775
Total invasion of privacy.
Stop violating our constitutional rights and focus instead on security procedures that actually target likely threats, political correctness be damned!
We have begun treating all passengers as criminals, but it has done little to help us catch actual criminals.
In the 1930, public work programs gave us infrastructure, grand public buildings, rural power, water and telephone. In the twenty first century public work programs are lining the pockets of corporations, and training a generation of petty thieves, vandals and molesters. As a child I had expected my future to be better than this. As an adult I say enough. Creating agencies who's sole purpose is to create the illusion of safety does not produce the anything like the nostalgic lifestyle of the the 1950's. In fact it creates something more akin to the fascism that gripped Europe in the 1940's, and the plutocracy that set Japan on it's hellish road of conquest.
As a foreigner, I feel even more threatened by the possibility that somebody whom I'll have a hard time understanding, and who may claim not to understand me, might sexually molest me for no reason at all. We won't subject american citizen to such degrading procedure. I shouldn't suffer it either.
Benjamin Franklin - They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Never mind the fact that we are giving up liberty to purchase no safety.
If we are not afraid they lose 90% of their power.
Why does the TSA need to grope my 1-year-old son?
Follow the Israeli model.
Honestly, the entire thing reeks of failure. Has there even been any studies on how effective these more imposing security measures are at stopping threats, compared to previously? What a waste of time and money.
I will not be molested!
This security theater stopped being entertaining when it became violating. How about some real security?
This is America- We invent new things everyday. I'm sure we can come up with a less evasive way to check for bombs. This is stupid!
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security. -Ben Franklin
Especially for those people underage, or those who have been sexually traumatized, the pat down process can be extraordinarily emotionally & mentally painful. It does not enhance our safety; it only angers the people of the United States and makes our country look like a country of fearmongers, rather than a country of free people.
We're more likely to be struck by lightning than die from a terrorist on a plane, but we don't freak out about thunderstorms.
Terrorist only "win" when we're terrorized; it's easy not to be. Let's be adults and stop the nonsense.
Security at airports should be the same as in any major train station; i.e., minimal.
I have a metal rod in my thigh that sets off metal detectors every time I fly, and so I always get the pat down.
It's humiliating, frustrating, and time consuming. I wouldn't want anyone to go through it who doesn't absolutely have to.
Furthermore, there is no reason for you to see me naked. Please, don't.
I refuse to submit to unreasonable searches of my person. You will not see so much as a penny from me until this policy is rescinded. I'm willing to drive and take trains as necessary for my travel requirements.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -- Benjamin Franklin
This concerns me as a mother. I do not want my children exposed to x-rays, nor do I want them physically assaulted in an opt out situation. This is disturbing.
On protest day, I suggest everyone wear a Dirk Diggler prosthesis.
We as Americans will absolutely not stand down while our Constitutional rights are violated. This is despicable and should never happen in the United States.
I will not fly while these policies continue to be in place.
Has TSA ever found a bomb in the checkpoints? No. Meanwhile bag-screeners let Dubia send live bombs last month. Come on, stop the madness! This does NOT make us any safer!
Using ionizing radiation for this purpose should be a crime!
I used to fly quite a bit. Now it's so intrusive, I refuse to fly. The current security measures are invasive, yet none to effective. Israel's approach seems much better for the flyer and more effective..
This is a repulsive policy. Why would anyone be okay with this? I'd like to see them be groped publicly and their scanner images of their bodies passed around and see if they're okay with it themselves.
Give us our Constitutional Rights back.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a Temporary Safety, deserve neither"
--B. Franklin
What next? Cavity searches? In the name of "security"? How far does this go? Rest assured, I will NOT be flying with my 1 year old daughter ANYWHERE until these potential sexual assaulters and potentially dangerous machines are no longer utilized. These ignorant, exhorbitantly expensive and fear based measures don't really do much to fight terrorism, they only to create fear.
The last thing I want for my young daughter is to have complete pat down in front of her entire family.
I moved to this country 20 years ago, and became a voting citizen 8 years ago, and frankly this invasion of privacy and civil liberties stands in stark contrast to everything my adopted country stands for.
"Those who give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." -- Ben Franklin, 1775
No safety is worth our dignity, even if I believed for a second that these measures did anything to enhance safety (which I do not). Those that died for our freedoms, and those that have died to terror attacks, did so in vein if we allow our fear to compromise the principles upon which this nation was founded. Strip searches and body scanning will not win the war on terror; they are in fact a sign that the terrorists have won. It is easy to defend freedom when it is not under attack; a nations strength is measured by how we act under duress.
I will conclude by saying I fear the TSA and its ilk far more than I do the Taliban; a terrorist may kill me, but erosion of freedom takes away my will to live.
I will not fly until the "naked or groped" policy is lifted or the TSA is dissolved.
I fly over 100 legs every year and I work in medical imaging, so I am very away of radiation and the potential side effects. I trust UCSF more than the federal gov't. I also believe this to be a direct and egregious violation of our 4th Amendment rights and such drastic invasions aren't required in other countries, take Israel for example.
Get some pointers from Israel.
TSA is just a performance to give the illusion of security.
How far can we push the word "privacy" before nothing is private?
Look to Israel's method, act intelligently.
It's time to stop giving up our freedoms in our own country while we try to spread freedom around the world. We need to start practicing what we preach, otherwise we are no better than the citizens of other countries that won't stand uo for themselves.
I will not fly until these scanners are removed and invasive searches come to a stop. Its uncomfortable enough as it is to fly, I refuse to put myself and family through this.
It is unacceptable to do away with the American people's rights as protected by the Fourth Amendment in the name of "safety", especially when the effectiveness of the methods in question are in dispute.
The TSA should focus its energy on identifying real threats.
I'm seriously thinking about finding alternatives to flying.
We need security procedures that do not compromise our health and our privacy.
Will be driving to our next destination.
WIll not fly until security procedures are reformed.
Take a page out of Israel's security handbook; they have the best in the world and they don't use this.
Already committed to flying over Thanksgiving, but intend to drive to annual conference in CA next year instead of flying if current backscatter/pat-downs still in effect.
Act NOW ..........
In addition to violating our rights these full body scanners seem to be another band-aid system that is designed to make flyers feel safe rather than actually be safe.
“Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both.” Benjamin Franklin
As a mother of a young child, this is despicable. What young children are being subjected to in the name of safety is nothing short of molestation and pornography. How am I going to explain it to him when I fly to see my father? "Sorry honey, I know I told you to scream for the police in anyone touches your special place, but you have to let this strange man do it now."
I can't even imagine how a rape survivor would handle such a horrible expierence.
We have gone from panic to panic with no discernible evidence of much planning beyond what the lobbyists can sell to the TSA. The whole of airline security needs to be reconsidered and revamped. People waiting like cattle in massive lines, accosted and mistreated is un-American and unacceptable.
We can do better.
Start profiling Muslims. They are the ones that do this.
The TSA is a joke. Different rules are upheld at different airports, so there is no consistency. And then TSA agents are rude and condescending because we don't know how to go through security. Well, maybe if security rules were THE SAME at each airport, we would know what is expected. Why do I have to take off my shoes at SEATAC but not at LGB?
And now these imbeciles have the authority to fondle me and/or see me naked while you save the files? (and yes, your machines CAN save images-this was a news story MONTHS ago)
I don't think so. No more flying for me. You people should be ASHAMED of yourselves.
Outrageous overreach by the TSA. In this the terrorists have already won a major battle.
This is an inexcusable power grab and erosion of our civil rights as American Citizens.
Until I have the rights in an airport that I have in the rest of the US, I will avoid flying if at all possible. This is an affront to my freedom, dignity, and privacy.
Most of my adult life has been dedicated to Law Enforcement. Never have I ever seen an agency that is so obsolete and defunct as the the TSA. I should mention that I am also a licensed commercial pilot. Stand up and take back your dignity America!
The goal of the terrorists is not simply to kill western civilians, but to wage a campaign of fear that will erode our precious freedoms and financially ruin us through frivolous reactionary spending and economic disruption. They no longer need to kill anyone, they simply need to keep us scared. We are scared, and the policies of our government clearly demonstrate our irrationality. Hence the terrorists have won.
I refuse to allow a choice between invasive images and invasive fingers. Neither are healthy, fair, or effective.
I am appalled that I live in a country that would allow these illegal searches. If there is a class action suit brought I will do my best to be considered a part of the class.
I am horrified that I will be forced to choose between allowing strangers to view naked simulacra of my daughters, or strangers to sexually molest them while traveling in my own country at the behest of the federal government. Moreover, I think such a search is unwarranted as a safety precaution. If the terrorists have gotten a bomb in their underpants to the crowded security line, we've already lost, they'll just set it off there. This is a policy born of fear, not reason. The terrorists have won when we stop living courageously AS Americans, but instead allow our basic human dignity to be degraded and violated in this way.
Sexual harassment is illegal for citizens. It should be illegal for the government as well.
I refuse to fly and submit myself to sexual assault, harmful radiation, invasion of privacy, being oogled, and having naked pictures of my body stored and I am outraged that these things are happening to millions of people, including children. People need to stand up for themselves and not just go along with it, justifying that this "security" outweighs the health risks and devastating emotional and mental effects.
This is an abhorrent and completely illegal act. I am appalled that these types of procedures were ever put into place, and I will be refusing to fly until they have been eradicated.
By taking your positions in our US Government you swore to upload the laws of this land, and those include the Constitution. You cannot let these procedures continue, you are legally BOUND to stop this.
This is the very definition of unreasonable search and seizure. There US constitution exists to protect the citizenry against this very form of tyranny. I hope the present administration will no longer turn a deaf ear to the welfare of the people of this great nation.
I will never submit myself or my child to this possibly unsafe, invasive technology.
The TSA should wise up upon concern from many of us, that these ways are not working and are only creating a rift between travelers and those that are supposed to keep us safe. Is it not obvious it's time to re-think these screening methods?
Stop the Security Theatre! Lets get real behavior profiling and other proven effective ways of detecting terrorists, not these invasive, inconvenient search methods that *still* won't prevent a terrorist from bringing on a bomb inside a body cavity.
I applaud those who have spoken up about the egregious overstepping of personal boundaries by the TSA and on the rare occasions that I HAVE to fly, I will be diligent in informing fellow passengers of their rights.
These procedures do nothing to keep us safer, they just allow the TSA to invade our privacy and our bodies.
I stopped flying in 2006 due to the TSA's ridiculous ban on liquids. I have even less reason to fly now.
It is unreasonable for Americans to have to make a decision between subjecting themselves to unnecessary radiation or being molested. As someone who both has concerns about their health and has actually been molested (not just airport security) I find it disgusting that I need to make a choice between my physical or mental health in order to share my research to other professionals concerned with the same problems.
The radiation part needs more research, but the right to privacy does not.
Terror attacks since 9/11 have not been thwarted by additional TSA theater and wasted taxpayer dollars, but rather by passenger action.
Not flying until we have reasonable, sensible airport security like Israel's.
Fight the enemy, but not at the expense of the people.
Why can't we be more like Isreali airport security?
This is despicable, idiotic, and wrong. A perfect example of bureaucracy gone awry... and it's not helping to make us safer. Find the actual terrorists-follow Israel's airport-security example.
We know these machines do not make us safer, but rather line the pockets of the people who advocate for them. Please do not give into corporate greed and fear-mongering at the expense of public health, personal dignity, and freedom. As Benjamin Franklin said, "People willing to trade their freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both."
I will not fly until body scanners and groping are done away with.
No to searches. No to machinery that scans and stores pictures of me. Security is not enhanced with these measures. Make them stop.
Stop abusing our civil liberties!
Americans used to fight and die in the name of freedom, now many seem unwilling to face even the slightest increased risk to exercise those freedoms.
Wow, talk about terroists winning...
I refuse to fly or let my children fly until the use full body scanners and genital searches are halted. This is a disgusting treatment of law-abiding citizens and a violation of our 4th Amendment rights.
Invasive and unreasonable search for our safety dangerous enough. But invasive and unreasonable search to provide only the illusion of safety is entirely unacceptable.
I find the scanners and pat-downs deeply degrading and offensive.
I don't think the 'illusion of safety' includes you copping a feel every time I fly. Please change this policy, would YOU like to be subjected to this kind of government sanctioned 'rape' so to speek?
Seriously, this has gone way too far.
These scanners are ineffective and harmful. The pat-downs are invasive. I want the option to use a metal detector. How much is Chertoff making on these machines?
Please give my heartfelt thanks to the TSA for encouraging me to try Amtrak or go Greyhound again.
Not only are these X-Rays a potential health hazard, I do not believe they provide any additional security or protection for me or my family when flying.
Technology will not obviate the need for intelligent profiling. Look at Israel's record.
We can't be ruled by fear.
As a former TSA TSO(Security Officer) I fully endorse this. It was a daily conversation by all TSA employees of the actual effectiveness of the agency. If the employees who are doing the searches don't believe that they are effective in countering terrorism, then why are we still wasting money on TSA. TSA is just a deterrent, a very expensive, ineffective one.
I will not allow the government to eliminate my personal freedoms out of fear of a terrorist attack. I will never sit by and let them win like TSA employees do every day.
I will respectfully decline full-body searches on my upcoming holiday travels
I didn't sign up to be a performer in what is ostensibly security theater. And I don't pay taxes to have my civil liberties trashed in what is, experts agree, a farcical and useless security process.
For Liberty
The TSA has more than overstepped their boundaries this time. I want our skies to be safe just like anyone else, but there is a line between rationality and paranoia.
I just returned home from a trip where not only was I xrayed but patted down too. All for a zipper on my cargo pants; which, by the way, I had worn on my trip out. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to the search procedure.
Enough is enough; this isn't the way you catch bad guys. You really think groping 80-year-old in-laws and having them take off their belts and shoes will stop terrorism?
Yea , their is no chance in hell i am going to allow them to scan my wife.
I'd rather be FREE than SAFE!
Won't fly until they are removed.
Those who give up liberty for safety deserve neither
When TSA agents insist they must either see or touch my junk, the terrorists have already won.
We have an unusually hi incidence of skin cancers in ou family—both squamish and melanoma—not to mention other cancers. I doon't need to increase my xray load in airport scanners.
This is a clear violation of my Civil Rights, and I don't Appreciate the fact that I am "consenting" to these conditions when I buy a plane ticket.
There's a point at which you don't want to travel anymore.
As an American citizen, I refuse to be stripped of my Fourth Amendment right guarding me against UNREASONABLE searches. The backscatter x-ray and "enhanced" pat down have crossed the line.
I was in the Navy during OIF, and worked on check point in country. Not even during war time, did I see such madness.
The appearance of security is not the same thing as security.
The madness needs to stop! Whatever happened to CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS?
Since our CORPORATE-owned government only listens to $$$$$, let's all boycott any and all air travel until these illegal searches stop!
Police States never work, never have, never will!!!
This petition says it all. No, I will not give up my rights - I'm still using them!
I will not fly until the scans AND pat-downs are ended. These are not providing additional security.
We need a new strategy. I want to feel safe, not violated.
I wonder how Obama would feel if his young daughters had to submit to virtual strip searches or groping by strangers. Well, that's exactly how THIS parent of a 14 y/o teenage girl feels!
The need to protect the public is great, but not when the cost is so high. We each have a right to not be touched or scanned should we so choose, and the simple act of boarding a plane does not negate that.
I am not afraid.
I did not serve in the USMC to tolerate this absurd approach.
We are destroying the very thing we are attempting to protect.
"Remember, remember the 5th of November."
I will not submit to this sort of invasion of privacy. I have not committed a crime, nor am I suspected of having committed a crime. These TSA techniques do not make us safer, they further strip us of our liberties.
I work for a commercial airline and worry how this will affect an already struggling industry.
As citizens we have rights and due process to respect and dignity.
As a survivor of sexual assault, I am deeply troubled by the new TSA rules. I have a trip scheduled next week and am very fearful of the triggers that being groped will elicit. Flying should not make me subject to humiliation, molestation, or displays of my naked body as a regular course of "security." If it is, I will not fly again.
End all security theatre now.
I was recently made to have a the enhanced pat down. It was humiliating and felt like punishment for refusing the full body scanner. I was touched in ways that are outrageous and usually illegal. Show evidence that these methods (full body scanner and enhanced pat downs) are necessary AND effective. Otherwise stop wasting time and money on pretend security that takes away my rights.
Showing fear my fear of backscatter radiation does not mean I am agreeing to release my human dignity.
As a survivor of both childhood and adult sexual assault I am now utterly terrified to fly. This may impact my career! If I do fly and am re-traumatized by TSA, will the government be paying my therapy bills?
Congratulations. The terrorists have won. This is your fault TSA.
Don't fly and the IATA pressures the TSA do actual security work instead of fondling people then we all win.
I just don't think it's an effective measure... Which means the sacrifices in rights and privacy are made for nothing.
I am a woman, reasonably agile, with bilateral hip replacements, meaning I am wanded and patted down -- that is, treated like a suspect -- every single time I fly. This is not necessary! Stop it, please. Your security theater in which I am an unwilling actor makes no flight safer.
I want our airports secure, but not at the risk of my privacy and health. Consult Israel on how to secure an airport and passengers!
As a medical student, I am very concerned about the possible long-term effects of backscatter machines. For someone flying even semi-regularly, the additive effects of these "scans" cannot be trivial.
As an American citizen, I am concerned about the "enhanced" pat-down procedure. If we are subjected to random and unwarranted searches and pat-downs at the airport, what next? train station? bus stop? office building??? I fail to see how anyone can blindly accept this invasion of privacy (not to mention the possible health effects of the alternative) all in the name of our "protection."
Tired of this.
Almost a billion flights since 9/11 and no planes have gone down because of terrorists. Of the terrorists that have gotten onto flights, they were stopped by the passengers: NOT the TSA.
Bye bye air travel! Hello buses and trains!
Our freedom is in jeopardy by our own actions, not of terrorists.
TSA needs to work on some intelligent intelligence rather than treating the innocent public like animals and criminals.
the tsa is simply "security theater"
Has the whole world gone crazy? Am I the only one around here who gives a shit about the rules?
Oh, apparently not. Well that's refreshing.
As a very frequent traveller I am exposed to enough radiation while flying. I do not need any more... There has to be a better way!!
You can't stop me from flying and the first time my privates are groped or I'm forced into a backscatter scan I will sue.
The founding fathers wrote the Bill of Rights for a reason. The TSA search procedures are invasive and in many cases illegal. Pretty soon we'll have to give blood/urine/stool samples to be "allowed" to fly.
None of these invasive searches has caught a single terrorist nor will they ever. This is nothing but a ploy strip Americans of our civil liberties in the name of Freedom. To quote Benjamin Franklin, "Those who would give up Essential Liberty
to purchase a little Temporary Safety,
deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
I will not fly unless this egregious practice is modified.
I opt out.
I am strongly objecting to this invasion of privacy and battery against the individual. A sexually offensive touching is a crime in this country and I will not be subjected to this kind of treatment.
This needs to stop. NOW. The TSA are acting like they’re Gods.. basically it amounts to the following: endure sexual humiliation, or else endure sexual molestation or else be denied the right to fly at the least. What’s next? Demanding all passengers disrobe to their skin to go thru security? Public (meaning in full view of the entire airport) cavity searches? WE THE PEOPLE should not be ordered around like cattle by our own government!!! Airport security is becoming more and more akin to the processing that went on at Nazi Death Camps…which makes me wonder if that’s the real goal...
Too far
I will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
I have traveled a million times from Israel and back. Their security is 10 times better and 10 times less hassle.
I've already avoided one trip partly due to the use of these scanners and pat downs. I plan to avoid many others.
What was that amendment? the one about illegal search and seizures!
This is an outrage!! I've seen the images from the "mild" x-ray scanner and my christian upbringing will not let me feel comfortable letting anyone other than my husband see me naked. and having a stranger touch me is out of the question. to take away our right to opt out of these invasive procedures is to take away our RIGHTS AS AMERICANS!!!
Another reason not to fly.
Xray machines and pat downs go too far.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither Liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
You are more likely to die from the radiation from the porno scanners than by a terrorist on an airplane.
Why not check out how Israel does airport security. They are professionals.
There are better ways. I've postponed all travel.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated...
When we have reduced ourselves to these crazy security checks just to fly somewhere the terrorists HAVE won!
I really want to see the TSA adopt security like Israel employs at Ben Gurion Int'l....use WELL TRAINED individuals to question passengers and weed out those who act suspiciously! Technology cannot take the place of intelligent and educated workers at security checkpoints!!!
Our idea of "homeland security" smells like proto-fascism to me...
There must be a discernible line between the degradation of liberties for the protection of the public. These scanners and the TSA do nothing to protect individual liberties.
I will sue anyone that molests me or my children. I will call the police on you and your child pornographers and sue you for everything you have.
I'm afraid to fly now. I don't want to submit to a virtual strip search or inappropriate touching.
Security experts claim these scanners might not have stopped recent attempts like the xmas bomber
To hell with your screening
While it is claimed that radiation levels are harmless, one could point to similarly erroneous claims: e.g. Prozac reduces anxiety (but could cause suicidal tendencies!!!).
Besides violating the 4th Amendment, this treats every citizen as if they were a criminal. What happened to "innocent until proven guilty"?
I will not submit to strip search without a warrant. If that means I can't fly, then I will drive or take the train.
As a mother of a young child we will never fly again if these policies stand.
In addition, I point out that the effectiveness of AIT scanners is questionable at best and simply adds to the sense of utter absurdity that comprises the entire airport security experience. Excepting securing cockpit doors onboard planes, so-called security procedures implemented since 9/11 are merely cosmetic and serve little to no practical purpose. It is a gross waste of resources and a gross violation of the flying public's rights and dignity.
I will not fly I will not travel I will tell the company I work for I will not fly and why until this mess changes.
I prefer avoiding unnecessary exposure to radiation, so I'll be opting out on my next flight. I read today how TSA agents are now actually reaching into the pants of the airline patrons, and this sparked another health concern. Is it OK to ask the TSA agent to get a new pair of gloves out from a sterile package in front of me so that I can confirm that I'll be safe? I'd hate to avoid getting cancer from the scanner only to get an STD from the previously-groped customer, so this should be a reasonable request.
The number of people unwilling to fly as a result of these Fourth Amendment violations will greatly increase the number of traffic injuries and fatalities. This is madness and must be stopped.
The terrorists have won...
Fourth Amendment – Protection from unreasonable search and seizure.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
Sexual assault is not ok, even if it is the government carrying it out.
padded down by a member of the same sex -- but what if that guy is gay ??
We have already changed our summer travel plans as I will not allow my daughters, ages 14 and 12, to be viewed nude, sexually assaulted, or exposed to radiation.
When do we as Americans get back the rights our forefathers fought for?
I have been able to cancel any plans that would require me to fly for most of the next year. I've had enough xrays and ct scans I've already doubled my cancer risk and I refuse to be felt up by strangers.
Invasive and won't help against terrorist attacks. Plus it will set a standard for the whole world.
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
Freedom! Forever!
Americans are being given the choice between an invasive full-body scan with unknown health risks or an even more invasive groping by a TSA employee. What's worse? These types of ridiculous procedures don't even increase our security. If this wasn't so disturbing, it would almost be funny.
As as sexual assault survivor/PTSD sufferer, I had to stop flying after December '01, when I was patted down six times on one cross-country flight (apparently part of the unofficial cute-girl procedure). Was just thinking I might be ready to try air travel again, but not now. This will be awful for everyone, but particularly awful for survivors and for some transgendered people.
Transamerican Sexual Assault
I'm choosing to drive to my family from here on out. I don't care that it takes 2x as long and is more expensive and hard on my car. I will not subject myself to this.
Is no wonder that more and more Americans are choosing not to fly. Choose trains or carpool if possible!
This is LETTING the terrorists win... come on get it together!
unless my name pops up on the No-fly list, keep your nasty hands off me! And no, I will not allow you to scan my image!
WE ARE NOT AFRAID
I just want to fly without getting hassled any longer. I would consent to a battery of background checks, etc if I could have a nexus type of fast lane that got me through security quickly and with dignity. Just like nexus, if you break the rules, you would lose it.
TSA's practices hurt everyone, including the TSA.
If I'm going to pose nude, I'd better be getting a check from Hugh. Keep your paws off of me, TSA.
If I must fly, I will, but I will do my best to find alternative transportation. When I do fly, I will request a PUBLC pat down so everyone sees what they do. This will not stand.
Unnecessary x-rays or molestation should not be our only options.
Paranoia
There are other ways to properly search a person. Such as the air suction technology that some airports already have. You can see if a person has anything under their clothes. And a regular pat down with this would be just as effective.
This seems like unreasonable search to me. Start another site about the unrestricted ability to seize personal laptops at the border!
Stop these ridiculous invasions of our basic privacies
Once again, I stress that this is a violation of our 4th Amendment rights! Please consider this!
I already glow with radiation. Is this really necessary?
If they want to touch my junk, I'm charging them 0 plus a convenience fee just like everybody else.
I opt out.
I went thought the backscatter machine without knowing it over the weekend. By the time I realized it, I was already being bombarded by its X-rays I wish that TSA would take more time to explain what they are doing...actually, I wish TSA provided reasonable security as opposed to the charade they go through now. Good article on how Isreal does it: http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
As long as these machines and invasive groping are completely removed from the airports, my sons and I will be driving!
This is just another example of TSA's desperate, random, reactionary policies. TSA is and has always been a disgrace. I would suggest training qualified employees instead of relying on a machine that so absurdly violates privacy and personal space.
Israeli security has this figured out. No need to reinvent anything, just copy what they do.
I am making the commitment NOT to fly until these excessive "security" measures are brought to reasonable terms. My dignity is a basic human right which I will NOT sacrifice for bullying under the thin veil of "security".
Whatever happened to innocent until proven guilty? These scanners treat innocent civilians like they are criminals! Not to mention they are causing so much fear and anxiety for passengers. People may fear flying but they should never have to fear the security check procedures.
Clearly, fascism is alive and well in this country. Perhaps we should all dress accordingly when we fly: (a plug for the holiday travel attire, not the site): http://www.cafepress.com/tsagetoffgeton
Another good reason not to fly. I have to say, this whole security thing is getting out of hand. Are we going back to the Bush Years of the New World Order?
People are disgusting. Some might try to sneak through by placing an object in a private place so that it cannot easily be found, but just because people are that sick minded, doesn't mean that every flyer out there should have to submit to having a humiliating scan, or a violating pat-down. That is also sick.
Fear is self perpetuating. The TSA creates fear and then exploits it
While certain security measures need to be in-place to protect the crew and passengers aboard our nation's airlines, there is a limit to what should be considered just and reasonable. Most of these invasive security measures do little to further any real security.
The TSA needs to be more accountable to the public.
I will not fly until you stop treating passengers like criminals.
I've got metal replacements for both knees and both hips, so I'll get groped every freaking time I take a flight. Do I feel safer? Not at all. Do I feel violated? Absolutely. It's fucking bullshit.
Israel uses humans to secure their airports. Let hire some humans to do personality scanning for us instead of potentially harmful machines.
We too will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are halted.
There's got to be a more dignified way to secure our safety in the air.
I am concerned after reading reports that some attractive flyers are being singled out for this additional procedure for the apparent pleasure of TSA staff. Some of these flyers are under 18. It's creepy. It needs to stop now.
TSA has taken more, and more, and more of our rights away. They have crossed the line; we should have required that they desist earlier. Given the odds of a bomb being on a plane, vs. the odds of cancer in my family, I will take the odds of dying in a plane explosion.
I am boycotting flying entirely until this is changed, and the powers of the TSA are carefully restricted to within the law.
Security, yes. Perhaps we need to have a national voluntary strip-naked-at-the-airport-day to demonstrate the ridiculous nature of the TSA's unnecessary searches.
I used to run these scanners at an military entry point in Iraq. They should not be used in our airports. The TSA has crossed the line.
This is going to be the issue that gets politicians fired next election.
Our rights have been violated enough since 9/11
This is such a violation of our rights!!
I used to fly often, always was amazed at the lack of consistency between airport security, this one take your sweater off, that one leave it on. It's a joke. Now xray-ing and groping is all of a sudden the only way to keep us safe. What a joke. I have no desire, nor intention to fly again unless absolutely necessary, how insulting and humiliating. Do you want your 11 yr old son groped by "professionals?" No thanks.
I personally experienced the TSA perverts who want to take pictures of you naked... First they stared at my boobs the whole time in line, then they made sure I went into the scanner. Didn't even know I had the option to say no. I felt very violated. I actually feel LESS SAFE with the TSA!
I wouldn't allow someone I don't know to take naked pictures of me or touch me in this way normally, it seems unreasonable to have my government do it to me. The choice "be searched or don't fly" isn't reasonable for some people (without driver's licenses, cars, ability to reach trains or long-haul buses), and results in forced coercion, not consent. I'm ashamed of our government for allowing this to happen. Thanks for killing my love of travel and potentially stopping me from contributing to our economy by flying and traveling.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons...against unreasonable searches...shall not be violated"
Ever hear of probable cause? If you don't have it, hands off!
When the U.S. Government dismantles DHS and TSA, only then will sanity begin to be restored to airline travel. Wasting over 1 trillion on Whole Body Imaging (which can store, transmit, and print images, despite TSA claims to the contrary), along with seizing gels and liquids over 3 oz. is patently absurd, and has never caught a terrorist, much less prevented a potential terrorist. WBIs have not been proven safe; they expose travelers to far more radiation than previously admitted, and the effects are cumulative, resulting in skin cancer, cataracts and other abnormalities, especially among children and the elderly.
Aside from those facts, TSA screening methods are just an exercise in security theatre; no security is gained, while people blindly acquiesce to invasions of privacy and other civil liberties.
Homeland Security and TSA have gone way too far this time!!!!!!!!!
As citizens, when were we given the option to vote for or against this horrible invasion of our privacy!? The TSA is undermining all of the difficult victories towards FREEDOM we have made since this country's inception. The TSA hides behind a false promise of "enhanced safety" and as we all know, the only safe place in life is IN A CAGE.
We, as Americans have the right to travel without being demeaned or humiliated by any government official. The reactionary solution provided by the Department of Homeland Security do not assure security as they are implemented after a terrorist threat, one which will not be repeated as it failed. The further you restrict our freedoms and violate our dignity, the more you change our way of life. As this is what they want, congratulations: You have let the terrorists win.
Unless the public STOP flying all of this will fall on deaf ears. We all know money or the lack of it for the airlines, is the only thing that will get their attention.
Stop looking for weapons, look at the way people act.
This is a horrendous violation of human rights. I am extremely dissapointed in the actions of my government and I will opt out every time I fly.
Stop Trampling our constitution!
I have 3 primary reasons.
1. Our Privacy should not be invaded, we are not communist or Utopians.
2. People pay good money for a flight, they should not be harrased, especialy to this extent.
3. I Don't want Terrorism to win.
We are not criminals. Do not disrespect our bodies as if we are.
I am a Flight Attendant and have gone through a 10 year FBI background check. These methods should NOT be used on Flight Crew members.
I will not fly again until the useless TSA security theater is removed from our nation's airports.
We are becoming a paranoid police-state. Stop the madness before it's too late.
There is other ways to protect our security then with these practices.
Don't touch my junk.
There are better ways. Consider Israel and their methods.
I won't fly until they come up with some other method of security. If not, well, I'll drive.
Continue the fight!
It is completely absurd that there is an exemption for Muslims because it is "against their religion" to be seen naked or to be touched in that way. Well, you know, I'm just a plain ol' Protestant Christian, but it's against my religion too! I'd like the same respect that the Muslims get!
Napolitano must resign. Period.
I don't want a stranger looking at me. But my teenage daughters & son too? That seems illegal.
Please stop these unreasonable searches. The backscatter machines don't work, and these extra searches aren't the answer.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Stop with the groping!
"Do you know why Israelis are so calm? We have brutal terror attacks on our civilians and still, life in Israel is pretty good. The reason is that people trust their defence forces, their police, their response teams and the security agencies. They know they're doing a good job. You can't say the same thing about Americans and Canadians. They don't trust anybody," Sela said. "But they say, 'So far, so good'. Then if something happens, all hell breaks loose and you've spent eight hours in an airport. Which is ridiculous. Not justifiable..."
http://chasingtheflow.tumblr.com/
Worthless security theater at the expense of both our rights and our dignity.
I was fine with occasional scanning. I was fine with occasional pat downs. But now it is to invasive, and to harmful for those in the airline business. Pilots are professionals and patriots and should not be treated like criminals.
With all the FBI, CIA, and police to work to find the potential threats BEFORE we come to the airport. It's time for Americans to be free to fly and not be molested. I quit flying because you!
It's wasting valuable time and extremely humiliating.
Saftey first is the mantra preached in all lines of work, yet x-ray scanners are somehow off the hook. I'd rather have a terrorist attack than the whole nation having cancer.
The TSA has yet to stop a single terrorist. These measures are nothing more than security theater and a means to scare the general public.
TSA goons are *not* security professionals. They have no more authority than mall cops. Like bullies, they abuse their power.
What would Ben Franklin say and do?
Enough is enough! I will NOT fly again until there are NO invasive x-rays and NO invasive & unethical pat-downs. We are ceasing to be the land of the free.
People shouldn't be afraid of their governments.
The measures are just for show, unnecessary and ineffective. You'd be better to train and hire smarter agents.
We can't even trust the TSA to not pilfer our luggage, but are expected to believe they'll only use these machines responsibly?
The money would be better spent on training TSA employees to read body language and ask the right questions of the travelers they feel are suspicious. No single machine will ever replace clinical judgment.
Those who sacrifice essential freedoms for temporary safety deserve neither
As a former airport worker, I protest the fact that the most stressful part of flying happens before you ever get to the airplane. The current state of airport security does NOT make us safer!
There is nothing reasonable about this escalation. There is, however, mounting evidence that the forcible introduction of these procedures is the direct result of lobbying by the makers of the systems involved. The measure is being supported not by well-considered evidence, but in exchange for donations to sitting government officials, and lucrative sinecures when they leave office. As such, this gross violation of the 4th Amendment isn't simply the result of dim-witted incompetence. Rather, it's the foul issue of corrupt government.
National Guard soldier against invasion of privacy/ infringing on our freedoms.
Flying next week and really not looking forward to my choice of unproven radiation exposure, or sexual assault as a precondition to getting on the plane.
Please stop treating citizens like criminals.
I will not fly until I have the guaranteed option of not being scanned or sexually molested.
I am quite tired of this absurd "security theater" we are forced to be a part of.
I will not fly through any airport that allows this unlawful, immoral and indecent assault upon lawabiding citizens. This is an outrage, and I have had enough!
if this continues, I will refuse to fly.
this laws violates any privacy we have left and strips us all of our dignity which we hold close
Stop fighting the "last battle."
I haven't flown since before 9/11 due to family circumstances which have now changed. I would love to begin taking trips again; however, these invasions of privacy are discouraging me from doing so. I believe in modesty and do not think it is right to subject people to virtual strip searches or to being felt all over when there is no reason to suspect anything. You should be focusing more on scanning packages instead of taking nude x-rays.
I wear a silver bracelet that I cannot remove. Because of this, I have been subjected to the "pat down". It is beyond humiliating. The TSA perform this degrading act in front of any and everyone in the security screening area. As someone who was a victim of rape, I hope you can see why a stranger touching my privates in front of a crowd is at the least traumatic. Please put a stop to this insanity. Let me have my dignity back.
I simply refuse to fly under these conditions, which is heartbreaking because I currently live overseas, and don't know when I will see my family again.
I work as a flight attendant for a public airline and I would feel comfortable if passengers did not have to go through such invasive screening.
I will not fly again while these procedures are in effect. What kind of a country guards against terrorism by treating its citizens like terrorists.
this isn't the change that I wanted
I opted out, without drama, at SFO. Took only a minute more than the person in front of me who didn't opt out.
We shouldn't have to pose for porno or be sexually assaulted just to fly somewhere. Is this even America anymore?
There is no evidence that the strategy has worked; and there is no suggestion that this will work. These searches make us less secure, not more.
The TSA is out of order and run by a bunch of morons. Fire the whole bunch and start over with a new sane program.
This is going too far.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Will not fly until scanners are removed and the intrusive pat-downs are eliminated.
Stop this insanity. I would NEVER want my daughters, nor myself, to be forced to go through such a degrating, invasive procedure. Nor do I want some guy in a back room ogling naked scan photos of my daughters. How disgusting. Can this "civilized" and "advanced" country of ours not find better ways of ensuring security?
As a survivor of sexual assault, I am afraid to fly until this is revoked.
I will not fly again until the groping and invasive scans stop.
I fly a lot and find the TSA experience degrading and unacceptable. At least if I have to have my junk touched, let it not be a man !
I want to travel, but I don't want to become a pr0n star or be violated.
Booo, booo, I say.
This is not a matter of security. For years security experts have criticized this kind of ineffective 'security theater'. Stop groping people!
I will not fly until I do not need to put my body in danger of further exposure to radiation. What's more the degrading and dehumanizing effect of your sick and twisted idea of "security" is offensive to every citizen of this country. I will not lend my support in the form of dollars.
14
I will not fly until they respect the Constitution, guess I'l be driving for a long time.
We get enough radiation from our cell phones, required medical x-rays, and naturally occurring onces from the sun. I don't need yet more radiation exposure to my body especially when this is not an effective way to enforce security.
I am retired so I plan to drive on all vacations etc.
Opting out every fight I get "randomly selected", and will encourage all friends to do the same
Little by little, more power is being granted to the Government over the people with our acceptance and complicity. Time for the foot to fall.
Stop violating our 4th amendment rights.
I am not against pat downs with probable cause, but feel the Backscatter X-ray or aggressive pat down regime is unconstitutional.
Please pay attention to this.
To presume everyone is guilty until proven innocent is in direct conflict with the very basis of what this country was founded on. The actions of the TSA and government only
offend the innocent and drive the terrorist further underground. We are submitting to a police state and delivering our rights on a platter to a reactionary mentality that only serves to discriminate against everyone and fails to protect as new methods are derived to circumvent procedures imposed.
Totally inappropriate, invasive, and degrading!
God bless America
Those who would... give up their rights for safety will soon find they have neither.
First, the safety of the x-ray machines has recently become an issue with many research scientists at UC San Fransisco. They claim that the level of ionizing radiation emitted from these machines is dangerous since the majority of energy is delivered to the skin. While I am young, and not yet at the particularly high risk for the mutagenic effects from x-rays, I am female and do not think it is acceptable for my risk of breast cancer to be increased by my decision to fly in an aircraft. If you have not read their letter I highly recommend you to do so. Furthermore, these scanners save the images they have taken. Not that having strangers, even briefly, see a greyscaled naked image of you is enough reason to be disturbed. After all this, they are not even infallible.
Second, the opt-out procedure. While it is not physically dangerous, is psychologically demeaning. Having security agents, although respectful and perhaps even apologetic, touch your primary and secondary sexual characteristics is something that should be done only under probable cause and during admission into prison, not at the airport to millions of innocent people. This is a major violation of personal rights and should not be the alternative to health conscious travelers.
Third, I may reconsider the necessity but not my emotional reaction to these procedures if they actually protected people from terrorism. However from what I have seen from the news, one man places explosives in his shoes, we all now and forever must remove our shoes, another carries liquid explosives, we can no longer carry water, or a reasonable amount of shampoo, another man places explosives behind his scrotum and now we must submit to groping or being virtually strip searched. This is not security it is reactionary nonsense, in that somehow we are protecting ourselves from techniques that have already been done. The only three things that have increased air travel safety since 9/11 are increased intelligence and old fashioned police investigation, which is done before the terrorist even gets to the airport, increased public awareness (from what I know all terrorist attempts in the actual plane (that have passed through security) since then have been stopped by perceptive passengers), and the inaccessibility to the cockpit.
While I realize that these scanners are promoted for increasing passenger safety, I disagree and see it as security theater. They only cause the public to think they are safer while not actually making flying safer. Humans are notoriously terrible assessors of risk. We remember the rare terrifying events and must feel safe even if the things we think make us safe do not.
Frequent Flyer
I'm flying in January. Please straighten out this shit beforehand. Thanks.
The power of the Government is out of control. Look to Israel, they don't violate innocent people for fear of offending the real terrorists, Muslims.
We also need to stop pat downs of our children
I will not fly until you get your heads out of your ass or allow yourself to be subject to such searches first.
http://www.google.com/finance?q=OSIS
I will only fly if I absolutely have to. Otherwise, no vacations for me that require an airplane.
As I am a minor, I have no control over whether or not I fly. I can only hope that I will not be molested without my consent by the TSA.
Body scanners and groping have to stop.
Every new public revelation leads to a change of story from the TSA, leading me to believe that I cannot trust my government in these matters.
I refuse to fly unless these invasive machines and pat-downs are removed. They would not have prevented any of the previous terror attacks and are illegal by our own constitution.
I will not tolerate this abuse of my Constitutional rights. I'd WALK before I'd fly under these conditions.
this situation is outrageous and violation of the 4th Amendment
If Israel doesn't need these, why do we?
Both options are excessive.
I have no intention of flying until these scanners are repealed and the TSA disbanded.
These policies are a greater threat to our liberty and the principles that make our country great than any terrorist attack.
Terrorists sure are doing a good job making us feel scared and nervous... In the meantime give up more freedoms right? All for the greater good? Sounds all to familiar...
It is shocking that anyone in the US Government would NOT consider this a violation of the constitution of the US. Saying we cannot fly if we do not select one of the options is extortion as well.
This will not stand.
I am required to fly for my job...so it is imperative that this unconstitutional injustice be stopped immediately. Thank you.
Backscatter X-Ray machines are un-American and go against the spirit of the 4th Amendment.
I'm done flying until these abhorrent machines are removed. I had to watch my 10 year old daughter get patted down just so we could return to the country after Christmas. If Israel can have the safest airport security without this humiliation, then so can we.
Rote procedures and zero-tolerance policies are not going to elevate low-quality TSA hires into intelligent, observant guardians of the skies.
Manifesto(s)
I will not fly.
Sick.
Airline Pilot.
Please stop this insanity. Talk to the Israelis about security. They laugh at us.
As a business flyer who has been hasseled by the TSA since the beginning, how about giving us a break please.
TSA doesn't make me feel safe. Can I scan them or pat them down??
No flying for me until these unreasonable, unconstitutional acts end.
flight attendant
"If we act like a terrorized nation the terrorist will have won!"
Abolish TSA. How's that for deficit reduction?
This is a horrible violation or rights and privacy. The government has gotten this one wrong. Way wrong.
These searches and scans are unconstitutional and a violation of the Fourth Amendment. Moreover, this is embarrassing to the global community. Let it be known that with these new procedures, with very serious detriment to one's physical and mental well-being, the terrorists have won by taking away our rights. We are now guilty until proven innocent. America, land of the suspicious and home of the terrified. Is this what the Founding Fathers had in mind?
Stop the security theater. Instead, spend it on measures that prevent possible attacks long before they arrive at the airport.
Couldn't possibly subject myself to these new procedures. No way.
Cancer and groping, not fun.
I am appalled by the lack of common sense of leadership in this Federal Gov't who not only have created policies to save face rather than solve issues, but in creating those policies have completely disregarding both genuine public safety and 4th amendment.
I experienced my first full body scan at the Kansas City airport last week and I found the experience both humiliating and degrading. I had to remove more parts of my clothing including my belt, watch and all items from my pocket including my wallet that I have never had to remove before In years and years of Air Travel. I am appalled that the TSA "security theater" has devolved into the equivalence of a sexual assault!
Israelification.
I feel profound disappointment in my country.
Please don't put me through this humiliation.
Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
I will not subject my wife, children, or other family members to this unsafe, humiliating scan. There are safer, non-invasive alternatives available. Please use common sense and don't give in to the politics of fear.
The increasingly invasive measures put in place by the TSA are doing little more than increasing the level of contempt for the TSA, and nothing to improve *actual* security. Particularly given the lack of security within the TSA's own staff-base itself. Subject the agents to the same publicly humiliating scans & pat-downs each time *they* enter the secure areas of an airport, and perhaps I'll consider flying again sometime.
There is always a trade off between freedom and security and we have crossed the line that is acceptable. What is "security" if the actions taken to ensure it themselves endanger the rights and well being of the people supposedly being protected?
The backscatter imagery and the opt out pat down is a true violation - not just of my rights, but of my physical person. Providing "security" should not be an excuse to ignore the constitution.
If an organization of the government refuses to follow the constitution, then what was the point?
As stated in a quote attributed to Benjamin Franklin: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
The only people terrorizing us now are the perverts and fat cats of the TSA. Buying a plane ticket is NOT an automatic consent to bodily harmful and physically/emotionally invasive searches. Rape survivors, cancer survivors, pregnant women, all of us have to make a decision between harmful and disgusting options in order to travel. It is sick. How do we explain to little children that this absolute stranger is going to molest them but its okay because the government says the stranger has to touch you? Sick. The TERRORISTS have won.
The Constitution of the United States is designed to protect the government from the people, when government oversteps its bounds, it is that governments existence that becomes threatened. We the people have had enough of your running roughshod over our rights. Stop this nonsense.
The scans can cause skin cancer and the pat downs are offensive. STOP THE MADNESS!
Security should be a reasonable deterrent, not an industry built around how to violate us all without actually stopping people who are truly determined to commit acts of terror.
I do not plan on flying from the U.S. until this stops.
Why can't we have successful screeners like in Israel??
I am appalled with y'all and the entire government!!! No one has the right to infringe on our civil liberties. If y'all are so worried about protecting us, then pull all troops out of every country, so we can quit policing the world. I'm sick and tired of my rights being taken away!!
A nation that would trade liberty for security deserves neither. I don't even believe any of the very serious liberties we're giving up yields one bit of security. This is out of hand.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Why not have a safe fly list for known honest citizens?
Profiling is the way to go ask Israel.
It's embarrassing as hell that we even need to say this.
This is a country by the people and for the people. Forcing me to be fondled or viewed naked implies that I am owned by the government when the opposite is true. The government serves at the will of the people.
While I personally find these policies merely irritating, I see that there are those who find them truly traumatic (rape survivors, young children who have no capacity to understand, people from more modest religions and cultures). For the sake of all of us, remove this ridiculous security theatre.
Security theater will not change statistical facts. The most dangerous part of your flight to anywhere in the world, will be your drive to the airport. The TSA knows this, but if they were to respond to these threats appropriately, what would happen to all of their superfluous jobs? They would vanish along with the threat.
I will not fly until these procdures are removed, and those responsible for these violations of American civil liberties are punished.
Come on, Janet and John. Strip down for us while I give you a little "feel" - you show us yours and we'll show you ours!
When did my genital become an issue of national security? What law has been enacted that we now must all become exhibitionists without our consent or wish, at the forfeit of flying if we don't present it all? When did a full-contact frisk and a grope become permissible while we are presumed innocent in this country?
How many lobbyists are going to visit your offices to push the sale of more of these devices? You're following the path of the FORMER DHS head who now works for a company who sells this junk to the government. KICKBACKS!
The TSA's goal should be efficiency and security, NOT humiliation and incompetency. Improve!
Treat the citizens with the respect they deserve. Stop the intimidation. I do not want to be treated like a criminal every time I fly
The entire budget of the FBI is almost equal to that of the TSA. Think about that for a second.
I have one word for everyone, "Israelification". Israel went through this same problem 50 years ago, and guess what? You can get through an Israeli airport in less than 30 minutes. They have the safest airports in the world, and you would never know you were being watched.
The TSA has never caught a terrorist. Not One. Ever.
I will not be flying until this nonsense is stopped.
I have had cancer. I do not need more x-rays. These searches are in violarion of my 4 th Amendment rights and a health hazard. In addition these searches are humiliating.
This does not improve security. Forfeiting privacy for a false sense of security is a dangerous and un-American slide to our liberty.
The terrorist have won & you've handed them that victory.
Those who give up liberty for security deserve neither
These machines do not protect our citizens or our country and only serve to humiliate the populace. How did the US government end up becoming the world's largest pornographer? It's despicable.
Traveling soon, hope I don't have to deal with the choice of certain cancer or molestation.
There is no room in a free society for a government agency to arbitrarily enforce a surreptitious security policy under threat of force and financial loss with no means of recourse.
Hello ? Why not conduct airport screenings like Israel utilizes ?
… in other news; Airlines continue to struggle to turn a profit. Some fear another a government bailout on the horizon…
My mother and father were concentration camp survivors, and were forced to parade nude in front of the SS. I will not fly until these machines and gropers are taken out of the security line.
These searches and scanners go to far. They are disgusting and violating.
I am sickened by these invasive measures. The person responsible for this should know that because of them invading the privacy of American citizens children have already been molested in these pat downs and women are being groped innapropriately. Are you also paying for counseling for those of us scarred by these measures?
I will certainly avoid flying as much as possible while this is in effect.
Please use your power to focus on actual terrorist prevention measures, like screening cargo! It pains me that we have allowed terrorists to make our nation cower in fear like this.
The TSA procedures are an embarrassment to courageous Americans.
I won't fly until there's no danger of my 5 yr old daughter being sexually assaulted by Government employees. America ought to be a shining example of freedom and liberty, not a laughing stock.
We can have better security, without the radiation. Look at tel-aviv.
Please take this seriously. It is a violation of our rights to privacy, and it does not make us more safe.
I have experienced this horrible violation of rights firsthand. I find it overly invasive, immoral, ineffective, unnecessary, and un-American. Please stop subjecting our citizens to this despicable process -- both the backscatter machines and the "enhanced" pat downs.
Shame on this country, and especially this administration, for allowing the lowering of these standards in the name of a false sense of security.
It's not like the scanners can check body cavities. If I were serious about smuggling something onto the plane, they wouldn't find it without an incredibly invasive search. But if we don't stand up to current policy, how long till body cavity searches become SOP?
Enough with the worthless, wasteful, idiotic security theater.
It's sickening that this kind of thing can happen.
After my experience with "special screening" I will not fly again until these useless and horribly invasive techniques and equipment are removed and TSA agents are trained in the proper procedure for a real pat-down used for *security* reasons, plus effective oversight of TSA agents to ensure the watchers are treating passengers as human beings instead of "young female" bodies.
It's time to end this charade. I dread the inevitable day when someone simply blows up a line of people waiting to go through security.
"We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
We WILL protect our constitutional rights against this and other illegal governmental encroachments. Remind the President he told the People of the United States of America that he would repeal the "Patriot Act" as well. The Will of the People will not be denied.
The TSA and their Backscatter Machines are a complete waste of time and resources and an invasion of personal privacy. There are far more sophisticated and simpler ways for terrorists to smuggle weapons into an airport[Assuming, as the US government does, that they would actually want to try the same thing twice]
Does our own Homeland Security not understand the point of the element of surprise?
This is not ONLY an invasion of privacy, but a waste of valuable resources.
In every public interaction we trust the sharp eyes of law enforcement and the common sense of our fellow citizens to spot and report suspicious behavior. Air travel should be no exception and I will refuse to fly any distance that can be driven so long as these police-state measures are in place.
Does the Bill of Rights mean anything to you morons? Keep violating the 4th Amendment, let's see how long it takes for fed-up citizens to start taking advantage of the 2nd.
This is an OUTRAGE!! I remember when being an American meant we were FREE.
This is the height of ridiculousness. I'd get pulled over for being brown and then subjected to this kind of crap. I AM A PROUD US CITIZEN! I HAVE RIGHTS AND I WILL FIGHT FOR THEM!
I will be avoiding flying as much as possible while this is going on, which is not good for the economy. This whole fear-induced program is a national outrage.
I have been screened so many times by these machines and on top of that, receive some sort of partial patdown. This is degrading.
This is a disgrace. I will not be strip searched without a warrant and give the opportunity to have my naked image saved and broadcast like has just happened to others. This is not an effective method, and is degrading.
In the eyes of the TSA, everyone is guilty until proven innocent. They are indifferent about the options, either let them photograph you nude or let them touch your genitals. If they like what they see and feel, they will let you proceed to your flight.
TSA is a total fraud, a tool to keep the fear level up, vistors away, and citizens totally subjugated. Enough of this crap already, it is total Security Theatre. TSA employees are illiterate thugs.
Casting my vote for dignity.
Let's put an end to security measures that degrade us and don't make us any safer.
The TSA has taken security one step too far and clearly doesn't care about the rights of our citizens. I will start opting out immediately having tried one of the scanners. Using one feels like you're being arrested.
If you would just adopt the same policies and procedures as Israel regarding air travel, problem solved. But you are more concerned with political correctness and the opinions of our enemies than you are about the rights of citizens. Shame on you.
Dont' abridge my 4th amendment rights.
The Constitution protects me from my government digitally strip searching or groping me without probable cause. I reject the notion that my privacy can be violated in order to ensure the safety of others. There is a line that should not be crossed. Likewise, when the next terrorist hides a bomb in her anus or vagina, I will not see it as my civic duty to let my government inspect my wife or daughter's orifices just to ensure the safety of others.
As a survivor of sexual abuse in childhood and violent sexual assault in adulthood, being seen naked by strangers or being touched intimately without my consent are simply not things with which I can cope. I will not fly until these invasions of bodily integrity are abolished. I am encouraging others, especially survivors (that's over 25% of women and over 15% of men in case you need reminding), not to fly until these assaults end permanently.
We do not need the AITs to have good security. All we want is for security to be like it was before 9/11.
I'm learning to fly so that I won't have to go through this.
It makes no sense to sacrifice our way of life in order to "protect" it.
Bad business for airlines.
This is what happens when morons try to catch terrorists. They target everyone except the Muslim extremists who are actually a threat.
The "pat down" is repulsive and the X-Ray is likely harmful. It makes me not want to fly.
There are times when flying is the only reasonable possibility for travel, I have done nothing to give anyone any reason to believe that I might be a danger to an aircraft. These new requirements go beyond the ridiculousness of many of the procedures introduced up to know, and into the realm of the unconscionable and unconstitutional.
The 4th amendment should be respected no matter what kind of transportation you use.
I am staggered at how the rights of people are gradually being eroded. Why! These scans would be absolutely degrading, humiliating and a gross invasion of privacy.
Having passengers that are not afraid to act (see shoe- and underwear bomber) will be more effective that a patdown or a fullbody scan. An overloaded TSA agent is still going to miss something and give us only a false sense of security and a feeling that we were violated.
I was proud to be an American, because we stood up against terrorists and championed liberty. Now, we are letting terrorists win by standing up against liberty.
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." Being groped by a stranger against my will certainly does not feel like liberty.
TSA has not stopped a terrorist attack yet. As someone who fly every week. I find them a hindrance to safe travel.
I will not fly until these procedures are abolished.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. -Benjamin Franklin
we should not be searched like this use common scence. This is not the America I know. Sad.
The erosion of the Constitution is appalling.
The TSA is the best thing to ever happen to Amtrack.
My name already gets me some extra attention (that is my name, no joke). I also have sleep apnea so I have to pull out my CPAP every time I fly so they can swab it - and no TSA agent has ever been able to explain why other than "That's the rules". They have to X-ray *and* swab it. I've done the AIT once - I think from now on I'll opt for a pat-down just to be a dick and slow things down. I'll enjoy making some TSA agent have to feel me up.
Orwellian nightmare. Shame on you.
No amount of assurance will remove my concerns over too much radiation. Sorry. I keep thinking about all those foot x-rays in shoe shops and how it was harmless at such a low dose. I fly a lot.
These procedures are disgusting. If anyone on the street did this to me, they would be arrested for sexual assault. However, because some radical Islaam's have caused problems, we all have to suffer. The radiation that we're being exposed to is also completely dangerous. Neither myself, nor my family, will fly until the scanners have been removed and the "groping" has been stopped.
Please re-think your strategy. Having my daughter's private parts fondled is not improving safety. I've been to Ben Gurian airport in Tel Aviv. They do things differently there, and sonehow it works.
Security by TSA is actually Security Theater. How about a system that doesn't treat everyone like a criminal and actually SECURES something? TSA is in the fear and compliance business.
Leave my crotch alone
Unless and until you have developed a security protocol that identifies and stops 100% (not 99.99999999%) of all dangerous activities, it is not useful. Quite simply, the security system used to screen passengers, crew and ground support is too porous for us to give up our dignity for a little extra security.
This is a violation of the 4th amendment and it must be stopped
This is a clear violation of the 4th amendment of our constitution and must be stopped before we allow the TSA to believe that its policies supersede our laws.
Please stop this violation of our 4th amendment. I am an American and thought the government was ment to work for me not to abuse me.
This is unethical and unconstitutional. The terrorists have won at the point where we sacrifice the rights of American citizens out of fear and fear mongering. Lieberman, this isn't "the world we live in." it's the world in which we, as Americans, have a voice and our voice is being ignored. Shame on you.
SSG, NCARNG and OIF II veteran.
Big Brother is here and the terrorist must be laughing.
No privacy, no peace
Ten years, Crew Pass is in use at two airports...no reason why it isn't at every airport.
This is not the way to keep our country safe.
TSA is a huge "make work program" and does nothing for security. Profiling works.
Eliminate pat downs!!
Enough is enough! The terrorist have officiall won....
The new TSA policies are a violation of my fourth amendment rights and of my physical person.
Of course, there have been unreasonable searches and seizures for years, as we go through the regular x-ray machine and submit to random searches. The whole process goes against the 4th Amendment. This is a good start, but let airlines be private, so we can choose the level of security we want!
My family and I refuse to fly when it means that we may be subject to unreasonable search where the choices are either a nude picture accompanied by a blast of radiation or sexual molestation. This is a violation of our Constitutional rights.
It's been a hassle travelling to and in the US for way too long. And it's only getting worse. Please start bringing some sense back into this...
Those scanners and pat downs do not increase security - they are simply violating everybody's constitutional rights. I hope more and more people and airlines take a stand against those unreasonable, ineffective rules. In the name of safety, just take away all human dignity. Here it is called safety measures, overseas it is called paranoia.
A backscatter x-ray machine or an invasive pat-down do not constitute a reasonable choice. I object to these unwarranted searches and the police-stat a atmosphere they create.
Please also see the health concerns related to this imaging, as discussed by UCSF faculty in the following letter: http://www.npr.org/assets/news/2010/05/17/concern.pdf
"We reiterate the act of body searches or usage of Backscatter X-Ray machines are unconstitutional and should not be conducted by any organization, especially a Department of the United States Government."
Stop the invasion of my rights
I'm worried about the health effects of the scanner and think both that and the groping, I mean "pat downs" are an invasion of my rights.
Only a country founded by Puritans would pull this kind of bullshit.
I am very worried that underpaid employees with very little training are entitled to our very private bodies in the name of safety. I have first hand accounts of groping under the clothes, and have seen the images of the x-ray machine. As a pregnant woman of a young daughter, I am choosing not to fly.
I'm lucky enough that I don't need to fly, but think of the people who have no choice because of their job or family situation. Each time they fly they are bombarded with radiation and embarrassment.
If a TSA employee makes inappropriate genital contact with out probable cause, I will have their badge #, their name, their supervisors name and I will then call the local police department and have them arrested for sexual assault because that is what would happen to me if I made that same contact. You don't get to hide behind the TSA to commit felony assault.
I am hoping we can get the ACLU to gnaw on this for a while.
Write your your representatives in congress and the senate.
Please stop this security theatre.
At some point the terrorists have won
Enough is enough.
I will not be flying until these measures are lifted.
All it takes for evil to triumph is for good people to say nothing. These new procedures are invasive, unconstitutional, and unnecessary. They may even be triggering for any PTSD-suffering victim of sexual assault. Show me probable cause for your search, or keep your hands off me.
I am moving to Europe to escape this nightmare. I found other people in the world who find this new practice offensive, disgusting and invasive.
I will not fly while these procedures are in place.
These supposed terrorist traps *do not work*. All they do is deter ordinary passengers and make them unwilling to fly, while costing a great deal of time, money, and effort. This system serves no one.
Airport Security Theatre has not caught a single threat. Mechanical failure is a far greater risk.
I am severely concerned with the medical implications of cumulative exposure to ionizing radiation from the new scanners. I appreciate the right to opt out, but there are several problems with the system currently in place - the first being that most people will choose the health risk over the enhanced pat-downs, which will increase long-term cancer rates and consequently healthcare costs that burden all taxpayers. Secondly, if the alternative to exposing yourself to radiation is to be groped and assumed guilty until proven innocent seems both unnecessary and perverse. Metal detectors and standard pat-downs (upon triggering of the metal detectors) seems sufficient. THe public outcry over the imaging/privacy of the new scans will overshadow the outcry over health concerns, but please do not interpret this as the privacy being the bigger concern. The health risks are far too important to sweep under the carpet here. To my knowledge no independent long-term studies on the safety of these new machines has been conducted, which is absurd, given that there are several medical reports of the health risks associated with cumulative ionizing radiation exposure. Please re-evaluate your position on these new measures to ensure long-term, big-picture safety rather than short-term terrorism-propaganda paranoia safety.
Good for you. Enough is enough.
I will not fly from or through airports with these scanners, nor while TSA is conducting invasive pat-downs.
This is a little to much!!! Let's have a little more common sense, this is ridiculous!
one cannot meaningfully consent nor decline the "pat-down" procedure as an alt to the x-ray screening, so this is forced assault. Also, no parent can meaningfully give consent for their child to be scanned or frisked. If they let a TSA official touch their child, then both parent and TSA agent are guilty of a sex crime against a child.
My fourteen year old daughter and her best friend will be spending Easter break with her grandmother in Orlando this spring. There is no way that I will allow either one of these children to be subjected to potentially harmful radiation or possibly touched in their private areas by any TSA Screener. I'll drive them from Buffalo to Orlando and back again before I let that happen.
I will not allow myself to be scanned or searched without a reasonable cause. I will not fly until these practices stop.
I haven't flown since the mid 90's, I haven't needed to, and I certainly will refuse to fly again until the TSA is disbanded.
I may just have a bout of incontinence when the TSA agent is doing their full body pat down. I can live with a ruined pair of pants.
Until your security actually targets people who can actually hurt me, I find them to be as laughable as the mall cop. Just because this technology is the new buzzword doesn't preclude the TSA from thoroughly testing and evaluating it. Also, most people who travel do so not to destroy the very planes they fly on, but to get from one place to another. Start to see PEOPLE and HONESTY and that's what you'll get.
No wonder tourism is down in the US. Why would anyone want to come here and be treated like this?
Scanners don't actually stop terrorists. Any terrorist who makes it to the airport has already won anyway. These machines are theater meant to make people feel safer while not actually doing anything except violating peoples constitutional right against unreasonable search and seizure. I'll be taking the train.
Israel.
We need to use Israel's and England's standards of talking with people NOT the raditation scanners. Let Congress walk through these scanners everytime they fly
Have the terrorists won? Have they succeeded in paralyzing us, our business, our freedoms, our way of life? Exactly what is our government protecting us from, if it is our very government who is violating our constitutional rights as US citizens?
As a frequent flier with status on many airlines, I have large concerns about safety and privacy. I am not a criminal, and should not be treated like one. Please focus on the the cause, not the symptoms.
I was directed to go thru the Xray machine without knowing what they were doing, forced to strike the cheesecake pose & then told that my body image "failed" and I ALSO had to be groped! And YES I am one of those quarter of American women who have been sexually assaulted/abused, as a child and I can tell you this was a VERY traumatic experience. I told them I didn't want strangers touching me and they told me they had to do it. They also told me they HAD to touch "sensitive areas". I argued, yelled, and finally submitted - sound familiar? Just like my sexual abuser, in the end I had to give in, and I cried while they were doing it. Bastards. This is insanity and will not stop any sort of terrorism and is completely unnecessary to use on people who are obviously no-where near any sort of risk group. This is insanity and it needs to be stopped. What about unreasonable searches and seizures, of our dignity. Just because they have invested in these machines already is no reason they need to continue to use them.
I refuse to fly into the US, even on a connecting flight, because of the fraud your government is perpetrating in the name of safety. I cannot understand how a nation founded on freedom has allowed this to happen, and it is my fervent belief that the security 'industry' is getting rich for no good reason by terrifying travellers into submission.
If enough of us refuse to fly rather than be physically groped, airlines will suffer, the effect on the economy will be devastating, and TSA personnel at all levels simply won't be needed....sorry about loss of job, John.
This is ridiculous and should be stopped immediately.
These strip-search scanners and groping pat-downs are unethical and unconstitutional. They're also unnecessary and absurd. That is clear to me after studying the facts surrounding the events of 9/11, and the many ways in which we've been lied to and manipulated through fear to give up our rights in the name of (so-called) increased security. Enough of the madness already!
We're tired of being treated like criminals.
I don't agree with the TSA's invasive methods used to catch "terrorists." So please respect people's privacy.
The TSA needs to actually provide security, not harass the American public!
These procedures will do less to protect our country and more to alienate its population.
Security shouldn't be about humiliating the secured, it should be about protecting them. Isrealify this system.
NO more flying until these unacceptable, medically dangerous and unconstitutional searches are eliminated.
I'm with Ben,
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.-Ben Franklin
I don't accept the need to be viewed naked or groped by a stranger no matter how much you try to make me afraid. I am not.
I will not fly again as long as I am going to be groped or subjected to nude scanning.
I will continue to urge the general public to not fly, killing the airline industry until you see our right to privacy.
This organization has done this to themselves.
This is disgusting. Let us all get together and tell government how powerful the public can be.
These measures do not make us demonstrably safer. They simply make travel more unpleasant and degrading, and put too much power in the hands of the TSA agents, who are too easily tempted to abuse it. This is not freedom.
Take a hint from the Israelis and get some effective, non-invasive, non-dehumanizing tactics.
Any trip that I can do in a car in under 24 hours, I now drive instead of fly. How many out there are like me? How much money are the airlines losing due to false security?
“Those who desire to give up freedom in order to gain security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.” - Ben Franklin
This does not promote security!
The well-known inability of these techniques and technologies to detect devices hidden in body cavities makes their utility against concerted terrorist activity ineffective, and therefore a waste of money that could be put to better use elsewhere. The trade of effectiveness versus infringement of personal rights and dignity plus the unknown long-term medical effects clearly supports termination of this program and reallocation of the funds. This waste of funds and effort, combined with the reduction of personal freedoms is providing exactly the result that the terrorists desire. Let's not let them win!
I will no longer fly until these conditions and policy are changed. I will encourage others not to fly.
This is an unbelievable and unacceptable invasion of privacy!
Israel keeps itself safe without stripping passengers of their clothes or their dignity.
I will not allow any stranger to molest me, not even if they wear a TSA uniform.
I'd rather take the (infinitesimally small) increased safety risk and retain my personal privacy.
A choice between radiation exposure and personal violation by a stranger is not a choice.
I have canceled multiple trips because of these measures. I refuse to be treated like a criminal for a false sense of security.
I don't believe the act of flying is probable cause to search...just saying.
What makes the safety and ethical concerns all the more tragic is that many security experts believe that this is just "security theater" -- the illusion of accomplishing something -- and does not actually make us more secure. The best defense against terrorists is still old fashioned detective work and communication with other agencies. The TSA's actions are both pointless and wrong.
Thanks Giving I will be taking the train - I have had enough.
TSA are raping our rites away and will make us sick. Radiation causes cancer!
If a terrorist is determined, molesting innocent passengerrs will not stop them.
We are human beings, not living weapons, and we are to be treated as such.
You've just crossed the line from "unbearable" to "unconstitutional."
Give up the expensive security theater and do something real and effective. Fear is your only successful product and we're not buying it.
Being groped against one's will is SEXUAL ASSAULT. What is wrong with you people?
Profiling was a lot more acceptable to being viewed naked or grouped by strangers. I will never agree to either.
will not fly until all scanners are removed and strip searches are stopped.
This does nothing to protect our safty and simply humiliates citizens. I'm happy to trade a slight amount of security in order to travel with dignity. The TSA is completely out of control.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -- Benjamin Franklin
As a physician, it scares me that we'd expose millions of people to this untested technology. Especially when it's so ineffective.
I will NOT fly again until something is done about the out of control TSA... Frisking 3 year olds and Nuns is Ridiculous....
The fact that the machines miss items stored in body cavities AND miss powders, liquids, or items not clinging to the body, makes this a complete (and outrageously expensive) farce. Is the Office of Homeland Security implementing mandatory body cavity searches next?
Or maybe lots of female, middle-aged schoolteacher American citizens like me *have* attempted in-flight bombings and it's just not making the news? Is that why we all are subjected to this?
How about using the money towards real intelligence instead of on pointless measures that only punish law-abiding taxpayers? Maybe something value-added for a change? Stop being in denial for once and treating citizens like they are idiots!
I fly regularly for work. I have a family. The radiation exposure's consequences for me are not known. You force me into weekly pat downs. You're lawyering is disgusting Janet.
TSA has been getting a lot of bad press lately, and rightfully so. They need to find a better balance between security and privacy and stop treating the majority of law abiding citizens as criminals.
Dear Janet Napolitano, et all (President Obama): If the TSA "professionals" that are hired were PAID A LIVING WAGE, maybe they would learn how to behave like professionals AND make appropriate decisions and use critical thinking skills. If you think you are going to get qualified people to work for /hr and deal w/ the public and their attitudes, you are living under a rock and are clueless about managing and motivating people!!!
We will not sacrifice our liberty and our dignity for the illusion of security.
Let's spend our money on something useful and productive, not idiotic and wasteful.
The ridiculous use of airport security is obviously simply a way to get people used to being controlled. We are not that dumb, so stop it.
This is not only a violation of privacy but a violation of freedom. Forcing people to choose between being felt up or exposed to radiation is no choice at all.
These measures have destroyed personal privacy beyond a reasonable level and I don't think they make us any safer.
Stop the false dilemma of choosing either untested, invasive, and non-private backscatter scans or invasive, embarrassing pat downs. This does nothing to make the country more secure; it just grooms the public for a police state.
Its sad to say but we only have ourselves to blame. With 9/11, it left many in shock and fearful of another attack coming upon us that we have allowed our basic liberties to be compromised in the false hope of security at the airports. But hopefully its not to late to fix the problem. Petitions like this one, calls to the airlines, and eventually suing the government over such practices may make a change in such policies. Bottom line is that the TSA is a joke, plain and simple. They have taken the approached that they think they can stop a terrorist coming in, by doing these invasive pat downs and having the government spend millions on useless invasive scanners. Its invading our privacy, downright disgusting, takes up precious time on our travels and basically does nothing to deter a risk. The TSA has not stopped a terrorist in years, thats the job of the intelligence community like the FBI, NSA, CIA. (If they do their job right). First it was belts, then shoes. No cells phones, etc What if another bomber around the world is caught with a bomb up their rear ends, is the TSA going to start doing cavity searches as well? Body Scans, Body Searches and in the near future Cavity searches are just downright unconstitutional and disgusting. Enough is enough.
Much like what others have said, and well stated by Ben Franklin, "Those who give up their liberty for more security, neither deserve liberty nor security".
In conclusion, it seems that the terrorists have won after all, by making us fearful and throwing away our basic liberties.
The scanners were purchase, at exorbitant cost to the public, before they were proven to be either safe or effective.
Sorry, I just don't think this is right.
I won't fly until these machines are removed.
Enough with kabuki security already!
Require all persons that have access to an airplane (cleaners, fuelers, stockers of supplies -food containers etc) to be REQUIRED to go through the same degree of screening as any passenger of an airplane.
I'm all for stopping terrorists, but not at the cost of my dignity and freedom. If you have a warrant to search me, I will gladly submit to it, but until then, please do not violate my fourth amendment rights.
The TSA screening procedures have been and continue to be ineffective and irrelevant - The TSA agents are consistently overburdened with onerous regulations. Before the TSA attempts to invade our lives further, they should be required to earn our trust with common sense and effectiveness
This is outrageous. You're gonna treat Muslim women citizens as if they have MORE rights than the rest of us US citizens?! Need I remind you that radical Muslims are the reason we 'need' this security?!
Seriously, this has to stop!
I've always been nervous flying in fear of the pilot asking me if I've ever seen a grown man naked, and now I have to worry about getting naked, and groped pre-flight? I don't think so!
My son who is ten should not be subjected to unnecessary radiation or groping. Stop these practices now!
I used to fly several times a year, but no more. Because of these new invasive and ineffective search measures I have resolved not to get on a plane in this country until the policies are changed.
The increasingly onerous security requirements imposed upon air travellers are partly responsible for my refusal to travel by air. Nitpicky restrictions on how much bottled water and shampoo one is allowed to travel with are bad enough; being subjected to invasive searches as a matter of routine crosses a line, and is simply unacceptable. I'd rather drive or take a traim.
There are countries around the world that are in much more danger of terrorist attacks and they don't force people to give up their freedom to get on a plane. This has gone way too far...
They climbin' in your airports, scannin' your people up, tryin' to grope 'im so you better HIDE YA KIDS HIDE YA WIFE
I will not board a plane until this is fixed.
Ben Franklin said it best: Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
I can understand requiring pat downs and/or other search technologies when there is a credible threat to air traffic safety, such as roadblocks are used during manhunts. Even then, though, not every vehicle is searched.
We have become a nation whose leaders rule through and by Fear. If this is what we have become then our enemies have won. We may as well lay down our arms and welcome the enemy in to our homes.
Our Nation was founded on the very ideal that the common person should be free of the tyranny of those in Power, that Government's involvement in our personal lives and homes should be at a distance, if at all. A line must be drawn. To X-Ray our bags is one thing, that is not our person (though, even that is in violation of the Fourth Amendment). But, to be subjugated to the Tyranny of the State in the name of Security is the largest step toward Totalitarianism that this country has taken in my own memory. To have allow our persons to be subjected to physical searches that would be reasonable only when conducted by a physician, and even then embarrassing and uncomfortable for some, means that We the People have ceded any and all control of our Civil Liberties to the State.
We the People must force those we have elected to Govern to find other means of securing our Great Nation that does not entail creating a Nation of 350 Million Criminals, Guilty Until Proven Innocent.
I am disgusted and the more I think about this the more upset I become. I do not let ANYONE touch me without my pure consent, not even a hug. So who are these people to come and say they HAVE to grab my breasts and pat my vagina? NO. I am not a criminal, I have no record, I am not guilty of anything, they are not law enforcement and I don't need to submit to their searches to board a plane.
I have to travel for work, but I will refuse to go through their virtual strip search or pat downs, if that means I don't fly... then I don't fly.
I can't tolerate with some machine containing high radiation that could cause Nausea and vomiting, Vomiting blood, excessive diarrhea, dehydration, skin inflammation, fatigue, hair loss, bloody stool,open sores on the skin, bruising sloughing of skin, bleeding in the nose, Ulceration of the esophagus, high fever, slow healing of wounds, and etc. The more you fly the faster you'll die!
The TSA people remind me of the Guards in the famous Stanford experiment. The scary thing however is that most of the public DOESN"T revolt...just goes like a sheep. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
I will not participate in security theater.
perverts with uniforms
Land of the (less and less) free...
I prefer liberty over security. If this is the way it's going to be, I will no longer fly.
The "enhanced" pat downs are also sexual assault and are subject to criminal charges and prosecution. We the people do not consent for TSA strangers to sexually molest us or our children and will inform the police and file charges against anyone who does so.
I'm very much in favor of effective security. And the "submit to porn scan or molestation or face a fine" charade isn't effective security.
I will not fly until these scanners are removed and replaced with sanity.
No body scan and no strip searches!!! I am there to fly, not to get molested.
Not flying until these practices are ended.
The US looks for specific types of objects, Israel looks for specific types of people Please consider using Israel as a proven model.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Security is not an excuse to give up freedom.
Give me liberty, or give me death.
I fly regularly for both work and personal reasons. But after my last experience with TSA and the stories I've read, I'm done. It's just not worth it. I'd rather telecommute for most meetings and drive for personal travel.
I can't be the only one. TSA public relations representatives are fond of say, "if you don't like these rules then don't fly." They better watch what they wish for. We citizens may just up and stop flying enmasse. Which would destroy the industry in the interests of saving it.
US government policy has gone insane.
A potential attack on the NYC subway system could have DEVASTATING consequences. And yet hundreds of thousands of people are allowed to ride everyday without being x-rayed or patted down. Airplanes should be treated more like air trains. 99.9% of passengers are just trying to get to their destinations, not trying to blow shit up. Stop treating us all like criminals. Put air marshals on every flight longer than say 4 hours. It will create jobs and reduce delays.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin
I strongly support this petition.
I refuse to be sexually assaulted, humiliated, and dehumanized in the name of perceived safety. Shame on you for putting men, women, and CHILDREN through these procedures. I will find other means of travel until these disgraceful procedures are gone.
I will be boycotting all US Airlines until the Backscatter X-Ray machines are removed. Drug/bomb sniffing dogs are a much cheaper, safer, effective and less obtrusive alternative than the Backscatter X-Ray machine.
Invasive, dehumanizing and totally unnecessary and coupled with harmful radiation.
Security Theater needs to be stopped. If a terrorist reaches the security gates... it's already too late. All you are doing at this point is embarrassing passengers and infringing on their right to privacy.
Stop the abuse.
I will not fly to or from or through America, in large part due to TSA overreach and the airlines' compliance with them. If I can't drive there, or get there by train, I stay home.
On the bright side, since aircraft pollute terribly at altitudes vastly more sensitive than ground level, perhaps this is just a plan by the TSA to end air travel and save the environment? Go Green, TSA!
The government does not have the right to unreasonably search individuals. This must end. I will not fly until the new body scanners and invasive pat-downs are removed/banned from our airports.
100% security is impossible. The imaging and groping don't enhance security nearly enough to justify the medical risk, the invasion of privacy, or actions which anywhere else would make the perpetrator a registered sex offender.
Please stop these absurd and dehumanizing procedures.
“Those who desire to give up freedom in order to gain security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.”
~Ben Franklin
This is ridiculous and unconstitutional! Are these people out of their minds? I will never submit to unreasonable searches of any kind.
I love to travel and fly places. Now, I don't even want to with these new procedures. What is the point? If someone wants to commit a terrorist act via a plane they will find a way to do it with or without security measures.
I appreciate the work being done by TSA to keep us safe, but this is going overboard. I fly quite a bit, but have planned my next vacations to use the train and automobile. The fact is that the odds are much better that I'll be hit by another motorist then be involved in an airplane hijacking/bombing. I'll take my chances in a car rather then at the hands of a random TSA agent.
have any of these intrusive searches actually prevented any terrorist activity?
Not only will I not fly while this kind of thing goes on, but I find it to be an incredible violation of our rights, and on a totally random basis at that. It seems to me that all that's ever come of this kind of policy is to give people a chance to pick anyone out of a lineup whom they'd like to feel up or bully. It's disgusting and inhumane, and do you really expect people to continue to subject themselves to that? I'd rather WALK across country than submit to such an outrageous violation of my person.
I will not fly again until the scanners are removed.
Every day is opt out day. Protect privacy.
I'm only 22 years old and now don't want to fly because of these extremely invasive and degrading security measures. Never saw that one coming...
Thank you for respecting the dignity of Americans.
What happens when a terrorist tries to smuggles explosives up his rectum? These machines can't detect that (not to mention there has been questions about these machines ability to detect the underwear bomb as well). Are we all in for prison style strip searches after that happens? Or perhaps we'll all be in for free colonoscopies courtesy of the TSA.
With the new TSA security measures we have lost, what I believe to be, the most personal and cherished sovereignty. We no longer have the self-determination to refuse others from invading what is most personal and intimate—our bodies. Our govt has granted others the right to invade our bodies, whether it is through scanners or touch. Free speech in the form of protest is not an option. We are forced to choose between taking the flight and silently endure the degradation and humiliation of total body invasion or protest and are removed as a passenger, unable to fly.
What more can be taken from us when our own bodies are treated as property of the State?
Please refer to this effective alternative approach to airport security:
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
What next? When terrorist start transporting materials in their vaginal and anal cavities do we submit to more radiation or full cavity probes?
TSA is a distraction. Strict searches do nothing but trick the uneducated into a false sense of safety. Stop harassing passengers and re-route TSA funding into the national education budget, where it can actually stand to make a difference.
I do not expect to be traumatized by being patted down when I fly. I will not be flying until this faux-security measure is ended.
Would like to know what criteria and training these TSA agents have to be permitted to do this type of examination....and are they examined or scanned daily to make sure they don't bring in any contriband.
Illegal search and seisure or sexual assault.. I will just not fly. The drives are more scenic anyway.
I refuse to fly now. You need to remove your invasive techniques and start treating the public with some dignity.
Preflight screening doesn't work. These scanners are dangerous and strip searches are unconstitutional without sufficient cause.
This is crazy. I applied for GLOBAL TRAVELER today, and they STILL treated me like a criminal. The tuuuurrrrists are winning!
No wonder Cancer is so prevalent now, radiation is being forced on us as a means of "safety."
These procedures are unconstitutional, illegal, and ineffective. The TSA must not be allowed to be above the law.
The true terror is the police state in which we now live.
I hope these images are not being stored for further implementation of biometric technology.
I will no longer consider purchasing flights on commercial aircraft.
My parents are coming this wknd, by CAR, a two-day drive, just to avoid the scan/grope option. Wonder how long til we get scan/grope instituted at state borders??? At shopping malls? Schools?
These new search procedures have crossed the line - we still have rights after purchasing airline tickets! Our bodies deserve respect.
I wont fly. i will drive where i need to go. if someone tried to feel my crotch or boob i would slug them. i dont care who they are. there are other modes of travel.
This is an affront to modesty.
Enough is Enough - Fourth Amendment: guards against searches, arrests, and seizures of property without a specific warrant or a "probable cause" to believe a crime has been committed. Some rights to privacy have been inferred from this amendment and others by the Supreme Court.
Although I had planned trips to AZ and WY, I will not subject myself to radiation, appearing nude, and touching by strangers in any situation other than a hospital. This is a violation of my rights and there is no proof that it will stop any terrorist action.
wont fly again until these nazi tactics stop
I will not fly out of any airport with these regulations.
I will not fly while the current policy is in place.
Its unbelievable that anyone would allow these practices at all.
As an abuse victim and a recovering rape victim, I do not look forward to the option of getting the icreased pat down just because I choose not to have radiation aimed at my body. You give us, the public you are supposed to be protecting, no choice.
The entire Office of Homeland Security (U.S. version of Nazi SS)is unconstitutional. All Presidential states of emergency need to be revoked. It's not WWII any more.
I will not fly under these conditions.
trains good, planes bad!
I appreciate security. I also appreciate being treated with respect. Figure it out.
1. Bill of rights broken 2. learn from Israel 3. assuming everyone is guilty 4. You guys forgot whose country this is, IT'S OURS
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
As a victim of sexual abuse I urge the TSA to reconsider this egregious violation of my person and my 4th Amendment rights.
This is a day and age where travel is not purely optional. I travel for work and the choice between being seen near-naked by means of a method with under-researched effects on the public health or being intimately touched by a stranger either in full public view or trapped alone in a room with them is Faustian at best.
This "security" move is poorly considered at best and at its core is a gross violation of the rights of the American public.
Worst of, all this does nothing to keep us safe.
Not my teenage daughter!
All measures that are more "security theater" than actual security are wasteful, but these procedures go beyond wasteful to intrusive and tasteless.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
i am always suspicious of statistics because it's so hard to know how counting is done and how research people or data are selected. so i rarely trust numbers. so posting this link feels contrary to my skepticism of numbers. and yet i'm so tired of more invasiveness based on promoting fear.
life isn't safe. we can take some reasonable precautions. and this isn't it. (my biased view.) after that, can we just accept the fact that life itself isn't safe and take personal responsibility to prepare and prevent what we can while acknowledging that we might die from bad situations and/or bad people anyway?
sigh. disillusionment reigns at the moment. mainly because i feel helpless to stop the insanity and i'm baffled that anyone signed up for or approved this crazy-ness.
http://www.v1news.com/page4/1/odds_of_dying/odds_of_dying.htm
I was body scanned in Vancouver flying home from the Olympics. I ask 3 times to be patted down instead and the screeners were relentless about doing a body scan. I was randomly picked and did not set off a metal detector.
The government must top sexually assaulting its citizens immediately.
I don't know how humiliating me will make any part of this nation safer. This is simply a violation of our rights, and no one is safer because of it. This is out of line and unconstitutional. When did I become a suspect just because the only viable mode of transportation for me to visit family is to fly?! This should be outlawed in every place in this country.
please end security theatre at the airports now !!
The additional security is an illusion, but the Constitutional infringements and ethical violations are very real.
This is unacceptable!
Say NO to Porno Scanners!
I used to fly between 50k and 100k miles per year. I have REFUSED to fly for 13 months now. I cannot justify giving one penny to this disgusting agency.
The only realistic way to visit my family is to fly across the Atlantic. I wish the TSA would enforce actual security rather than supply actors for the daily kabuki theater at the checkpoints.
this is absolutely ridiculous
I find these increasing invasions on our rights unacceptable.
America the groped?
The world is as you create it. Not you and your colleagues... do not try hide behind a role or in a crowd. It is just you, alone. What you make is not your legacy to others, but your own eternal inheritance. Be just... yourself.
This is ridiculous! It must be stopped!
When we sacrifice our private parts for security, the terrorists will win.
We must vote with our wallets. I for one will not fly until these policies are changed.
Millimeter wave machines as well!
This form of security is far less effective than the model used in Israel. We need to *completely* change the TSA's security model from one of "security theater" to an effective, non-invasive, constitutionally appropriate one.
I never thought Id prefer to travel in Mexico than in the United States.
I'll wear a kilt... bottomless.
I work as a Flight Attendant for a major US carrier and I feel that these measures are an illusion to make people feel safe. It is invasive and illogical. They are even pulling people aside that are in the flight crews and patting them down. Tell me how watching the person who will be flying your plane being fully searched make you feel. I think that the government needs to stop wasting money on stupid things like this and find a new focus point. How is it ok for the people that work for the TSA to have full access to everywhere in the airport without ever being screened. I see them walk through the metal detector all the time and set it off and no one questions it. I also watch them sit there on their cell phones texting all the time. Now we are supposed to let these same people look at us naked and touch us?! I don't feel safe...I just feel violated!
America is now a paranoid nation that is slowly taking away freedoms from its citizens: The terrorists are winning.
This is a direct violation of my constitutional rights and my personal health.
You are "treating" the symptoms, not curing the disease.
Preventive measure are more effective than reactionary ones.
As a foreigner, I've chosen to not fly to the U.S., and therefore not spend any of my tourist dollars there. I can't imagine that I am alone in this, and I further can't imagine that the current actions of the TSA won't increase the number of people who feel like I do.
Just do what Israel does.
TSA : Theatre Security Administration
These clowns can no longer justify their existence.
I will arrive extra early, I will opt-out, I will complain.
Evil occurs when good people stay silent. No more.
This is a disgrace and a total disregard for our 4th amendment rights. The pat-downs and backscatter are only able to keep us safe from other passengers and provide no real security.
The odds of developing skin cancer from the "full body scanner" radiation is greater than that of dying from a terrorist attack.
The TSA is just a show that humiliates and degrades people without actually improving security.
“Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.” - Benjamin Franklin
Until these draconian measures cease, namely the strip searches, pat downs, scanners, and other invasions of privacy on innocent citizens, I and my family will not step foot into an airport.
I will not fly until the scanners and inappropriate "pat downs" are lifted.
Let us fly with dignity!
We need increased security, not needless harassment that does not amount to anything. The Israeli airport is a fine example of the kind of security we should be working towards.
Will not fly until the scanners are removed from use, and the outrageous molestation opt out is ended. And I would like the TSA out of US airports for good, go back to letting the airport run the operations with some common sense security operations instead of this gradually increasing humiliating security theatre that does nothing to protect America.
The scanners are ineffective at best. Motivated terrorists can surgically or rectally implant contraband which will remain undetected (scanners do not penetrate skin). Knowing that the scanners are ineffective, I fail to see why someone needs to stare at my wife naked.
I was taught to never let a stranger touch me. I plan on passing this advice to my children. I will not let anyone touch me or my family without my and their consent. I do not and will not give consent to TSA agents. I am not a terrorist and will not be treated like one simply because I bought a plane ticket!
I am beyond tired of this nonsense. Our government has done so little for us in terms of security. Stop destroying my rights.
I'm more terrorized by being sexually assaulted by "security" than being attacked by "terrorists".
Terrorists have got to be smiling right now. They stage a few attacks and then sit back and watch as our government takes over the job of terrorizing innocent citizens. We need to find sensible alternatives to these ridiculously invasive and potentially dangerous methods of screening.
I refuse to fly anymore until the TSA is removed from airports.
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.-Ben Franklin
Increasingly invasive search procedures have done nothing to increase the safety of our airlines, and everything to erode the freedoms we claim to be protecting. This needs to stop.
TSA has gone far beyond any reasonable constitutional process.
This is America, for Christ sake! Get your hands off me!
I have a feeling that Janet Napolitano and John Pistole would never allow their family or themselves to be searched in the manner that we are now being subjected to.
Let's not keep going in this direction. We're overcompensating for a lapse that occurred 10 years ago. At this rate, where will we be in 20 years?
I do not support any part of the government seeing any form of my naked body. I do not support the sexual assault allowed by these "pat downs". I do not support the trampling of my 4th amendment rights.
http://www.latimes.com/health/fl-nbcol-body-scanner-cancer-brochu-120101117,0,3026203.column
Due to the restriction put on I will chose not to fly if at all possible.
Thank you for this.
This is security theater at best. Israel has a better and more efficient method of protecting airports and airlines. TSA should copy their model.
This is ridiculous where our government who is supposed to be working FOR us can abuse the fear and paranoia instilled in us by a few terrorist attacks/attempts and use it to their own advantage to take away our civil liberties.
This is all about money and business of one person and not our safety
To charge me for a visa to visit the USA and then to grope me or use x-rays on me without any just cause is a disgrace
I will be seeking other modes of transportation until these procedures are re-evaluated. I would like to see the airlines pushback as they see sales start to drop.
I do not plan on flying until this has been resolved. Please stop the insanity now.
Live Free or Die!
I fear for the repercussions from the government and my employer for opting out of the TSA procedures. These new procedures are getting in the way of my pursuit of the American Dream and my rights as a human being as I need to travel to stay employed.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin, February 17, 1775
The only thing terrorizing the people of the United States is "security" agents employed by our own federal government, molesting and/or saving naked photos of you and your children. Napolitano and her Transport Security Administration should all be thrown in federal prison for violating the Fourth Amendment Rights of millions of Americans every day.
I used to be scared of flying thousands of miles in the air. Now I am scared of security at the airport and I have absolutely nothing to hide!
As a skin cancer survivor, I cannot see undergoing a dangerous x-ray scan, nor can I see subjecting my children to sexual assault at the hands of TSA agents.
Without a cavity probe and an x-ray scan for implants, these scanner/searches are mere window dressing. The new procedures are clearly a violation of my 4th. Amendment rights as a citizen of the United States of America. I refuse to submit to the TSA, and will not fly until these unreasonable searches are discontinued. How does a parent choose between allowing a TSA agent to view their naked child's body or allowing a TSA agent to grope their child. Sadly, when you see the pictures of children and even a Catholic nun being groped, you know the terrorists have won.
Thank you for speaking up against this organization.
As long as these ridiculous screenings are happening with the TSA in charge of security, I will not be flying.
Every step we take seems to be going in the wrong direction. Fix this now before it gets out of hand.
The simple solution, opt for the pat down, make farm animal noises while it's going on.
The TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening and I don't believe these outlandish measures are going to increase their success rate.
I will not submit to sexual harassment by the government.
I can use AmTrak or my own vehicle for travel, but I would like to be able to fly. Please stop the TSA from violating my rights.
Israel has a better system. These are useless.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." -Benjamin Franklin
I will continue to opt out in an effort to point out how unduly invasive and unconstitutional these search methods are.
"I would rather be exposed to the inconveniencies attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it."
Will not fly until these "policies" are revoked.
How do I travel then with my autistic child who I won't expose to nude scans, and who can't bear to be touched? Power gone amuck.
End this now..
Making me choose between having my 5 year old daughters photograph taken through her clothes or having her felt-up by an government employee is unacceptable!
Irradiating the populace is endangering the populace and therefore a public health threat. The US government will be complicit in giving millions of its traveling citizens and visitors cancer. Pretty horrific, don't you think. I prefer an improbable terror threat over a definite health threat.
We won't allow the TSA to violate constitutional rights for a false sense of safety.
I definitely feel less safe knowing that my children and I will be Sexually Assaulted at the airport if we refuse to be seen naked.
There was nothing wrong with the previous, already invasive search methods that needed to be "fixed" by the new method. Submitting oneself to this de-humanizing, "guilty until proven innocent" searches is simply pandering to the culture of fear that has been created in this country.
As a PhD student in human genetics, I'm fully aware of the health risks that X-rays confer. These TSA draconian policies are the reason why I won't be able to see my family back in FL this Christmas, because I refuse to take part in either health-risking or dignity-degrading procedures. Please, don't give the Tea Party anything to be right about. Get rid of this Orwellian bullshit and quit spending so much money on security theatre. There are plenty of better causes towards which this money would be better spent.
I'd much prefer the Isreali method of airport security -- trained screeners look you in the eye and ask you where you're going, have you kept your bags by your side always, etc, and look for signs of uneasiness and nervousness, etc. I felt much more secure on El Al than I ever did on an American plane.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Ben Franklin
The longterm health implications of these x-ray machines have not been tested or proven. Yet by refusing to subject my body to this untested, possibly damaging technology, I must instead subject my body to intrusive private searching? Where's the better choice in that?!
I'm more afriad of being groped and humiliated in public than any type of danger associated with flying. Thanks TSA.
Seriously, this is against everything this country stands for.
I will not fly until the TSA changes their policies
I would love to see my family this holiday season, but I refuse to put my fourth amendment rights into a 3.4oz plastic bag.
Our country is becoming a nation of propaganda indused state of fear. This is so our government can rule us in fear. I will not stand for this. I will not allow my personal dignity and rights to be taken away from me.
Take note airline industry, I will not fly if the TSA requires I submit to molestation or a nude body scan.
I don't feel that these measures keep us safer. I feel this is a gross violation of my rights.
I now have more fear of being groped by a TSA agent on a power trip then any terrorist blowing up a plane. These searches keep me from wanting to visit family back east, I should not have to feel trapped and unable to travel for fear of being humiliated in front of strangers.
I'm with Jeffrey Goldberg on this one. Security theater doesn't make anyone safer. If you're catching terrorists at the gate, you've already failed. Learn from the Israeli experience: Develop threat profiles and catch people BEFORE they get to the airport.
I would rather be free than "safe."
I refuse to fly until this stops.
The scanners are unsafe, the pat-downs are sexual assault, and neither do anything to increase security.
Terrorist plot... Success. Seems like the the TSA are the terrorists these days. Instilling a fear into our hearts.
I fly for work at least twice a month. I highly disagree with this practice and will not vote for any politician supporting the TSA!
I will not fly until this nonsense is ended, I'll be on a train.
To give innocent civilians the choice between cancer causing radiation and degrading criminal-like pat-downs is not only unconstitutional, but also inhumane.
This is plain ridiculous!
Won't be flying until they get rid of this.
"It will be found an unjust and unwise jealousy to deprive a man of his natural liberty upon the supposition he may abuse it."
--George Washington
Will never fly until the scanners and hands on searches are removed.
"I prefer liberty with danger to safety with slavery." -- Rousseau
The simple thought that the TSA has determined that being photographed naked is a reasonable requirement for flying in the United States is beyond comprehension.
If I were to perform these acts myself, I would face severe consequences.
I believe that this is common sense, since things of this nature have not been allowed to take place publicly.
With these practices becoming more common, I believe we will lose this common sense; adding to the confusion that our upcoming generations will have to face.
Buying an airline ticket doesn't mean I am guilty until proven innocent.
The use of these machines was approved following intense lobbying from their manufacturer.
My girlfriend and I are flying out of the country around March and it worries me that she is gonna be able to be legally molested by a TSA agent and all I can do is watch. Bullshit much? ID SAY SAY!!
I fly every few weeks for work, and while I've been lucky enough to bypass the scans and body searches so far, I know they're coming, and I'm afraid. That is not right
I hope this works out for you guys, and this petition better not be the only medium through which you express your outrage. Get out on the streets, let the politicians know you won't stand behind them if they let a breach of the Fourth Amendment carry through--you can change the country if you act together.
This is humiliating.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
- Benjamin Franklin
I might be north of yours, but frankly, i've had it with the draconian methods of the TSA.
Security Theater is not what we need.
Grope me, Amadeus.
Not flying until this is fixed. I'll just take the train. This would be a good time to sell any airline stocks you have.
TSA is a scam to make money nothing more. They would create an event to show everyone that you need TSA so they could abuse peoples privacy and rights.
I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death! -Patrick Henry
There is no way my kids or I will be subject to any unnecessary radiation. There is no way that some random dude will touch my sons junk. I'd rather not fly.
I am not a criminal and I do not deserve to be treated and humiliated like one. There exist better alternatives, please learn from them instead of making your own mistakes.
I've had breast cancer & reconstruction. I do not want x-ray exposure or my surgical scars revealed.
Stop eroding our rights in the name of a false sense of security!
Israel has a much better system
This is unconstitutional and needs to stop. Now.
DHS and TSA are perpetrating a fraud on the American people at the expense of our hard fought and won 4th Amendment rights. We lose our right but DO NOT get more security than you have walking down the street.
It makes me sad that I have to give up my rights in order to make travel. What next, we will have to get groped before we go to the mall? Will we need to go through the xray to get on the subway? I could drive my car in to a building, should I be patted down before I get in my car every day?
The TSA's War on Americans in the name of the War on Terror must stop. It's clear the TSA is more interested in looking busy and important than actually trying to balance security and civil and privacy rights and foster a safe environment for air travel. I'm obligated to fly twice before the end of 2010, but will not be making flights after that.
I agree, this is a violation of the rights our country has given us. It is unbelievable.
I refuse to continue shedding personal rights simply to feed into our collective illusion of security.
Reproductive defects are in a sense, being promoted by the TSA
THe agents I dealt with got upset and mocked me for asking for a glove change and for asking if having a sanitary napkin was a problem. I had a panic attack over how I was treated. THen I asked for my luggage to be given to me when I cancelled my flight and they said they didn't have to match on international flights. We're so safe right...
Canceling trips to FL and Italy for next year. Not flying until these asinine measures are repealed.
The 4th Amendment is not a suggestion.
Will not use the scanners no matter what, and will ensure the TSA is as uncomfortable as I am when a pat-down is performed. Moaning lewdly, perhaps.
The TSA scans and pat-downs are unlawful searches, and violate my 4th amendment rights as a United States citizen.
I am ashamed for the farce that airport security has become. I will not tolerate an invasion of my privacy and my rights as a citizen to pretend that we are any safer.
Clearly it is time to fight.
Security theater is not the answer.
So my choices are x-ray induced cancer risk or sexual molestation?! Thanks a lot, TSA.
TSA should require higher education of its employees and adopt an intelligent non-reactive approach to security.
Will not fly until this shit is stopped.
I am a frequent flyer that will not fly until the scanners are removed.
Israelify our check-points - it's time for direct profiling based on who intends to do us harm.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
I will not fly until these scanners are completely removed, and searches are 100% stopped. These measures could easily be considered molestation or sexual assault under normal circumstances. These measures do not make us safer, and even if they did, it would be marginal and not worth the potential health risks and privacy concerns.
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." -Benjamin Franklin
Ridiculous.
"Those who sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither."
I refuse to fly until this is removed.
This is a violation on every level.
These searches are dehumanizing; the scanner is dangerous. Both are unjustified. TSA has NEVER caught a terrorist. I will not fly until the scanners and enhanced patdowns are discontinued.
The terrorist have won... when ALL people are treated as objects of fear.
I am a amputee I set of the metal detectors all the time i get the whole nine yards. they even check my leg for gun powder like im going have a leg bomb when the search me they find my piercings and say whats that. its gets old after the 100 times so i haveto leave early just so they can play there games
Will not fly.
Janet Napolitano's position that citizens who do not agree with the procedures have the option to not fly is untenable and arrogant. To deny private, law abiding citizens access to air flight unless they submit to extraordinarily invasive search methods is wrong.
This is absolutely ridiculous, they have NO right to force this upon us.
I believe in correct usage of the 4th amendment.
We handled it fine without the privacy loss, why start now?
This needs to be pushed through.
I refuse to fly until these machines are removed. It's an outrage!
These body scanners are a disgraceful excuse for "security"
Feeling uncomfortable about flying home this Christmas to visit my family.
No one benefits from Security Theatre. Stop this nonsense.
I sign this petition not simply for myself and my privacy but for the right to privacy of every American citizen.
I absolutely WILL NOT fly until these policies are redacted.
think for yourself, question authority.
Please don't touch me there.
I also will not fly until the scanners and pat downs are completely stopped. These procedures do not make me safer, they make me feel violated.
Please don't subject me to any more harmful radiation!
Too invasive.
The constitution has an implied right to privacy and a right against unlawful search and seizure. Search measures such as this are both humiliating, and degrading but are in many eyes, sexual assault. If you really want to know how it feels to represent your constituency, just take a flight as a regular person, no fanfare - and opt out of the 'nude' backscatter device and get an enhanced pat-down. Then consider how many terrorists that the TSA have really caught in the millions of flights passengers have taken since 9/11. Terrorists hate us for our freedoms, and you've gone and taken a good part of those freedoms away from us. You are doing their job for them.
I find it sad that the way the TSA is attempting to 'protect' travelers is to subject them to devices whose health consequences are not known, to harass them when they try to assert basic rights, etc.
This show is absurd, a waste and flat out not right. Once again, Ben Franklin: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
End security theater now.
I'm about to move to L.A. from N.Y. I will be driving for this trip, and all subsequent ones until this policy is changed.
Stop violating the constitution and telling us it is "making us safer" when we know it isn't.
The US military refuses to use these invasive search techniques in Afghanistan -- a war-torn country -- because they are deemed too offensive and humiliating to the locals. Are domestic planes more dangerous than Afghanistan? Are we in the USA less worthy of dignity than they are?
We teach our children that this kind of touching is wrong. Respect America's children.
It is insane that these scanners and pat-down procedures made it in to use and are only being addressed because of public outcry and not because they are in direct conflict with the 4th amendment. It is your duty to protect my constitutionally guaranteed rights. Do your job and get rid of these scanners.
This slippery slope to a police state must end NOW. We will not stand by as the TSA continues to take advantage of airline passengers and their right to NOT be molested or exposed.
I have been patted down before and it was an embarrassing and demeaning experience. I felt extremely violated and cried after the experience was over. I will not fly again until this practice is discontinued.
Would either of you want your children or loved ones going through this process? It is degrading and a blatent breach of civil liberties; something I'd expect in China or North Korea, not the United States. The TSA does not supersede the Constitution.
I understand safety is priority, and I appreciate that, but this is not the right way.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Franklin
Real security is welcomed and does not have to be intrusive; what the TSA has implemented thus far can only be called security theater. The loss of privacy to uphold this charade of keeping people safe is completely unacceptable.
Thanks for molesting my daughter.
Thanks TSA, I am now afraid to fly and wont be doing so any time soon.
Please improve security, not security theater. I dread having my daughters fly because of the draconian rules that are a pedophile's dream.
As a Libertarian I commend your efforts and will forward others to your site. Thank you!
These machines do NOTHING for security and violate basic human decency. You need to find a better way... look to Israel for the answer.
Profile! It works!
I will not set foot on a plane till this is taken care of and come on I want to travel.
This is simply ridiculous! Why hasn't anything changed yet...?!
I'm saddened to say that I think terrorists have finally won. We are terrorizing each other now and stripping away our own rights.
This is just outrageous! Flying is already enough of a hassle and upsetting enough. I certainly don't want myself or my daughter to go through something like what is detailed here: http://www.ourlittlechatterboxes.com/2010/11/tsa-sexual-assault.html
I fly for work weekly, and I now have to submit to being viewed naked or touched by people that I don't want touching me to work!
The Patriot Act needs to die and burn.
We must stop the unnecessary tactics and procedures!
I am perfectly content with the regular metal detector, but I refuse to be forced to have naked pictures of me taken to board an aircraft.
No Scans. No Gropes. Stop lying about the machines ability to store and distribute images. Stop misinforming American Citizens that they're checking their Constitutional rights at the door.
I will be flying home for the holiday season, and may be the last time i fly in America, and may be my last straw for considering myself an American
Stop treating passengers as security liabilities and start treating them as security assets. Responsible citizens can take care of themselves and each other.
I am appalled that the images are taken and that they are kept for an indefinite time period. I am outraged that my only option, if I decide not to let strangers SEE my naked body, is to let strangers FEEL my body. This is a repugnant and irresponsible policy. You should be ashamed to support such procedures.
This process has not been proven effective, yet it is blatantly irresponsible and very likely unconstitutional.
With the use of "your" new "security", the terrorists have actually won. They have impacted our normal daily lives. What you are doing now in airports, if done at any other location, would result in a call to the Law & Order SVU police. Enough is enough - I've written my Senator!
The TSA is bald-faced government make-work. They recently tried to confiscate my hair gel at
LAX because I had 6 ounces of it in my carry-on bag (I didn't let them take it - I just put it in my hair where, apparently, it's legal).
The idea is too invasive and unsafe to even consider.
I prefer to be secure 'in my person' and not sexually assaulted by some ham-handed federal, featherbedding employee! Because of this I DO NOT FLY commercial air! ... Nor will I.
I thought I was supposed to fear the bad guys, not the good guys.
Don't touch my booty!
This is a freedom I'm not willing to give up.
These tactics do nothing but to perpetuate fear and distrust.
Please keep your hands off my junk
The TSA is bald-faced government make-work. They recently tried to confiscate my hair gel at
LAX because I had 6 ounces of it in my carry-on bag (I didn't let them take it - I just put it in my hair where, apparently, it's legal). www.daviddeeble.com
This is clearly an unreasonable search and without any cause to suspect wrong doing.
The Constitution is the moral and intellectual foundation for the freedoms that we all enjoy. Please do your duty in upholding and observing it by ending the TSA's abuse of American civil rights.
What's to prevent a suicide bomber from swallowing explosives? That won't show on the scan. We need to stop reacting to the last threat. The terrorists have already won if their actions have destroyed our freedoms, rights and personal dignity.
this feels like the same concept as getting a restraining order against a potential stalker. it's just going to aggravate people into becoming what you're afraid we'll become.
We The People, Take A Stand.
I will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
A state funded security force? 1904's Germany had one also, we all know how that went...
Strip searches without probable cause are anathema to the ideals of American freedom that TSA would purport to protect. You do not serve your citizens by dehumanizing them. Being given a choice between a stranger's eyes on my naked body, or their hands on my genitalia, is like my rapist offering me the choice of whether he will wear a condom. I have canceled my plans to fly in January, in protest of these barbarous, (and likely, ineffective) new policies.
Driving is now more convenient than flying.
This is a gross violation of rights. Train travel is looking better everyday.
This is ridiculous, I fly a lot and I've gotten to the point where I know exactly what to do to make sure I never get screened. If I can figure it out, I'm sure any terrorist could. Seriously, this is too far. Nobody has the right to grope your private areas or use X-Ray to essentially see through your clothing
Won't be flying until this stops.
We, the People are OPTING OUT. We are crossing the political divides that usually keep us apart and standing together, speaking loudly with one voice, saying "No!"
These procedures are dehumanizing, freedom infringing, unconstitutional, and wrong.
Do not allow the fear of a terrorist take away our precious Constitutional rights!
It is a sad day in American history when our leaders choose to use national security as a pretext for the forced relinquishment of God-given and unalienable rights. This includes among other enumerated and unenumerated rights, the right as a citizen to be treated with decency, respect and trust, until we have given cause to have violated that trust by our own actions. By allowing foreign and non-state terrorists to coerce our nation's leaders into continually increasing the invasiveness of inspections and law enforcement of law-abiding citizens who have done no wrong, we are giving them the power to permanently shape our government in an extremely negative and detrimental way. I have traveled many times in the past ten years, and have never been in fear of a terrorist attack on my flight, but I have always been afraid without exception when I enter the TSA screening area, not because I have something to hide, but because I am consistently treated with disrespect as if I've already committed a crime and must prove myself innocent while being verbally and physically degraded in front of my peers. But more than fear, I feel sadness because I can see where this is heading and if we don't change course soon, it will be a very sad future indeed.
I will be driving until this is resolved.
Freedom!
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
Time to stop giving up rights in the name of "security."
This is absolutely ridiculous. I don't feel the need to be groped for the illusion of security. It's been proven over and over that if someone wants to get something harmful on a plane, they will do it whether the TSA is scanning or not.
So sad to see our country and it's morals be totally undone by the violent people in the world.
This is just plain stupid - knock it off!
If this change in policy is due to a "terrorist" threat, then the "terrorists" have already won: using our own security to molest, harass and endanger ourselves.
I will not fly! This is invasion of privacy.
The United States is starting to feel like an Orwellian nightmare.
When my mom is more afraid my 12-year-old brother will be touched by a stranger than dying in a terrorist attack, we have a major problem.
I never knew just how low our government was willing to stoop in the name of security until now. Turning on the American people can not and will not be tolerated.
Seriously considering canceling all of my scheduled flights until this gross violation of civil liberties is made right.
"Those who would trade in their freedom for their protection deserve neither." - Benjamin Franklin
Sometimes I don't even let my boyfriend get that much action, let alone some TSA employed stranger. Because of this ridiculousness I recently drove 17 hours rather than take a 2 hour flight. Please, fix this.
17,000 killed by drunk driver's each year, where is the TSA security when it matters?
IF I PATTED SOMEONE DOWN IN THIS MANNER, I'D BE ARRESTED!!!!!
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
Please stop this knee-jerk reactionary security and stop infringing on our rights.
I find these the backscatter machines and the invasive genital groping to be an insult to my freedom and an obscene intrusionon my constitutional right to privacy. I, and my family will not fly until this policy is changed.
This needs to stop
Stop the erosion of my personal rights under the banner of security.
It saddens me that places like Israel face greater threats every day and have a much less invasive and more effective screening process.
Neither the AIT scanner OR the enhanced pat-down is necessary to provide adequate security for air travel. Please do not desecrate our civil liberties and the rights given to us upon the founding of this country.
This is clearly an unconstitutional practice. For those of us Americans who live and work overseas, we have no choice to not fly and give up the fourth amendment rights of our selves and our families.
No more security theatre!
This insanity and erosion of our rights must stop. I won't fly as long as this policy is in place.
Please do not require us to choose between our person health (radiation from the scanners) and our personal space.
We have the right to our space, our safety and to not be groped in the name of false security
Hello, Invasion of Privacy? Its ok to be gropped and naked scan by people just cause they have a badge? I for one would be in jail for beating the hell out of whoever tried it with my GF or kids. The government doesn't run this country. We do. Citizens do, in when they wake up and see it, this will be a different better country for all. I say america goes on strike. The terrorist caused this and american citizens are being punished for terrorists acts. Its not right, and under the laws of the US its not legal either. So now cops are nothing but pedophiles and perverts. People we are suppose to trust to protect us are now feeling up our wives, gf's and kids. I for one will never let that happen.
I don't want my penis involved in any pre-flight ritual!
TSA is the reason we will not be flying when we move to the UK. We would rather take a ship, which will take much longer, than have our bodies and our rights violated.
We should be focusing on measures that actually detect and prevent terrorism, versus ineffective, invasive actions just for show.
comletely inappropriate treatment of citizens.
Amtrak is getting a lot more business from me lately, I refuse to fly until this nonsense stops.
Once we have lost our freedoms, we have lost our security.
I will not be dehumanized.
4th amendment. Need I say more? OK:
Congress voted no these machines, the TSA spent 25 million on them anyway.
The states need to use their powers of nullification on this one.
My wife and I are opting out and will file official complaints if touched inappropriately. I suggest everyone else do the same.
Any government that asks us to forgo our rights out of fear or a perceived threat, is in fact a terrorist organization, the very thing the Department of Homeland Security and the Transportation Securty Administration claim to be protecting us from. Furthermore, to insist that practicing our rights to protest and boycott is irresponsible, is reprehensible.
This is totally unethical.
Do not plan on flying until Back Scatter X-Ray scanners are removed from use and strip searches are halted.
I've already canceled one of my flights, had my ex-wife cancel her flight with our daughter, canceled plans for a future flight with my daughter and convinced another friend to cancel his flight. I WILL NOT FLY until I can fly with dignity.
Down with this sort of thing!
My wife flies a lot for work and I feel uncomfortable allowing another man or woman to sexually assault her or stare at her beautiful nude body.
Scanning shoes and bodies and baring water is not going to stop the bad guys. Learn from Israel who's been successfully protecting their passengers for decades, without 25 million dollar machines, and sexually assaulting their citizens.
This sucks
Frequent Flyer (20-40) weeks per year and it is understood that their are always risk in flying as with everything else. Dignity for the illusion of security should not be one of them.
Creating this atmosphere of fear and desensitizing us to physical violations under color of law is letting the terrorists win. If the Constitution matters at all, and probable cause means anything at all, these invasive measures must stop and be replaced by measures that actually will enhance safety. I, too, plan to boycott flying until sanity returns to passenger screening.
I do not plan on flying period, even home to see my parents during Christmas, as long as these humiliating rules are discarded.
Canada is also afraid of the TSA. The world is watching.
Let our bodies remain our bodies and our rights remain intact.
I refuse to fly until this has changed.
The TSA is inefficient, unprofessional, and out of control.
I wont be flying for a while it seems.
security theater does not make us safer it only inconveniences us and provides for more beaurocratic nonsense. ABOLISH THE TSA! start personality profiling like Israel does.
The TSA does not have the right to irradiate me or molest me.
This is RIDICULOUS!
I would much rather that my tax money be spent on safer, more effective, and non-invasive methods of security instead of security theater.
If such power is to be handed to those in the TSA I demand that said persons have rigorous requirements to pass prior to obtaining their jobs including an advanced degree from an accredited university, law enforcement training and training in social graces. I already have little to no confidence in their ability to follow the regulations set out by their organization and none of the regulations they are purported to uphold make me feel any safer since 9/11. Instead fearmongering is being used in the name of national security and it is bullshit.
4th Amendment.* The asterisk has become bigger than what the the rights imply.
I opt out.
American Citizen's ARE NOT TERRORISTS!!!
Americans are human beings, not cattle. If security was really an issue, it would be far more effective to have armed guards on flights, rather than subjecting all passengers to invasive and grossly offensive (not to mention immoral) screening procedures.
My family and I will not be flying until the new TSA regulations are reformed.
I just keep thinking, "are people going to have to get government-issued cards that state they are rape victims?"
gross violation of the constitution
My rights, I want them back.
Never flying again until scanners are removed.
So where are all the reports of terrorists caught (statistical data) by using these porn scanners?
It's a shame this administration is expanding the police state-like tacticts of past administrations. I hoped things would change under our president - I'm sorry to see that I was wrong.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin
I oppose this invasive new policy.
Airports got along fine for years without having to see me naked or touch me in inappropriate places. I don't think we should let paranoia over terrorist attacks be an excuse for grossly violating personal privacy.
The Backscatter X-Ray machine is unacceptable. I do not agree with people seeing me naked and I do not trust that there is no radiation. I also don't think they are an effective form of stopping terrorist. What happens when terrorist ingest explosives orally or anally? This whole thing is out of control. I also will no allow anyone to touch my private parts and subject me to a search. I am an innocent person, this is unacceptable! Why not use trained dogs, which are also much cheaper. The only result of pat downs and backscatter machines are millions of innocent people are being violated, justified through fear and intimidation.
Liberty is king.
I'm all for security; however, as citizens we have a duty to point out when our constitutional rights are being circumvented. Moreover, I am very uncomfortable with the options of either being scanned (exposing my body to radiation and to the eyes of judgmental strangers) or being patted down in sensitive areas (molested by judgmental strangers). I appreciate your taking the time to read my comment and hope that you can take it to heart.
We should not be required to surrender our Fourth Amendment rights to board a plane. Many people fought and died to secure the rights offered in our Constitution and for the Federal Government to so blatantly violate those rights is a travesty. I will certainly not fly again as long as these measures remain in effect.
These security screenings are entirely reactive. It's only after someone tries to make a bomb with liquids that liquids are limited; it's only after someone puts a bomb in his underwear that we are subjected to porn machines and sexual assault. Money would be much better spent on proactive security. The TSA is a total sham.
The TSA behavior is absurd.
I would just like to plainly state that I do not intend to give up my freedom for this level of security. I understand that there needs to be a compromise but the line is very clear to me now: this is too far.
There has to be another OPTION, look to the Israelis.
This is not Okay.
Live free or die!
The TSA should be disbanded. It has turned on the people is supposed to protect.
Mandatory physical or optical inspection of regions on the human body that are culturally held private is a blatant erosion of the public's general definition of human dignity. These policies must be suspended if America wishes to be an advocate for human rights.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
It is an invasion.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin
Freedom isn't free, but degradation and fear is not an acceptable price to pay.
We are protecting nobody, instead throwing billions of dollars at the companies who build these machines. TSA has never caught a single terrorist, yet continue to get massive funding to continue developing the most expensive, yet completely ineffective security theater in history.
I am an American citizen living in Canada and I will not accept this invasion of privacy.
In the name of "protecting freedom," they [TSA] are destroying it!!
I feel like I live in George Orwell's 1984
Don't touch my junk.
Use of bomb sniffing dogs and behavioral specialists that interact with passengers (ie - check-in agent) seems like a more common sense method opposed to violating the right against illegal searches as defined by the fourth ammendment
I am planning on driving to Florida, rather than fly, for a cruise this summer
I don't remember giving away my rights, but I definitely remember when they were taken.
I haven't flown in about 5 years due to the fact I'm scared of the TSA lines.
This is an unneccessary invasion of privacy and a violation of my religious and philospophic beliefs. I am a christian and we are a modest people. There is no security risk anywhere near sufficient to justify forcing me or mine to public or private viewing or touching of our private areas. With 20 years in the military, I am not convinced that these punitive pat downs or invasive scans add credibly to air travel safety, and they do nothing to protect the homeland from terrorists. As some one with a degree in business administration and who has spent several years assisting my parent to run a family business, I am also unmoved by fallacious arguments concerning the large sums of money the government has spent on these machines, or obligated for them. This money constitutes a sunk cost, not recoverable by either course of action, and is therefor irrelevant to the discussion. These procedures are offensive, consitute an unlawful search, and of no significant benefit to our security. Please rescind them and do not re-engage later.
Maj Karl Barden (ret)
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted. Already making arrangements to avoid flying during the holidays as a result of the TSA's unconstitutional policies.
Is the Constitution optional now?
Is this Nazi Germany? Seriously.
I am relieved that driving has replaced flying for my company business. I would rather spend the entire day driving than to be sexually violated.
Even with the threat of terrorists I was never afraid to fly, now I am , but not because of the terrorists, it is because I fear being violated by the TSA, either through viewing me inappropriately, or touching me inappropriately. I would rather have the terrorists.
I am not a criminal, nor am I a suspect of a crime. I will not stand silently while you treat me as one.
Security Theater, now with porn!
We wouldn't let Mall Cops grope our children. This is no different.
Secretary Napolitano - You recently said that citizens have the right to travel by any other means.
I live in Juneau, Alaska; a landlocked city. To get out of this place within a week one must fly.
I dare you to live here for several years and see how often you can work flight-less travel into your schedules.
this is truly an outrage....
"Bad" and "worse" should not be the only available options for invasive security at airports.
This is outrageous.
Safety is worthless without dignity.
Nothing more than a power-grab, wrapped up in fear and bound with threats. SHAME ON YOU.
I received the enhanced pat down @stl, it was disturbing and humiliating for both myself and the poor tsa agent who i ridiculed for being a perv.
These "enhanced" measures do nothing to enhance the safety of flying. They are a needless intrusion on privacy and an illegal search without due cause.
I'm driving or taking a train as much as possible.
Hell no, we won't show!
My country is being turned into a fascist police state and I want America the beautiful back!
The 4th Amendment would like a word with the TSA.
Stop the madness.
CHERTOFF is profiting from this just a Guliani profited from 911. What will you idiots think of next?
Israel has found much better and less intrusive ways to secure an airport than the US.
We must strengthen our privacy laws not cripple them!
I will not fly until these policies are changed.
It should be noted that if the government truly wants an accurate description of my balls, I will be more than happy to send them pictures.
Please partner with your Israeli counterparts to speedily employ efficient airport security techniques instead of the current inefficient, ineffective ones.
Please do not let the terrorists win by making us so scared to fly that we're willing to be sexually molested before getting on an airplane.
Those who would give up essential liberty for temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety. The TSA is the most un-American institution since McCarthy'ism.
I don't like being groped.
Seems like Israel is doing something right, and they keep their shoes on.
I will not fly out of an airport with these scanners.
We are loosing our freedoms to protect them. This is ridiculous.
How many terrorists have you caught again? Oh yeah, zero.
Won't fly until there's no scanner and no strip search
I'm not going to fly until these rules are changed.
It is vehemently unexceptionable and an invasion of privacy for TSA agents to molest the public or to condone the use of non-FDA approved "virtual strip search" technology.
Here's to hoping the TSA just GOES AWAY.
I sign this on my own behalf, as well as on behalf of my daughters - aged 3 and 5, who will NOT be flying until these scanners are removed and the pat-downs are stopped.
I travel frequently for work (6-8 times a month) and will change to driving if at all possible until the TSA policy is changed.
There has to be a better way to fly then molestation.
I am afraid to fly now, I don't want to be touched and violated.
If my nieces, who are minors, were subjected to either the enhanced "pat downs" or to the scanners, I will personally pledge my entire fortune to a lawsuit charging TSA with sexual assault of minors and violation of relevant child pornography laws.
I cannot believe the irreversible damage the machines and the people of TSA are having on the American people. We should all be ashamed for not stopping this earlier.
This does absolutely nothing to enhance our safety. We've had enough of the charade of kabuki-theater safety measures. How about you focus on measures that ACTUALLY make us safer?
Embarrassed DHS badge holder.
Really, this is taking the scare tactics too far.
Constitutional rights don't stop because the TSA needs to pretend like it's effective.
I've written all the airlines, the FAA, the TSA, my Congressional Representatives and the President. I have also stopped flying until this changes.
This is a security theater, it doesn't help solve the problems. This is a completely inappropriate joke to expect people to be groped or photographed with an X-ray machine. Do you want your mother groped?
I feel that NV should "opt out" of TSA and hire our own security for our airports. We'd probably do a better job and would abide by the United States Constitution at the same time. Also, see what Israel thinks about us, they get people from the parking lot to the gate in 25 minutes!
This is totally unacceptable. I will travel to Canada and fly out of Montreal before I submit this perversion.
The illusion of safety is not worth the loss of freedom.
We put molesters behind bars, we do not employ them
Stop touching my crank.
As an Arizonan, I'm very disappointed with Ms. Napolitano's choice to defend the new unconstitutional TSA policies. I hope that she makes the decision to protect Americans' rights and repeal these policies.
Current methods of TSA security are time invasive and time consuming. Alternative methods are available and new methods should be researched.
I am just livid and will not be flying as much as I did in the past. Haven't heard of any suburban, 50 year old moms who have been terrorists in the past. Did I miss something or did the TSA just get stupid and abusive. TSA use the no fly list and leave my body alone!
I Will not be flying until these scanners and invasive pat-downs are ceased.
I will not fly at all until Backscatter X-ray (or similar) machines are removed and TSA perverts are not allowed to physically touch me without legal cause. Let the airline industry die in the wake of your fascism.
Stop stealing civil rights in the name of national security.
Backscatter X-Ray machines are a disgraceful violation of the Fourth Amendment.
Stop throwing our money away, and stripping our civil liberties, under the guise of "safety".
I will not fly until this current pat down and scan policy is eliminated! This policy is un-American, our government continues to take our civil liberties for granted. It's time for all Americans to start standing up for our rights!
Pervo-scans and forceful groping need to stop.
I have a constitutional right against unreasonable search. Flying on a plane is not probable cause that I am a criminal.
Since I have an artifical knee, I've become accustomed to the pat down. However, the new "improved" pat down is degrading and unnecessary. Theoretically my life would be easier if I used the scanner, but I do not find it a satisfactory option in any way, shape, or form... for all of the reasons given by others. Security Theater has not prevented anything. It's only given the illusion of safety to the sheep-like masses. I opt out and will continue to opt out.
An optional comment.
Stop wasting taxpayer money on ineffective, unnecessary security measures that undermine our rights.
I typically fly 5-10 times per year. I will do everything possible to avoid those trips until our liberty to travel is restored.
Stop the madness with these unreasonably invasive searches of citizens and the other totally ineffectual screening procedures. I certainly fly less because of them. Train more K-9 units for sniffing of prohibited substances, and hire more Air Marshals for onboard security. The rest of the post 9/11 gate "security" enhancements are pointless.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." - The 4th Amendment is not optional.
"At least 17 known terrorists ... have flown on 24 different occasions, passing through security at eight SPOT airports."
The TSA should not have the right to treat US citizens as terrorists until proven innocent. The scanners are a clear violation of an individual's right to privacy and his/her own body. I will opt out, every time.
Please consider this seriously. I have been a victim of sexual assault. Even the thought that there's a possibility that I could be molested by TSA agents just because I want to fly brings back many dark emotions. This is an outrage. I am appalled that I would be treated like this in my own country.
I firmly believe that the TSA policies make air travel less safe for myself, my family, and the public.
I will not fly until these procedures are changed.
It is possible to strike a balance between freedom and safety. Meaningless security theater, however, does not accomplish this. Instead, it threatens the viability of an entire transportation industry and strips American citizens of both their civil liberties and their dignity.
I plan on boycotting flying until a better, less intrusive way of providing security.
I urge our leaders in the transportation and security administrations to develop an alternative form of security screening that is less invasive and medically safer.
I know we've always been at war with Eastasia, but can't we ease up a little bit here?
You say you're protecting us from terrorists, but I believe we need someone to protect us from you
I want my privacy back!
This is SO important... PLEASE be heard by ALL.
Enough with the security theater. These policies do not make us safer and only serve to weaken our liberties.
Waste of time and resources for an invasion of personal privacy and a deprivation of individual liberties. This is not in holding with the spirit and founding principles of our nation.
No one has the right to touch me in such an invasive and oppressive manner or force me to go through a scanner of this kind. I am not against the Govt but I am for my dignity. I am INNOCENT until proven guilty. Your treatment is unethical and should not be allowed to happen ever again.
I will stop flying due to your newly implemented measures.
The TSA is doing far more to destroy our democracy than it is to protect it. I would rather live with risk and my civil liberties than to live in fear and without them.
I am forced to fly and now I have to choose between cancer and being violated by gloves that have touched 5,000 people that day. The gloves may protect the agent but they might also spread around dangerous diseases. Who knows maybe next year we'll have La Guardia Flu on top of swine flu
STOP this nonsense. Let common sense prevail.
The TSA has just gone way to far.
This has gone too far!
Don't touch me in the no-no place!
All part of the plan to keep people from traveling for better control. Make it as difficult as possible then we'll all stay home
This is all fear mongering. Burn in hell, TSA.
I will never fly while these 'protections' are in place.
I never granted the TSA consent to image my genitals. Each time I walked through a backscatter X-ray machine prior to knowing its effects, this agency violated my Fourth Amendment rights.
I fly a few times a year. Until the TSA changes their policy I will be driving or finding other modes of transportation.
We are free from the day we are born.
I support the 4th amendment to the constitution.
These rules are a violation of the 4th amendment and are generaly unamerican.
You are a bunch of jack boot thugs.
Let's put an end to these ridiculous practices.
Secretary Napolitano,
Simply stating the backscatter x-ray machines do not invade privacy does not make it true. You stated images could not be stored, yet stored images have been published online. You stated the machines are totally safe, yet the machines have never been submitted for FDA testing and independent experts claim they may be unsafe. You claim privacy is absolute, yet individuals who have submitted to these x-rays have been ridiculed for their appearance. And claims by TSA staff that they have been directed to make pat-downs as humiliating as possible shows contempt for those who disagree with you.
Naturally I expect your contempt for the will of American citizens would continue unabated even if every single American citizen signed this petition. Therefore I am also writing my congressional representatives and encouraging everybody else to do the same.
I am disappointed that my liberties and privacy were deliberately seized by my government. I would gladly forfeit "security" if it meant I wouldn't have to be exposed or, worse, sexually molested by the TSA.
We've been complacent with ridiculous demands from TSA long enough. We're citizens, not prisoners!
To quote Ben Franklin,
"Those who sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither."
I'm refusing to fly until these searches are gone. If this means forgoing holiday visits with family, so be it.
The Constitution must be upheld! I will not give up my 4th Amendment rights!
The should put out a tip jar and give "Happy Endings"
This is America. Please let us be a free country, not one where people are afraid of flying because they don't know if they will be molested by TSA Agents or if they will have to pay a ,000 fine.
Stop the invasive, ineffective, worthless screening practices!
I've already been afraid to fly for the last nine years out of fear of embarrassing myself at a security checkpoint, but I seriously doubt I could let someone touch my groin against my will and not put them in the hospital or try to have them arrested. The TSA has created a nightmare situation for victims of sexual assault and I feel as though I have been de facto declared unfit to fly because I don't like to be touched or humiliated.
I fly all the time...but I will drive instead if these machines end up being mandatory in my airport.
People that travel as part of their job are being forced to endure a giant breach of personal privacy. Please make it stop.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
TSA is about as useful as tits on a turtle.
I fly in the states a lot! Not anymore...
True security is a myth and our privacy is too negatively impacted. Their statistics on how many incidents caught vs. cost of operations should be transparent at the very least so a value assessment can be made.
Thank you for collecting signatures
I will not fly until these violation of my rights are removed from airports. This is how the terrorists win. America is no longer the land of the free.
Stop the TSA!
Chuck Donovan
777 Captain
Libertarian candidate for U.S. Senator
I refuse to be publicly humiliated by TSA. Trains for me now!
Hands off.
I find both the back scatter and the "enhanced" pat down to be intrusive and an affront to my rights. I would rather risk terrorism than allow the terrorists to win by limiting my freedoms. As Ben Franklin said, "Those who would give up essential liberties for temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety"
Will be staying away from airports until I can fly without the fear of being groped.
I personally hate the "options" TSA is giving me in choosing to fly as my means of travel.
Sacrificing privacy for the illusion of safety is what the Founding Fathers warned us about.
Please stop these unconstitutional and invasive measures.
Treating me as if I am a criminal just because I am flying is not appropriate.
This is not about safety, it is about power and intimidation. Ordinary, law-abiding American citizens should not be punished for the paranoid delusions of the rich and powerful.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Congrats on making us choose between either being imprisoned to only areas we can drive to or being completely humiliated. On the bright side.... Big Oil must love the TSA.
Wish I didn't have to fly next week, not looking forward to this violation of my Constitutional rights! Look at our national budget woes (and what the TSA costs to maintain), accept the reality that pre-flight screenings haven't caught any terrorists, read the Fourth Amendment (again, apparently), and then explain to me how this is justified. Go ahead, try.
I won't fly until these scanners are removed and the body pat-downs are stopped. They should go back to using the metal detectors and waving wands over our bodies. This is outrageous! The argument that we can simply choose not to fly is not an option for most people, who cannot always rely on a car or train or bus or a boat or on walking for transportation. People who fly on business cannot choose some other way to travel and still keep appointments on time. The government has NO BUSINESS using such invasive techniques on its citizens who are to be presumed INNOCENT until PROVEN guilty in a court of law. They need a WARRANT from a COURT to conduct such searches, which warrents must describe exactly what they are looking for and exactly where they will search, and without those warrents, they are violating our rights!
You shall go no further. The american people are awake and we will tolerate no more! Just say No!
I refuse to fly until these violations of my constitutionally protected privacy and health cease.
I would like to retain my dignity.
I will not fly until this is changed. I will drive or take Amtrak. Amtrak is much more comfortable anyway and less of a hassle, worth the added expense in my book.
When I go to the airport I feel like I've left America and walked into a scene out of some dystopian novel -- and I felt this way before all the body scanning lunacy.
We are not in so much danger that we need to lose our national identity in order to keep ourselves safe. Frankly this sort of thing scares me more than terrorism could ever hope to.
Need to just have an armored room with equipment that detonates explosives that everyone has to walk through by themselves.
This needs to stop now. These extra security measures are ridiculous. We don't live in a police state.
This is not helping "beat the terrorists", it's just "killing our economy" and "diminishing our civil liberties"
I'll donate $
TSA are a bunch of dicks who just like to cop a feel
If we're willing to give up our dignity for the illusion of protection, haven't the terrorists already won?
If you grope me, I'm groping you back, TSA!
The best way to vote is with the wallet. Enough is enough!
Security theater does not make us safer. Look to Israel for good, non-invasive, effective airport security.
Malo periculosam libertatem quam quietum servitium
Please treat passengers as the security asset they are, not as criminals.
Do not infringe upon our rights. Once you do, the terrorists have won.
If Israel doesn't need these procedures to prevent terrorist attacks, then I highly doubt the US does.
If Israel can figure out a system that lets people keep their dignity then surly we can as well.
This is nothing but security theater. Not only does it waste my tax dollars and violate my personal rights, but it makes us *LESS* safe from terrorists by creating a false sense of security and bunching together thousands of people in security lines that are better targets for terrorist attacks than any plane.
Stop wasting my money on paying people to grab my balls.
As a survivor of sexual assault and a woman of child-bearing age who could be pregnant at any moment, I feel as if HS and the TSA have left me with no real option other than not to fly. I am not confident in the testing done on the backscatter, nor am I willing to consent to a situation where I could be forced to relive my sexual assault as yet another stranger touches my vagina. Also, even if I were to submit to the backscatter, I could be forced through a physical check, as well. As a soldier's wife, I am insulted that my husband supposedly risks his life for the freedom of the government to offer this up to citizens for any flight, especially domestic. I will not be flying until I can be assured that I will not be forced to allow agents to touch me in a way that is illegal in any other situation.
This is not merely an issue of safety or convenience. What the TSA is doing is completely immoral.
These machines and pat downs are a disgrace and embarrassment to our country.
Stop wasting taxpayer money on useless "security" theater. TSA doesn't need to see every passenger naked nor do they need to molest passengers.
this procedure is expensive, dangerous for my health, and cannot help against terrorists
I sign this petition not only for the intrusive nature of the subject, but also for the unsafe dosage of X-ray waves emitted from the Backscatters. Its horrendous.
The TSA will do more to kill the airlines than the airlines themselves. That's impressive.
This is NOT the kind of transparency I was expecting from the government!
See how Israeli airport security is done for an example on how to treat people as fellow human beings and still maintain a high level of security.
My nuts are ment to be eaten, not watched.
I have 2 small children and am more concerned about them being molested before flying than I am their safety on an airplane!
A tiny increase in security is not worth a giant increase in the humilation of law abiding citizens.
This, and it's natural progression, is not the world I want for my kids.
Please also take into account passengers with disabilities. I am a young Muslim woman who wears hijab and I walk with a cane, and I am frequently separated from my luggage AND my cane by TSA personnel as they pat me down multiple times.
“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized". I will not fly until these words are upheld.
I refuse to be treated like a criminal. Even the US military, in war zones, does not stoop to such actions when the threat of loss of life is considerably higher. A full pat down conducted in this manner would be a crime anywhere else.
I won't be flying again, or allowing my children to fly, until reasonable, evidence-based security procedures are in place. I think the number of people who feel this way is growing exponentially. Maybe then the airlines' lobbyists' voices will have an impact, even if individual citizens' Constitutional rights don't matter anymore.
How much safer are we now that we have given up our rights to privacy?
This will not make us safer, just many violated Americans.
This is disgraceful.
In addition to the points listed above, as a parent I feel that these machines and the pat-downs are comparable to child pornography and assault. No one should be put in the position of having these images taken or face a violating pat-down, but children especially should not ever be put in the position of having someone see or touch their bodies in inappropriate ways.
Proud Spouse of Iraq and Afghanistan Veteran
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin, 1775
The aim of the terrorists is not to completely destroy us, but to destroy our culture. The culture of free nations is heavily dependent on personal freedoms and liberty from tyranny. The more personal freedoms that are chipped away by the TSA, DHS, and laws such as "The Patriot Act," the more our culture, as a free nation, is threatened.
These backscatter machines and invasive searches would have been right at home in the Soviet Union during Stalin's reign.
He who would trade liberty for some temporary security, deserves neither liberty nor security.
I will keep it clean...this is Fing RIDICULOUS!
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
This is unbelievable the power the TSA has been able to obtain. There is no need for this type of security and for people to feel shamed for their dignity for deciding to fly on an aircraft.
We are doing this for a good reason. You are demoralizing us and using "safety measures", as your excuse.
The TSA has completely overstepped what it was setup to do. It is now a monster that will do whatever it wants and doesn't care about peoples safety. The TSA has not made things safer for us. If you don't believe that, then just think of all the people who are on the no fly list that aren't a threat and all the known terrorists who have been allowed to fly.
If you want to make things safer, put a visible Air Marshal on each flight.
The TSA is not making us safer . . .
I think the American public has finally reached the breaking point. Enough is enough. A false sense of security is never worth giving up our own freedoms and dignity.
How about we actually train our TSA agents so that they are competent, instead of relying on invasive and potentially dangerous technology?
Congratulations, Fourth Amendment, you too have become a casualty of terrorism!
Terrorists are aware that they can not destroy our nation through military might. Their greatest hope is in making us disproportionately expend resources to calm our wild fears.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Benjamin Franklin
I will not accept our transformation into a society ruled by fear and paranoia.
I prefer liberty with danger to security with slavery.
This violates the Fourth Amendment, plain and simple. Will not fly until it is stopped.
This is insanity... absolute insanity. Do it like Israel if you have to.
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
As a sexual assault survivor, I have no wish to be viewed or touched by anonymous and unaccountable TSA representatives. My body is my own.
I will not fly as long as Body Scans and full body pat downs are required to get on a plane. I will either drive my car or take the train.
I wonder if you or any other person in the Obama Administration would be willing to undergo the same invasive procedure. Please Reply !!!
This WILL be a voting issue for me, and it will deter me from flying more often.
I'm surprised airline personal unions aren't up in arms over the radiation exposure they most certainly are receiving on a daily basis. They should really check into radiation badges to get an accurate measure of the amount of radiation being forced upon their constituents.
I do not trust the TSA agents to properly adjust and calibrate the X-Ray Backscatter machines. Who knows if the machine is delivering a "safe" or "unsafe" level of radiation? For all I know, it could be dosing me with 10-times the normal level of radiation and I would be none the wiser.
Law-abiding citizens have the human right to travel freely and the Constitutional rights to remain secure in their person and free from unwarranted search. Backscatter X-rays do not protect us; they only keep us afraid and ashamed.
The funny thing is that for all the rights and dignity we give up to the TSA to ensure our "security", they still haven't caught a single terrorist using these invasive and unnecessary procedures. I am embarrassed for our country.
I will never fly if these stay around. This is just sick and wrong.
Cancer Runs in my Family. Subjecting us to additional radiation is unethical and dangerous.
Being sexually assaulted shouldn't be a prerequisite for flying to Grandma's.
fuck yo couch nigga
Benjamin Franklin said it best:
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
While I understand the reasons the TSA would have for implementing such severe security measures, I recognize that these procedures violate the constitutional rights of American citizens, and by refusing to acknowledge this, the TSA is preventing the betterment of current security standards, which are, inarguably, capable of improvement.
How long is the 'Post 9/11' excuse going to last?
By moving our country, that so many spout as "free", more and more towards a police state, you clearly show that terrorism works. I am not afraid to fly, I'm afraid of a government completely detached from common sense and self-control.
I will not fly until these scanners AND the intimate body pat downs are removed.
Regardless, children should be exempt from bot full body scanners and full body pat downs.
I will not be flying until these policies are changed.
Hands OFF
Israel has a better system (and faster too)
Please do not continue to use fear to dismantle our Constitution and our rights as free Americans.
They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
This additional, useless security measure is the final straw towards my decision to no longer fly domestically.
TSA has gotten simply inhumane. Please stop violating my Human Rights.
the TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening.
Security yes, flight safety yes, but dangerous scanning our lewd pat down are unacceptable and excessive. In a word Unnecessary.
I understand wanting to be safe. But being paranoid to the point to where we are basically having to been seen naked or touched in areas that are very personal is not security. In the fact that our enemies have us this paranoid shows that they've basically won. For everyone's sake, think of something else that actually works and doesn't have a chance (even the most minuscule chance) of giving us cancer?
To sacrifice basic human dignity and our rights in an effort to feel secure is the first step down a slippery slope that can only end in tyranny.
From one of our Founding Fathers:
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.-Ben Franklin
I refuse to fly as long as these invasions of privacy are tolerated.
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
Thanksgiving will be my last flight until the backscatter scanners and genital touching is taken out of Airports. I made my flight reservations 2 months ago, before I knew of these new standards. TSA has NEVER caught a terrorist, and touching my penis isn't going to help them catch one.
The Supreme Court has slowly whittled away our 4th amendment rights. It is time for our rights to be reaffirmed.
Give us back our RIGHTS! I refuse to fly through the USA while these gestapo TSA screenings are in place
I have a flight next month for a wedding and I'm dreading being selected for a body scan.
Especially in regards to our children, who are equally subject to these invasive and traumatizing "pat-downs". Asking me, as a parent, to not only consent but to HELP a stranger fondle and molest my child is not only unacceptable, but inexcusable.
Fear profits a man nothing.
I fly 100,000+ miles per year all over the world and my country, the U.S.A., is where I have to put up with the worst security theater dog n' pony show nonsense that does nothing to actually increase security, but does strip us of our fundamental rights, our dignity, and now our clothes. American Exceptionalism my ass. We've become a nation of cowards and I'm ashamed of the frightened majority that quietly submits to creeping incremental degradation of their freedom.
I planned to take a trip next month but will not go now. I will not board a plane unless required by my job until things change. At my job I send many college students abroad each year. When they ask me about traveling to their study abroad destination, what should I tell them? Should I tell my students they should put up with being sexually assaulted? Or do I tell them to take their chances with the scanners. Maybe they won't get cancer and maybe their naked pictures will not be saved for others to gawk at. As an advisor, I honestly do not know what to tell my students.
I just canceled a cross-country flight I had planned for next month. Like others, I will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and these unconstitutional electronic strip searches and *way* over-the-line manual "pat down" searches are completely halted. Given a choice between my rights and freedoms being taken away or dealing with a (potentially) greater chance of being harmed or killed by terrorists, I'll take my chances with the terrorists. The odds are ridiculously low and I'd prefer that my government remember whom they work for.
The treatment we suffer at the hands of the TSA is shameful. We are meant to be a nation founded on liberty. We have an enumeration of rights, one of which is to be secure in our person and possessions. Yet, when we commit the crime of buying an airline ticket, we are subjected to invasive searches without suspicion of any wrong doing.
Anyone that supports this is a traitor. Traitors must be hanged, or at least voted out of office. Save your career and your your necks. Abolish the TSA!
"I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them."
-Thomas Jefferson
The gap between security and paranoia is filled with common sense. Use it.
Refusing to fly until this is sorted out.
Becoming a Police State is not what the founding fathers had in mind.
Test the damn machines better. I don't care about appearing naked, but X-Rays are serious business.
I will be using trains much more than I have in the past. I will be voting against the incumbent U.S. senators and my U.S. Rep. if this outrage isn't changed to some other methods that are dignified.
TSA terrorism is the only terrorism I fear.
I am not a lawyer, but...
*the petition claims that the searches are unconstitutional
*a lawyer should look at this, because unless there are precedents, and by precedents I don't mean "the kind where people are allowed to have their bags searched upon exiting a retailer, after having purchased things from them" -- I mean where people that want to use a service are required to go through unusual requirements like having their belongings searched, and where that has been found against the constitution, then the simplest response to the allegation that the TSA's actions are unlawful are "you don't have to fly" -- although there may be something to it, if the people are not aware of the rule when they get in line and then are told that they can't exit the airport (as I heard it, there was a threat of ,000 civil lawsuit/fine for attempting to do so in at least one case).
*Although I do not agree with everything stated above, the result of the petition will be, I hope, that the ability to fly without these invasive measures will be possible within the U.S. -- so that we don't have to go to Canada to fly to the U.S. Or drive across the country or be ground bound.
I am a pilot. In addition to concerns about privacy and dignity, I am concerned about additional exposure to radiation, which is already significantly higher than what most people are exposed to.
I am a corporate pilot as such I will not be able to participate in biometric programs that airline crews will be part of. My choices will either be an extra dose of radiation or a humiliating "pat down".
"He who would trade liberty for some temporary security, deserves neither liberty nor security."
TSA is lame
This is humiliating, degrading, and unconstitutional.
End legislated sexual assault immediately.
Profiling has worked just fine for Israel for the past 50 years, why on earth should law abiding citizens be subjected to such intrusive searches? Citizens should not be afraid of their government.
Until the Backscatter X-Ray Machines and the extensive pat-down searches are stopped, flying isn't an option. I don't check my rights with my luggage when I fly.
Honestly, I'll probably still fly for the free handjobs.
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself. Also, the TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening.
I feel strongly that our rights as American citizens are being denigrated by these practices - first this, then what? Our 4th Amendment rights are clear; and as such this government agency has no right to preform these invasive search procedures.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." -Benjamin Franklin from "Memoirs of the Life and Writings of Benjamin Franklin"
I am an American Citizen who will NOT be visiting my family in Portland Oregon over the Christmas holidays due to the TSA and their invasion of privacy. I will not allow myself to be put through this humiliating theater of supposed security.
I won't be flying to the US or to any country that has these policies.
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.
This is unconstitutional
I have a huge problem with the backscatters in general. Why should I have to put my own health at risk because I want or need to fly somewhere? And if I don't want a huge dose of radiation, groping me in inappropriate areas is just as disturbing mentally and emotionally.
The idea of these machines and pat downs makes me sick to my stomach. I believe them to be invasion and damaging procedures.
Every day, millions are subjected to "Security Theatre" that does nothing but continue the victim mentality of Americans. Our rights have been eroded and we are the laughingstock among our allies. There were terrorist attacks before 2001--but this is the one where the terrorists have made us sacrifice the basic rights our country was founded on. This time, the terrorists won.
Never should I nor anyone else have to subject themselves to such an intrusion of privacy. It's a blatant infringement of our rights, and we will stand for it no longer. TSA, enough is enough!
We are all to blame for letting the flunkies seize control of our rights.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
No one should have to choose between the Scylla of a strip-search and the Charybdis of a groping. These scanners must go.
I have opted out of flying unless absolutely necessary - and in those circumstances when I have to fly, the fact that my choices are to be inappropriately touched by a stranger or receive radiation exposure in unacceptable. What is most absurd is that the searches while humiliating and dangerous will not in fact stop a real terrorist seeking to do harm. It will serve only to yet again let the terrorists win by removing still more of our civil rights as American citizens.
Parents shouldn't be forced to submit their children to this abuse. Period.
Stop the tyranny and abuse.
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." -- Ben Franklin. Must we debase our citizenry in an expensive, showy, and potentially dangerous attempt to placate fears of an event against we already have adequate controls?
TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening.
Everyone who "Opts Out' should then file a complaint against the TSA agent for inappropriate contact and threaten a law suit, that should stop this madness!
2+2=5?
How do you feel about your kids going into one of those machines?
"Touch my junk and I'll have you arrested!"
I refuse to be subjected to violations of my privacy without good reason. Let's stop being reactionary and consider what proper intelligence could do to prevent problems in the first place. Any sensible terrorist (domestic or foreign) would have to be intelligent enough to find a work-around for the scanner or the pat down or both. Why subject folks who are law-abiding to this when it doesn't change a thing?
Unfortunately the TSA has proven itself to be an arm of the government that is very hard to trust. This is a blatant disregard for basic personal liberties in this country.
Thank you for letting the terrorists win. When they figure out that a bomb can be housed in the rectum will you then subject us to cavity searches?
Let's end the charade of what currently passes for security at our airports. It's time to trade security theater for actual security.
Those who sacrifice liberty for security end up with neither.
Touch my junk and you will be arrested.
TSA is a useless face to a buracratic money pit. The "Patriot Act" simply strips away freedom with a smile, and is sad commentary on how government continues to strip away individual rights.
Considering that Israel has, by far, the most threats of any nation and has the BEST and most efficient airport security, why not take a page from their book? The TSA hasn't made us any safer, they've only effectively targeted ALL people as potential terrorists. I do not want to be sexually molested on my way home for Thanksgiving.
The terrorists have won.
The choice between molestation by strangers and being naked in front of strangers is not a choice at all. I refuse to fly until these regulations change.
I will NEVER Fly in an airplane again.
Last year my wife and I flew to London and Athens on two separate vacations. We will not be flying again until some common sense is brought back to airports.
Way to make us awkward and uncomfortable people dislike airports even more, asshats.
HANDS OFF!!
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Ben Franklin
When fear drives us to to give up our constitutional rights in exchange for "security" the terrorists have won
I need at least dinner and a movie before anyone gets to second base.
A hijacker doesn't need to hide something in their crotch to force their way into a cockpit and drop kick the control panel.
These machines are also a waste of money. There are other, more effective and less invasive methods for ensuring safe flying.
Our family will avoid flying until I can be sure my daughter will not be irradiated or fondled.
It seems to me, with all of the technological breakthroughs we've made (including the full body scanner), we could also invent a way to scan folks in a more dignified way. Perhaps the scan is a generic human shape (male and female version) that indicates on that scan objects/areas that are suspicious. In the case there is real reason for continued investigation, then a more detailed scan could be provided. My guess is that 95% of travelers will not need the additional level of investigation. I implore you to halt the use of these embarrassing methods contraband detection until a more dignified solution is exists. Thank you.
Invasion of privacy and completely disrespectful of the government to it's citizens!
X-Ray strip search machines are a violation of our rights and won't make us safe.
X-ray machines and chemical sniffers are enough screening for airline passengers. Backscatter machines and groping do not make passengers safer.
I'd rather walk...or swim...or...
This is a clear violation of rights. Forcing people to forfeit their base rights for airfare is not an option! Flying is a fundamental ability that is required, it's not optional.
As a frequent flier and a contributor to early childhood education, feel that the searches on children are completely out of line. To subject my child to be violated in ways of which I try to protect her from is just unacceptable.
These porno-scanners and molestations are an offense to basic human dignity.
I refuse to fly as long as these "security measures" are still in active use.
I don't want them to see my wrinkled penis. Definitely a violation of my 4th amendment right.
This nation is just one rights violation after another in the dreadful worry that one of them will eventually stick.
This government needs to be overthrown and replaced with one that is for the PEOPLE, rather than the corporations.
We do not need strip searches to travel from one state to another by train or automobile. There isn't a single reason why we should need them for airplane flights.
When I am already a United States Citizen flying within the country, this is an insult to what are supposed to be my rights: I should be able to travel within my own country without being subjected to such search measures.
I will no longer fly anywhere until these procedures are changed and the backscatter machines are removed.
Enough with security theater.
This system amounts to institutionalized pedophilia: the TSA is permitted to either grope small children, or take 'nude' photos of them. Oh, and how about rape victims suffering from PTSD who will be triggered by this abuse?
Never take for granted your 4th Amendment rights; or the rest of your rights for that matter.
I want my privacy back! And as a breast cancer survivor, I don't want any additional radiation since I've had enough. As you can imagine it's not easy to lose both breasts, and then to have someone have access to look at my naked body or feel my chest makes my stomach churn.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." Benjamin Franklin
I refuse to fly until the security theater ends. I will not subject my two young children to becoming the victims of either government-sanctioned child porn or child abuse at the hands of TSA agents.
I want at least dinner and soft music before I get groped!
When flying, I shouldn't have to choose between sacrificing my reproductive health and allowing a stranger a clear view of my genitals, or choose instead to sacrifice my dignity by letting a stranger touch aforementioned genitals. Both are clear violations of privacy rights.
I will not be flying within the US until the TSA procedures are overhauled to be LESS intrusive and MORE effective.
"Don't interfere with anything in the Constitution. That must be maintained, for it is the only safeguard of our liberties." -Abraham Lincoln
Having family out of state does make non-air travel for holidays difficultand stressful. The added insult and injury of being treated like a convicted felon off to jail to board an airplane is against everything i took an oath to protect
USMC 96-00
End this 'security' charade. Atop treating all Americans as guilty before being proven innocent. Stop 'protecting our freedom' by destroying them.
Stop creating troughs like this for multi billion dollar corporations to profit from in the name of 'protecting' us.
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Ben Franklin
You will never touch my sac!
This security theater nonsense needs to stop. All we're doing is wasting money that could be spent actually making us more secure.
I see what you're doing there. you're taking away my personal space and privacy one step at a time. The line? It's been crossed.
As someone who always sets off metal detectors (knee replacements) and flies 10+ times a year, this has gotten ridiculous! I can either have someone see me naked or get aggressively groped. The TSA is targeting the wrong population!
It's to start El Al style profiling...elderly ladies and toddlers don't blow up planes
So if a terrorist puts explosives in their rear orifice, will the public then undergo cavity searches too? Where's the line?
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
I was jerked out of line by an extremely RUDE TSA worker, given a "pat down" at IAD airport security check point. I had my breast roughly touched and hand jammed between my legs, as they "Patted Down" my body, Then forced into one of those xray machines, It humiliating and embarrasing as youre standing with your husband and kids as they go through the regular metal detectors! I will not be flying again. I do not believe that an airport worker has any right to infringe on my 4th Amendment right of my persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated. The airport is clearly immune to this Amendment!!!! Whats worse is that certain religious groups are exempt from these searches based on religion, by I a tax paying AMERICAN citizen have my 4th Amendment rights taken away!!!!!!!!!
The stripping of liberties through fear is not what America was founded on. There are ways to maintain public safety without fear and harassment.
Osama bin Laden is smiling ... no, laughing.
dismantle tsa and dhs
My children and I will not consent to be violated in this manner. They should never be the subject of child pornography by being made to be seen naked. My teenage daughter will not have her breasts groped or her groin felt. My son should never have anyone touch his penis or scrotum - he's eight! We will not fly again until this is changed.
The only ones in my adult life given permission to see my naked form or touch private areas of my body are my long term significant other and my ob-gyn. There is no way in hell I'm going to let some stranger sexually assault me or let strangers, even the internet, see me naked. And I will never knowingly expose myself to such a cancer risk as those machines. I will be driving cross-country until these degrading practices are stopped.
I could quote Ben Franklin, but I think you already know what I'm going to say.
I did not waive my constitutional fourth amendment protections when I bought an airline ticket. Also, if this was about security, the Christmas bomber, who bought a one-way ticket with cash, had no luggage, and didn't have a passport would never have made it onto a plane.
Michael Chertoff belongs in jail!
Disband TSA!
These invasive and medically suspect screens are the mark of a police state, not a country that calls itself The Land of the Free.
Is it really in the best interest of the country to treat every traveler like a criminal suspect?
This IS the United States of America after all.
Might as well make a porno of me without my consent too. You're halfway there.
I'm very, very uncomfortable even traveling anymore. I don't know what is more uncomfortable, sitting next to a possible terrorist or knowing some random person is going to fondle you (in front of people or not) and your naked body is stored in a system without consent of the owner.
No matter what precautions you take, terrorists will always one-up you with tactics on how to hide their weapons.
It really is up to the passengers on board to save a flight in the event that something does happen.
Sure, it's nice to take a precaution for everyone's safety, but don't in the process please don't invade someone's right to privacy. You enforce the rules every other time, how is this the exception to that rule?
If I'm pulled and searched inappropriately, lets just say I will make it the most uncomfortable time in your life.
By the way, terrorists win, we live in fear now and humiliate our own people.
As a member of the U.S. military, it disgusts me to be pretending the rights of our citizens on foreign land while our own government is violating our privacy at home. I would never give up my privacy in return for security.
I refuse to fly in any airport that employs the scanners or the expanded search. They represent nothing more than false security and drastically encroach on our fundamental rights to privacy.
I pass through airport security 2 - 4 times a week. This security theater needs to stop. Where's my protection from unlawful stop and search?
Stop this madness before it spreads the world!
Just one more reason to add to my do not fly list
We the people are taking the power back.
PLEASE DO NOT TOUCH ME
Aggressive pat down is nothing but fear and humiliation tactic to make you want to use a scanner instead. There needs to be a better way, we don't live in a policed state!
Israel has been providing their travelers with secure travel under much more aggressive circumstances for years, with great results, and no invasive measures like the TSA seems obsessed with implementing. The TSA has never caught a terrorist. Stop the invasive, ineffective "security" measures and learn from them how to actually implement a sane, secure and effective system which won't destroy the airline industry and cost us our civil liberties and dignity.
It's morally despicable to assume that as the government you have the right to demean even your own citizens in the name of "security."
Random acts of sexual molestation will not make flying safer.
I am a senior citizen, who has lived through the end of the great Depression, WWII,McCarthyism [communists were hiding behind every tree], the Korean War, Vietnam, and every other major event from 1940 to the present. Never in my whole life have I felt that the American way of life has been as violated as this time period that we are living in now.These full body scans and sexual assaults that people have to endure reminds me of the way some people were treated during Hitler's Germany. We are American citizens, not terrorists, and it is time that we stopped being scapegoats because the government can't get it's act together in finding other ways of finding terrorists. It is time to stop this madness. Prisoners of war are treated better than American citizens. Stop this breach of our civil liberties now.
I feel assaulted with these extreme and not-useful inspection measures. I can't believe I don't feel safe U.S. airports.
I have to fly for the upcoming holidays and I am dreading it because of these procedures.
We've been tourists in the US most winters, but we sure won't be now.
There is no security in relinquishing liberty.
As a modest woman, there is no way I can consent to such a disgusting invasion of personal integrity. As a survivor of rape & trauma, i am even more concerned about the damage that such an experience would certainly cause to my well-being. As a Muslim, I am also fully aware of who is most likely to be selected and assumed guilty of "something" and this is completely unAmerican. I honestly don't believe that the screeners or pat downs would be at all effective, nor that we are so uncreative that we cannot come up with a better method that doesn't disrespect people.
These new "enhanced" security measures do not make me feel any safer, but they do make me feel violated.
The greatest tool of terrorism is using fear, and neither pat downs nor scanners stop them from using aircrafts as Weapons of Mass Destruction; so not only is it ineffective to start with, but it violates our 4th amendment right since the TSA is a gov't entity.
I do very little flying to begin with, but since the very start it's been obvious that these new policies were a bad choice. Please stop security theater in all it's forms.
I think our whole state of paranoia has become overwhelmingly out of hand, shit happens, deal with it then move on.
I will not fly until this shameful policy is ended. The TSA is an American disgrace.
Israelification! Check out pegasus mail
I am the owner of a small business and we have officially suspended all travel, turning down business at great expense to our company, to prevent our employees from being molested by TSA.
Will not be flying as long as this policy is in effect.
I won't be subjected to humiliation in order to avoid offending Muslims. These procedures are the result of a moral failure on the part of our government: it is willing to sacrifice the rights of its own citizens to avoid looking for people who might actually be terrorists. After this Christmas, I won't be flying anymore.
I should not have to be forced to endure high radiation or personal embarrassment to have the right of movement and travel.
The TSA should be banned.
I won't be flying anymore.
This security theater is sexual assault -- both the backscatter machines and the molestation by untrained non-law-enforcement personnel who may or may not be sex offenders. I will not fly, except under duress, until I can fly without being sexually assaulted.
Stop violating my rights! Follow the ISRAELI model.
They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty or safety.
usa citizens don't know how to stand up for their own rights...
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/744199---israelification-high-security-little-bother
Malo periculosam libertatem quam quietum servitium
Amtrak never looked so good.
I am a frequent flier who will limit my flights to necessity only, and seek long distant business solutions.
End the TSA completely. Separation of airlines and state!
I'd rather risk being blown up by a terrorist than to be submitted to a choice of being irradiated or groped.
The TSA is security theater.
I will not fly until our Constitutional Rights are restored.
These practices are unconstitutional.
It disgusts me that I've served my country for over 20 years only to see American citizens who have been accused of nothing treated like criminal suspects.
I will not fly until the TSA gets rid of the scanners and perverted "pat downs".
My fiance' was raped as a young teenager. It has been quite a few years since the incident and a lot of healing has been done. When I told her about the new screening she turned white as a ghost. She has been struggling ever since with the idea of subjecting herself to the new procedures during our planned Thanksgiving flight to see family. Just the thought of going through the TSA screening is bringing back bad memories and causing a huge setback in her healing process.
I find these new procedures to be a violation of our rights and I am not at all comfortable personally with the procedures. But my level of anxiety doesn't even come close to that of my fiance'. Subjecting rape victims to "naked scans" and/or intrusive touching of genitals is simply incomprehensible.
I am hoping against hope that something changes and we will be able to make this trip. But the simple fact of the matter is that if these screenings are still in place at the time of our flight then we won't be going. I just can't put her through this.
There's a limit to how much freedom we must surrender to protect our liberties.
As someone who flies regularly, I do NOT want to be constantly subjected to radiation of any kind, whether it's been deemed safe or not. Furthermore, I don't believe for one moment that our ridiculous, anti-common sense security procedures add to our national safety one bit. With proven, sensible alternatives available by example in places like Israel, we can do better. Beyond scanning, the reactionary level of groping now permitted to TSA screeners would be considered sexual assault if done in any other content. I'm not entering a prison, I'm trying to fly to Milwaukee.
Lastly, I am not afraid. I am not afraid that my plane will be hijacked or blown up. I know that the risks are real, but just like how every once in a while someone loses it and opens fire on their place of employment or a school, I refuse to live my life in fear. Airport security is obviously very important, but we have allies (Israel in particular) who have even greater security threats than we do, have a proven track record of airline safety, and don't have anything close to the nonsensical farce that the TSA puts on each day.
We can do better. We can have dignity. I am not afraid.
I will not trade my basic human rights for the ability to fly.
I believe in the hard-earned freedoms that America is famous for and initially felt powerless that it seemed so easy to sell them away. I've never been convinced that the backscatter, pat-down, or even water-confiscation techniques made our airports safer. And when does it end? How much longer before my wife will have to submit herself to a cavity search? I've also routinely found many TSA employees to be disgruntled and unprofessional, definitely not the sort of person I'd like to voluntarily waive my rights to.
I am thrilled and relieved that there has been so much push-back.
Not only are you destroying the personal rights and dignity of your citizens, but you are encouraging governments in other parts of the world (Canada for me) to adopt the same policies. Keep your hands off my body.
I am not flying until this stops.
I will no longer be using the airlines until this ridiculous "enhanced" pat down goes back to normal. I will NEVER use the Naked Body Scanner. If I don't get to fly again I have still stood up for my liberties and that is worth far more than the convenience of flying.
The TSA has not successfully stopped a single terrorist attack. They have instead terrorized the American people, playing right into the hopes of Osama Bin Laden that the attacks of Septerber 1, 2001 would diminish our freedoms. He was responsible for the attacks that day, but the U.S. has been responsible for thousands of more despicable retaliatory acts.
Nazi-ism!
I will not sacrifice my dignity or my health for the illusion of safety.
If the TSA's goal is to inconvenience, you have succeeded. Lets take a page from Israel and other countries that face terrorism daily and change how we deal with security and threats.
They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
The politicians and the press and the world says that this is for our protection. You know what I say? That doesn't matter. It doesn't matter what the press says. It doesn't matter what the politicians or the mobs say. It doesn't matter if the whole world has decided something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all others: the requirement to stand up for what we believe, regardless of the odds or consequences. Now, when the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move from your ideals, you plant yourself like a tree next to the river of truth, you look them in the eye, and you tell them: "No, YOU move."
I had my knees replaced so I show my knee replacement card and then they call for a female assistant. I don't understand why I have to be subjected to this invasion.
All we have wanted was our first big holiday to be a trip around America at the end of next year... I will not step a single foot in the US until I know we wont be violated by airport security while on holiday.
Patriots are willing to risk death rather than give up their Constitutional rights. In this case the risk is miniscule, but we give up our rights anyway. Airport security denies us the patriotic choice, and dictates that we submit to fear. Most people fear the TSA more than they fear terrorists. The fear industry will not give up its extremely profitable stranglehold on the American people, and Congress gives them more and more power. Money talks.
Every day we get closer and closer to living in an Orwellian world, this is the final straw. I will NOT be x-rayed and groped just so the TSA feels like they are actually doing something.
I have a phobia of being touched by strangers. That leaves me with being seen naked by strangers and that is almost the same thing to me.
It's an embarrassment to say I live in this country anymore.
What's next
Not planning on scheduling any more air travel until TSA stops these offensive new procedures. I used to fly almost once a month for business and pleasure, nationally and internationally.
The current experience at TSA security checkpoints is a gross violation of my civil and Constitutional rights and human dignity. We cannot allow government power to run unchecked, in the name of security.
Is there anything preventing a registered Sex Offender from becoming a TSA screener, and subsequently doing these pat-downs on children?
What of the irony of terrorizing passengers in the name of preventing terrorism?
The NoS machines MUST have the ability to store the images; how else could evidence be captured for legal prosecution, in the event contraband is found?
Usama bin Laden knew that the Government backlash would do far, far more to restrict the freedoms of American people than he and his band of cave-dwelling lunatics ever could.
As a "free" U.S. citizen, I am outraged. Our grandfathers fought and died to give us freedom, to protect our Constitution; now we hand over such power right back to the Government. This is an insult to their sacrifice. As long as I must submit to either a naked photograph or a physical pat-down, I will avoid commercial air travel altogether. We have lost progressively more and more privacy and freedom over the last decade, and naked pictures and/or physically intrusive pat-downs are where it stops for me.
The illusion of security is not worth losing our civil liberties.
Please consider following the security practices of Israel. They seem to be more effective and less intrusive.
Because of this I will not be able to see my son who I have not seen for 2 years, he is in the military and is in Germany now I was going to go see him and my new daughter in law but not if I have to be put through an illegal search and seizure which violates the "Bill Of Rights" 4th Amendment!
"Give me liberty or give me death" - Patrick Henry had a point...what is living without liberty?
What the TSA is doing is a clear violation of the 4th amendment
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
Number of Americans denied their 4th amendment rights: thousands every day
Number of Terrorists caught so far: 0
Take some lessons from El Al and Israel who has dealt with terrorists its entire existence.
I will not fly again until these grossly intrusive measures are stopped.
I just drove 12 hours to go on vacation to avoid being molested by the TSA. I refuse to fly until these machines are removed from our airports!
Props.
Thanks to the TSA, I will be driving from now on.
Please support effective security instead of invasive security.
I gave the wife the option of driving or flying 1500 miles this holiday. We chose to drive rather than deal with the TSA
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
As a frequent business flyer both domestically and abroad I am disturbed by this trend or dehumanizing the passengers. What we should be doing is following the israeli approach. From car to gate in 45 minutes, and I feel much safer flying in israel then in the us.
Amendment 4.
Instead of these cheap theatrics, TSA should conduct meaningful training in the effective spotting and profiling of potentially suspicious persons. Data from field tests of such profiling should then be assiduously collected and carefully analysed against actual results in order to improve, and most importantly, _verify_ the effectiveness of the profiling methodology.
This is not being done currently, and investigative reports consistently show that the current methods are little more than theatrics and intimidation.
Why is that respecting the basic freedoms of citizens coupled with actual, confirmable profiling of criminal and threatening behaviour too much to ask?
Stop this ridiculous practices made by TSA and leave our privates alone!
Let's use common sense, do what is right, and avoid self-serving acts
If the TSA ultimate goal is safety and security, do so in the least intrusive manner to save the dignity of the people which they are tasked to protect.
I work for the Federal Government. I will not be taking any trips for the US government while these scanners and the "enhanced" pat-downs are in place. I would rather take the statistical chance of a bombing over the invasion of what little rights I have left.
good luck!
Please restore our individual rights as Americans and allow humans to have some dignity.
it's time people stood up to tyranny, and do it now before
its too late.
Who thought this would be a good idea in the first place?
As a Canadian, I will not be flying anywhere in the United States until this issue is resolved. I will not spend my hard-earned dollars to support molestation.
I am writing to express my concern about the new TSA regulations that allow for naked body scans or "enhanced" pat-downs as an alternative.
My family and I fly fairly often, and we have a child with autism. I can barely get her through the metal detectors at this point, and I know she will not tolerate a stranger touching her if she fails to go through the scanner.
How am I supposed to travel with my child if she is to be put through this kind of experience? For her, this would be absolutely traumatic. I can assure you from years of visiting the pediatrician that she will be far from compliant. Will we then not be able to fly?
Why are we not following the same procedures that are used by El Al, an airline that is subject to terrorist threats all the time?
Please help us by opposing these procedures. Yes, I care about my dignity, freedom and security as an American citizen. But I am much more concerned if not downright frightened by what will happen to children like my daughter -- autistic or otherwise unable to cope with these measures.
Thank you for your time and attention. Please let me know your thoughts on this issue.
The act of unwanted pat-downs and full-body scans is vulgar and goes well beyond a nation trying to protect itself. You have absolutely no way of protecting the flying public from being physically abused or aggressively groped by someone in a TSA uniform whether that person is male or female. What are you going to tell a woman, I'm sorry after she's been forced to undergo one of these searches by an over-zealous or sexual predator that the TSA hired. Then smooth it over by telling the American public you are going to re-train the guy. Get real! As an American citizen and as a human being I have the right to my own dignity whether its in the constitution or not and no government, even for reasons as lofty as protecting the nation, has the right to deny me that dignity. Your searches are rude and repugnant, I only pray your 12 year old daughter doesn't have to go through one of these searches. As for me, skip the airlines, hope they appreciate the revenue lost, because I'm going to drive next time.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
As someone who would very much like to not have her breast fondled by a random woman in the airport please put a stop to the legalized molestation..
I will not fly under the current changes with the TSA precedures(Scanners/patdowns).Family health and dignity are first priority!
You are making us the laughing stock of the world.
These measures do not increase security, they are a farce. I am ashamed of my country and what an embarrassment it is to the global scene.
It's time to admit that most of what the TSA is purely for show. This has gone on too long and way too far.
should I turn my head and cough when i'm being fondled?
I will be using other forms of mass transit, as I would like to keep my privates private.
Stop the security theater and implement real security. Use proven profile techniques to identify those that require additional measures. Stop this madness of treating everyone the chooses to fly as a criminal.
The American people are exhausted by the security Kabuki that the TSA provides. Please stop up-ing the ante.
This whole things is unjust, inefficient, and in my opinion unconstitutional(4th amendment).
Is this what our country has come to? Grope or Porno Scan every individual (kids, elderly, disabled, etc)that wants to fly? It's time to take stand. Liberty, Freedom, Morality and Faith are the only answers here folks.
http://www.fuckthetsa.com/
It's ironic how the Greyhound, transit associated with poorer people like myself, treats it's customers with more humanity than the airlines.
Oh for God's sake. There is a limit. Forcing people to allow TSA officers to either look at or touch their bodies in ways that most people aren't comfortable with is not acceptable, even if it does enhance security. In this case, it really doesn't, so the point is moot anyway. There is a limit. This is way past it.
We have had enough of your invasion of privacy and abuse of rights.
Myself nor my family will be flying until the new TSA regulations are revoked.
Those who trade freedom for security deserve neither.
I detest the humiliation of the enhanced pat-down that I received, and the humiliation of the new body scanners that I also experienced. Neither is acceptable. A pat-down that did not constitute a sexual assault -- my genitals definitely were MORE THAN patted, which would have been bad enough -- would be an acceptable option. No GENITAL TOUCHING IN ANY WAY, SHAPE, OR FORM!!!!
The terrorists have already won. Quit giving them reason to cheer in victory by removing our freedoms, and let us travel without fear.
Driving from Chico, CA to Denver, CO for Thanksgiving. No genital grabbing for me!
Fed up flight attendant.
This violates my fourth amendment rights.
These measures are demeaning, constitutionally questionable, and un-American.
Enough with allowing fear to drive policies. Enough.
I have cancelled all travel plans that require flying, into perpetuity, until these ridiculous practices are ended.
These searches are dehumanizing, immoral, and completely illegal. If you touch my genitles, i'll file a complaint and a report to the police. Those who sacrifice liberty under the guise of freedom deserve neither, as jefferson said. When will this stop? Where will the line be drawn?
Im drawing it today. Here and now, im saying no more. Get the fuck out of our airports, and get your fucking porn machines out of our country. This is america, and when we allow this shit to continue, we allow the terrorists to win.
this stuff doesn't work. we need to spend security money on stuff that does, not on stuff that makes flying obnoxious.
There is no reasonable standard under which sexual assault is a legitimate prerequisite for travel.
So long as this behavior is going on, I refuse to fly again!
From the words of Benjamin Franklin: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
The new TSA regulations are not in line with the righteously free America we were promised by our founding fathers. Their words no longer matter, as the TSA has proven yet again. The TSA is violating our human rights granted by the fourth amendment and we the people will protest such a mockery of liberty and freedom until these TSA regulations are reversed.
I fly multiple times a year. I won't be flying at all anymore unless the scanners are gone, and the TSA stops feeling us up.
Never mind the damage to passengers; X-Ray scanners are actively damaging the handlers. There is a reason that radiologists leave the room when they take an X-Ray.
haven't flown in years and won't fly again until airport security theater ends.
Only an overfunded and underperforming bureaucracy from the Bush administration like the TSA could attempt to legitimize genital fondling and expose innocent people to potentially dangerous levels of x-ray radiation, justifying it in the name of "homeland security". And only gutless Obama administration people could continue to cave in to the industries who stand to make the most money from all of this fear-mongering that lingers in the face of no credible excuse or statistic.
No more air travel for my wife and me until this government-sanctioned profanity is outlawed. The bureaucrats won't listen to reason - so we hit the entire industry in their bank accounts instead. Maybe the airline lobby will get the message and coerce their paid stooges on Capital Hill to do something.
My body is a sanctuary.
I refuse to fly under these conditions.
I will not fly until these policies have stopped, and will encourage everyone I know to do the same.
For the love of all things holy, I urge you to reconsider this invasive and offensive screening process.
This is WRONG. Sure these machines might be more effective, but at the cost of our rights and possible health? When will you people draw the line?? Implement Israel's security measures, I've heard nothing but good things about it. I would rather be profiled than analyzed naked.
I don't want my family to be x-rayed every time we travel.
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself. Also, the TSA has not once caught a terrorist from preflight screening.
This is clear violation of the Fourth and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution!!
I am an Iraqi war veteran, and I find the newest TSA rules to be draconian and unconscionable.
I will never use these scanners, the constitution gives me the right not to.
This is an invasion of privacy. For my money this whole TSA business is nonsense!
Mandatory government sanctioned groping and nude photography is simply not acceptable. Please put an end to this dehumanising power abuse.
Great initiative
As a cancer survivor who has been cautioned to avoid any and all potential risk factors whenever possible, I deeply resent the TSA's presumption that anyone who declines to go through the backscatter machine must have something to hide. True, a single screening will probably not cause me to relapse, but it won't be just the once, will it? If the TSA gets its way, it will be one time for every flight I take for the rest of my life -- a risk I literally cannot live with. I will not now, nor will I ever submit to the backscatter, and the TSA is acting as though this reluctance constitutes probable cause to suspect me of terrorism. It does not, and I will organize and vote against anyone who suggests that it does.
The new screening machines are a cancer risk and the TSA pat down procedures are an invasion and are more like molestation than a security screening. This must stop, now!
Stop the body scanners and pat-downs! Our old system has worked just fine! We don't want a police state!!! This is 4th amendment violation!!
This is not security, this is invasion of privacy!
American Airlines AAdvantage Platinum
For anyone who has ever been sexually abused you are eliminating their ability to trust airports and airport security. This is not protection it is abuse.
How the hell does the TSA break the constitution and many other laws without batting an eye.
Let's wiretap people's house's too, because since it's for national security, it's worth the invasion of privacy. It's for your safety.
If the argument is don't fly if you don't like it, then what happens when they start putting these at malls or public events? Stop going out if we don't like it?
There are other ways of providing security. Israel deals with security every day, and yet they don't have body scanners at airports. Don't choose a bad plan just because we don't think we have alternatives when there are.
Flying carries with it inherent risks. That is no excuse to subject people to degrading and harmful procedures. Until you reconsider your methods I will not fly anywhere, nor will I allow my child to be degraded or violated.
Focus more on runway security. If there will be another terrorist attack, it will likely be from people infiltrating the unprotected runways.
Security theater and a power grab. Enough is enough.
I will be using all available means not to travel by air. The creation of the TSA constituted a federal violation of our rights as enumerated by the fourth amendment.
I'm all for security, but these new policies cross the line of human decency and respect. The US, of all places, should not force citizens to humiliation just for the privilege of flying.
I am appalled that these machines are in use when the health effects have not been thoroughly investigated! Exposing thousands of people per DAY to ionizing radiation is beyond harmful. Also, publish a list of foiled plots and criminals caught by the highly pointless TSA. The searches do nothing but provide a false sense of security and a great deal of inconvenience. Get rid of these machines and the TSA.
I would fly every year to visit friends across the country. Now I won't even consider going to an airport until they remove them.
If someone hides something in her bra, will we start requiring women to remove their bras in security? Maybe breast pat-downs? There is a line you do not cross and these backscatter machines and 'pat downs' have crossed it. This is only taking our freedoms away.
What country are we living in? What's next? You guys couldn't find a needle in a haystack.
I work in radiation protection. I find the machines suspicious, at best.
The choice between radiation poisoning or sexual assault is neither fair nor rational. In the eight years since 9/11, we have had no detrimental attacks on US soil without these unconstitutional violations of human rights. Please do your job without destroying our rights as United States citizens. I will avoid all airports until these invasive policies are halted.
So much for our right to privacy.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
Will not fly again. Would not recommend to others.
I'm glad I prefer driving and have no actual NEED to fly, but this is a horrible "choice" for people whose lives actually do require time in the sky.
There are better -- more effective and more efficient -- ways. Please look into them as alternatives.
This is not becoming of a free and democratic country. It's humiliating and clearly unconstitutional. Passengers are more likely to be struck and killed by lightning than by a terrorist. Enough already!!!
This is ridiculous. Ridiculous. The TSA is an enormous waste of resources.
This is ridiculous. Please do something about it.
I no longer want to fly anywhere thanks to this.
I should not be treated like a criminal in my own Country!
I will always opt-out!
We are officially living in a police state. If we don't stop this now, its all over.
Please consider what is right for our country. We cannot be defended from terrorism if we must surrender all of our personal freedoms.
Let's have real security, less theater.
I will not let them take naked pictures of me and I will never let my child go through one of these machines.
This policy is an outrage and needs to stop now.
I am forced to fly for my job. I am considering quitting so I do not have to be subjected to the radiation or some overzealous TSA agent sexually assaulting me. Have you ever heard of the fourth amendment? It pertains to illegal search and seizure. Do you have a warrant to search my person?
Do they do this at Ben Gurion, Israel?
Won't travel to the US until scanners are removed.
There is no reason to touch people like that.
Stop the scans and stop the racial profiling associated with air travel.
Dismantle the whole of security-theater!
Security theater does no one any good. Implement intelligence-based security measures and eliminate the pointless screenings.
Stop the groping.
These scans and searches are completely unconstitutional. Everyone is a terrorist until proven innocent.
We should have drawn the line a long time ago, but better late than never. STOP.
Janet Napolitano my infant deserves a better future than what your mind can conceive.
http://www.reddit.com/r/OperationGrabAss
Our rights are being violated. Please stop this.
These new procedures are an outrage, and absolutely MUST be stopped immediately. I'll be staying on the ground until I can fly without being groped.
I have skin cancer and don't want to be exposed to the x-rays that are emitted from the backscatter machines. I don't believe that having my genitals groped is a reasonable alternative.
I would like to see Napolitano or Pistole go to the process as well as their families. Would the President allow this be done to his wife and children too?
They'll say we only complain if we have something to hide. ... what about civil liberty and personal freedom? search till 'reach resistance' ... no thankyou!!
When you treat us all as a potential threat, the enemy has already won. I'm an American and I'm not afraid of terrorists. I refuse to surrender my constitutional rights while traveling within the borders of my country.
Please stop this insanity!
If the terrorist plot has actually made it as far as the airport, then these scanners will not be of any use to stop it. This is a huge waste of money, and I do not have any doubt that the people who own the company manufacturing these machines have a huge hand in the fear-mongering that attempts to necessitate them. I will not fly until this changes.
Get RID of the TSA and let private firms do security.
Does the Constitution mean anything anymore?
I am an American Citizen, I am not a criminal! How dare you protect the rights of muslims and attack us americans!! You have gone to far this time, you have no right to put your hands on my body or to look at my personal and private areas. Use the model of securing these airports like they do in Isreal, get some dogs that can sniff out stuff.. better yet - screen your airport employees better .. that is where your real problem is.
This is a complete invasion of privacy against people who have no intentions of bombing an airplane with them in it. Sorry to say, but it is Muslim radicals who have this propensity and not normal everyday citizens. Get your heads out of your @#$ and get a clue about the real world.
the terrorists on 9/11 didnt enter the airplanes through normal security, how are these invasions of privacy going to stop them?
Dignity is not negotiable currency in the war on freedom. Dignity is a human birthright - except in the United States of America.
Will not fly until the scanners are removed and strip searches halted
This is against my privacy
The huge amount of money invested in these expensive machines could be put to constructive use by hiring more agents to sift through the intelligence data that currently is too extensive to handle. These degrading, intrusive searches do not keep us safe.
I've already contacted my representative about these issues.
I feel no more safe than I did before 9/11
New policies such as these negate the American way of life.
These measures are unjustified and invasive. Please repeal them immediately.
Don't make me fight for nothing.
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
Will not fly again until my 4th amendment rights are re-instated. I did not protect this country for 11 yrs to have my privates touched inappropriately.
Becoming terrorists ourselves is not the answer. You must understand the psychology and then deflate the fear and concern in order for balance to be restored.
The Terrorists win when people lose their rights
I morally disagree with being seen naked with the full body scanners as well as being groped like a criminal with the invasive "pat down"
The power given to TSA officials to bully and humiliate innocent people is unacceptable.
They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin
The department of Homeland Security has simply lost all sense of balance in these choices. There seems no end to this endless stream of requirements and searches. The end result is a police state. It is beginning to sound as though you may be getting close in the arena of air travel. Police states have no trouble keeping its citizens safe at airports because they can do whatever they want at any time with no repercussions. We are a democracy whose citizens hold as a value our individual freedoms. This nation must learn that the choice of freedom necessarily entails a level of risk that those living in a police state don't suffer.
These screening procedures are dehumanizing, demoralizing, punative and animalistic, and a direct antithesis of the liberty and dignity we claim to champion in the USA.
Do it like Israel does.
I will not be flying as long as these methods of searching continue. They don't provide increased security, only increased "security theater." Please consider implementing security measures that actually provide security.
I'm a licensed attorney - and this blatantly unreasonable and improper violation of the 4th amendment is absolutely disgusting. I refuse to fly until the situation is properly resolved and the rights of the people are restored.
Never give up. Resist. Resist. Resist.
It is embarrassing that the government is doing this in the name of "security". The scanners are an infringement of people's privacy. And the TSA needs to keep their hands to themselves. How dare they pat down innocent citizens and children!!!! Who is the idiot that thought this would catch a terrorist?! The real evil-doers are probably laughing their asses off watching all this.
I do not feel comfortable flying until these scanners and pat-downs are removed from airport security.
Oh my God, don't get me started. How am I supposed to tell my six year old little girl that it's okay to let the stranger rub her vagina? Who in the worrld said it was okay in the first place??? How about we start implementing the Israeli's security practices, ones that actually work, are not invasive, and won't scar my little girls?
I shouldn't have to choose between ineffective, privacy-invasive, potentially-risky security theater (and hundreds of millions of tax dollars being wasted) on the one hand and sexual assault on the other. Neither should anybody else.
I refuse to fly until the TSA removes these scanners and stops sexually molesting American citizens for the sake "National Security".
'Those who are willing to give up liberty in exchange for security deserve neither." Ben Franklin
The thought of a stranger touching my body in such an intimate way would be the cause of a panic attack. Enough is enough!
Go all the way with TSA!!
Stop the madness. America is becoming a police state and the laughing stock of the world. The terrorists must be thrilled at what you've turned this country into.
This really violates the constitution.
Flying is a stressful experience in itself for most! Adding kids to the mix and this is just insanity! Why don't we profile like EVERY other country??!!!
I'm not going to teach my daughters it's OK for a stranger to touch you as long as they're with the government.
I refuse to fly until these scanners are removed. Implement a more reasonable method to scope out the "rampant" amounts of people that want to blow up our duty free shops. (See Israel's methods)
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
If you can't respect your people enough to not treat them as the enemy how can you expect them to respect their government?
It's disgusting what the TSA is doing, and more importantly what the congress is allowing the TSA to do.
Would this have stopped the 9/11 whackjobs? More importantly, if we as a country allow our children, mothers, grandfathers, partners, and spouses to be felt up, are we not whackjobs? Benjamin Franklin would tell you to kiss his promiscuous buttocks.
This needs to be changed NOW!
I object to the way you treat the citizens of your country.
This has to stop! I will not fly until the sexual assault searches and invasion of privacy screens stop!
I will not fly because of the full body scanners, or the crazy pat-downs.
i OWN A tRAVEL aGENCY AT LAST COUNT i JUST RETURNED FROM MY 100TH COUNTRY..NO OTHER COUNTRY MAKES U PLAY THESE STUPID GAMES...GO TRAVEL WORLDWIDE AND SEE HOW ITS DONE...STOPING WASTING OUR MONEY WITH THE WORTHLESS TSA..
They still let me carry my razor on the plane
stop the insanity
The current scanners are incredibly invasive. At the very least, we must ensure that no images remain in storage on these scanners.
I won't let my children's nakedness be viewed by TSA or allow their genitals/breasts/butts groped by them either.
As an American citizen, I protest the fact that more and more private and public agencies are taking liberties with our civil rights and are insisting on treating law-abiding citizens as if they are criminals.
We as American Citizens should not be forced to sacrifice our dignity for the illusion of safety.
As a survivor of a sexual attack I do not want anyone touching me even if it over my clothes. I also do not want to have a machine let someone see my body even if they cant identify me. It is a violation of my privacy. I have little faith in reports that the machines are safe. At one time thalidomide was safe. Asbestos was safe. Agent Orange, deet, should I go on?
Yes, I do believe that the terrorists are winning, but only because the government is putting us all in a frenzy. Children on no fly lists? Elderly being groped? Insane!
Those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.-Ben Franklin (copied from Sean)
Security Theater now has audience participation?
“Those who desire to give up freedom in order to gain security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.” Benjamin Franklin
I wont be flying until the scanners are removed and strip searches stopped, this rape of freedom has caused everyone to feel violated and children are actually being traumatized.
What if certain TSA agents are convicted rapists or pedophiles? These regulations are an abomination and noone should have to be felt up sexually due to the events of 911 - nearly a decade ago.
Presumed innocent...
Disgusting way to make a buck.
Seems the terrorist have won if we have gotten to this level of 'security.' Thank you Janet Napolitano, for allowing this to come true.
Electronic strip-searches and physical molestation are violations of the 4th Amendment of the Constitution of the USA in the absence of probable cause.
Gainsaying Benjamin Franklin is an invalid argument: Those who give up liberty in exchange for security end up with neither.
Fuck off TSA
I've taught my children that no one has the right to touch their body - especially their private areas - for their protection. How does this support parents and the rights of children when they fly?
nonfunctional security theater, this is.
Its unpatriotic and un-American to take away personal liberty in this way.
I will never fly again til these are remove and the problem is fix.
What ever happened to dignity?
I will not surrender to these unreasonable, invasive and humiliating procedures for the sake of false security. If we lay down and allow our liberties to be stripped away in the name of 'safety' right now, where does it end?
I will not fly until this is overturned. I refuse to be treated this way.
We are Americans. This is an unwarranted invasion of privacy and yet another step towards 1964. Where do we stop?
I am tired of the TSA running their hands up my legs, and discovering I have a freakishly large penis. When they do they always look at me wide eyed, and I say yeah that's my penis, and they have to bring the scanner over, and they run it over my penis, then they talk about how giant it is and I'm sick of it.
Utterly disgraceful that someone thought this was even reasonable to begin with.Heads must roll.
If our founding fathers were to come to 2010, they would be saddened to see our liberties violated, especially over an one-off fluke incident years earlier. The TSA needs to be abolished, if not I fear America may fall victim to revolution or civil war.
The terrorist have won, they have succeeded in chipping away at our precious democratic freedoms enshrined in our constitution for the sake of a precarious "security." I can't believe America and Americans have sanctioned this. The highest principles are never worth giving up under any circumstances.
My eight-year-old daughter has heard of this and with no prompting from me has quite strongly said that as long as the backscatter or pat-down is in place, she does not ever want to fly again. And this just after a great trip and her first plane ride this summer. Even an eight-year-old girl can see straight through all of the excuses for these measures.
Unless forced to, I have no intention of flying.
We can't waterboard terrorists but can grope U.S. fliers. Have we gone nuts?
My family and I will not fly again until these disgusting practices are stopped. These types of searches and scanning do not improve our safety. They are mentally and emotionally harmful. Bad TSA, bad!
Not only do these practices not make Americans any safer, they are deeply detrimental to the American aviation industry and its employees.
Medical professionals have reasonable concerns about the concentration of X-rays near the body surface, exposing vulnerable skin, breast, and testicle tissue to cancer-causing radiation. Submitting to a dangerous medical procedure or being intimately groped is not a tolerable choice.
Don't touch my junk or see my junk.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." -- Benjamin Franklin, 17 February 1775
I am refraining from airport travel until this is resolved. This entire matter horrifies and offends me. There are other, more dignified ways to keep America safe.
The use of "body scans" and searches is a complete abuse of power. The fact that these are enforced in airports demonstrates that we do not live in a republic or a democracy. We are just one more step closer to dictatorship.
Security is not supposed to harass those who support it.
Would the president subject his daughters to the pat down?
Consult the Israelis, how do they implement air travel security?
I will not travel until this is stopped.
Thanks.
I highly doubt this does anything to deter would-be terrorists.
This has nothing to do with security and everything to do with power.
Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither ~Benjamin Franklin
stop the abuse!
I am vehemently opposed to being exposed to excess radiation just to visit my daughter and my sister. I am vehemently opposed to being touched by airline personnel in what I consider to be an offensive manner. I am vehemently opposed to creating a situation that delays my fellow passengers when we're all in a hurry to get somewhere at the airport.
I feel uncomfortable about the scanners and will not fly until they are removed.
I do not consent to an invasion of my privacy and that of my family. Your thugs will not grope my infant and I will have them arrested for sexual assault if they attempt to. You may be a chicken shit that's afraid of the bearded brown men, but I'm not and I prefer my constitutional rights to a false sense of security provided by a carcinogenic strip search.
What a terrible waste of money in these unsteady times.
I think it's disgusting that Americans must pay for TERRORist threats and wrong doings..... This is what they want.. We must show our naked bodies to random sickos OR get touched inappropriately by them in order to fly on a plane we paid our hard earned money to be on? Isn't there a no fly list and other precautions for a reason?
This is degrading and re-victimization for victims of sexual abuse and voyeurism. We will no longer be silent victims of your violation.
As a Christian I believe that this is immoral in it's application besides being unconstitutional
This whole thing is ridiculous. Especially when they are doing the same to kids. Despicable.
I will opt-out every time I fly, I will not subject my body to potentially harmful radiation.
There has not been sufficient data to prove that this significantly increases flyer safety, nor has the existing data indicated that the whatever added safety provided outweighs the potential long term health effects of frequent X-ray exposure. Furthermore, using overly invasive "pat downs" as a means to intimidate travelers to submit to the dangerous and invasive backscatter device.
Don't forget the 4th amendment.
I will not fly until the scope or grope is gone. Don't touch my junk.
Look to the Israelis for how to run airport security.
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
TSA screening is at best useless; at worst, it increases the likelihood of a passenger based attack on an aircraft.
I hate the TSA, this is unjust.
The TSA and Chertoff need to be videotaped while being groped and photographed nude for public viewing. Enough already!
This is just getting incredible. Pretty soon you will make us all strip naked and submit to a cavity search before going through the security checkpoints. I've had enough.
Virtual strip-searches and invasive pat-downs by the TSA are unreasonable searches as per the 4th amendment, performed by government agents. This is simple and obvious.
We're not even getting a side benefit to shredding the Constitution, as the TSA has failed to prevent three attempts to attack planes since its inception. The TSA's strategy is reactive only and as such will not succeed in thwarting attacks. The measures being taken now would not even have succeeded in preventing past attacks - the scanners that we put our shoes in can't detect c4. The naked-scopes wouldn't have caught the 'underwear bomber', and meanwhile cargo is wide open while citizens are treated like criminals. It is all for show and; an ass-covering busywork carnival of total incompetence from start to finish. Nothing the TSA does bears any resemblance to a reasoned, intelligent approach to security.
I will be taking Amtrak or declining to travel.
In the paraphrased words of Salman Rushdie, if we become the armor that we put on to protect ourselves, we lose that which we were intending to protect.
In the famous words of Mel Gibson, "FREEEEDOOMMMMM!!"
If the Constitution still means anything, these scanners and "enhanced pat-downs" will go away.
I think it's ridiculous that this should even have to be done.
I do not believe in security theater. Prove that these machines or the agressive pat downs would be statistically effective in preventing terrorism. Otherwise, implement whatever noninvasive procedures are necessary to keep us safe on planes. I don't mind waiting, I do mind being submitted to an ineffective and flawed TSA screening process for no good reason.
This theater of safety is doing nothing to protect us, perhaps you should consider the manner in which Israel protects their airport in Tel Aviv, and just in case the memo didn't make it all the way around the country, 1984 wasn't an instruction manual.
Thanks,
Cullen
Honestly, we've gone to far. Consider the trajectory we are heading in. It's a slippery slope. What is next? Cavity searches? We think that is crazy now but ten years ago we would have thought these machines were too much.
Want to have airport security that's actually effective? Privatize it. And have El Al train all security personnel.
In the meantime, none of the airlines get any of my hard-earned $$ until they get rid of these jack-booted thugs.
True story: I was at a small airport and asking if certain items were okay to have in my carry-on. One agent kept saying no, no, no, and another kept saying that's allowed, that's allowed, that's allowed. The items in question: hand lotion, shampoo, and shower gel, all in 1 ounce bottles. Kinda gives you a warm feeling, knowing they have their facts straight...
We shouldn't sacrifice our civil liberties for the perception of safety.
If someone wanted to kill people, they'll just blow themselves up while standing in that huge line waiting for the scanners.
Who's to guard against a pedophile getting a job and groping children? NOTHING. They are letting people of the lowest common denominator (look at the type of people who apply and their qualifications.)
My mother was raped as a child and has severe issues with anyone touching her-- doctors included. I guess she won't be visiting any more. Thanks Dubya!
If the equality of individuals and the dignity of man be myths, they are myths to which the republic is committed. ~Howard Mumford Jones
I won't be flying until the TSA changes their policies.
The day someone touches my wife, child or self in an inappropriate way after declining their back-scatter XXX-ray machine is the day I assault them in return. I fail to see the connection with my balls and terrorists....
I am willing to deal with the increase statistical risk to protect freedom.
These assaults on our unalienable rights stop NOW. I will not ever fly again while this tyranny is in place.
I think this country has taken a turn for the worse if they think it's within it's rights to see us naked or be groped before getting on a plane.
This is absolutely sickening, I refuse to fly until this is over with.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Benjamin Franklin
Looks like I'm road tripping it from here on out
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. ~ Benjamin Franklin
This is crazy that we are letting the terrorist actually "terrorize" us. This is what they want, and if we subdue to them we have already lost.. I know very cliche, but very true.
Odds of being killed by a terrorist: 1 in a million.
Odds of being molested by a TSA agent: 1 in 100.
You do the math.
Video: TSA Chief When Asked Won't Deny that a Cavity Search Could Come Next! http://bit.ly/bfK6Y2
In addition to these concerns, I am also concerned about the effect on children's safety. There is already a significant child abuse issue in this country. We should not allow our children to be violated in this way except under extreme medical need.
These new measures are completely ridiculous. Please stop.
The *ONLY* people involved in aviation who have stopped terrorists are We The People. TSA has not stopped one single terrorist - NOT ONE.
The only REAL threat to airplanes is explosives -- yet cargo is not screened while passangers are!??
Solution: Use "Puffer" machines to screen ALL passengers for explosives, otherwise screen NOONE for ANYTHING. If some miscreant brings a weapon, there will be "good guys" able to stop him.
Experience proves you cannot stop all determined terrorists - all you do is ensure the law-abiding are disarmed.
We The People will ensure our planes are safe - we learned our lesson on 9/11.
Leave us alone to do OUR job.
Redeploy TSA resources to scanning CARGO.
Lastly, stop the collectivist avoidance of "profiling." The Enemy here is well-defined: militant, islamist males. Searching everyone to make it LOOK "fair" is idiotic - and proves the whole thing is nothing more than theater.
How anyone can legally implement these procedures is beyond me.
I'm sure it's fun for you people to humiliate the populace of the United States. It's not fun for us. Knock it off, and come up with a different solution.
This will not make us safer, and the security-theater mindset that it represents should be a concern for everyone in the US who still believes that what the government MAY do is not the same thing as what the government SHOULD do.
I wear clothes to the airport for a reason.
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.
Let's have real security - TSA is theater that must be stopped.
I will not fly until these machines and procedures are replaced.
Why are we still trying these when the foremost authorities on terror prevention all call them a joke?
The government are just people. People aren't inherently better than other people.
It's time to end the wasteful and pointless Security Theater we call the TSA.
Abandoning the 4th Amendment has never been an acceptable response to terrorism.
This direction of security must be reconsidered. Janet, I used to live in AZ and loved you and supported you as Governor ... what has happened?? This is no longer a security issue .. this has become a human rights issue!
Elizabeth Powers
This isn't freedom.
Illegal searches and seizures, sexual assault, cancer-causing machines, trading freedom for a fake sense of security...
I fly up to 50 weeks a year and I will stop if this continues. This violates my 4th admendment rights and the former head of the TSA even admits that. This is wrong.
I will avoid flying until these procedures are changed.
We're tired of security theater.
this is a disgusting perversion of safety, if i cant even stand in the line because i know the fat man behind the monitor is selecting the attractive girls out of line
end the tyranny
It seems that other countries are doing a better job with psychological profiling and sniffer dogs, why are we not using theses techniques?
**** ***
I have a traumatic history with sexual assault. Ironically enough, both incidences were perpetrated by so-called professionals in another field meant to protect those it serves: medicine. People put in a position of power over another cannot be trusted, and innocent citizens should not be forced to submit to such acts of violation and indignity. Benjamin Franklin once said that those who would sacrifice liberty for safety deserve neither. My country has too frequently trespassed on my rights, and if these invasive machines are not removed, I am emigrating within a year. I will not stand for such injustice.
I would like to fly without being sexually harassed or treated like a terrorist, thanks.
This is a serious invasion of privacy and needs to be stopped.
This is sick, stop!
Please and thank you.
This is an outrage! How dare they attempt to take away our dignity? It's like the concentration camps all over again.
After the trips I've already bought, I'm done flying. The air travel industry isn't getting another cent from me. Driving may be slower, but my family won't get groped, irradiated, or have our naked bodies viewed by strangers.
I was offered the choice between a backscatter xray and an enhanced pat-down in Boston two weeks ago - I chose the pat-down but it took a long time to get to my gate. I'll be avoiding flying (indefinitely if need be) until they come up with a better system.
Get rid of the naked body scanners and groping
Government sponsored sexual assault has got to stop!
This has nothing to do with safety but is purely for humiliation of passengers.
These new so-called security measures are a disgrace. Stop being so reactive and be more proactive! Every new security measure in the last ten years is a REACTION to threats...if everyone reacted in such a way to every threat we would lose every possible freedom we have in the USA. The American People WILL NOT tolerate this kind of abuse at airports!
I will not allow my family to be searched without a warrant. Good job, TSA, for doing the terrorists job for them. What a waste of tax money.
I am OUTRAGED! Enough, enough, ENOUGH....THIS IS A DIRECT VIOLATION OF EVERY CITIZENS 4TH AMENDMENT RIGHTS. This serious overreach of government needs to be stopped immediately.
Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither- Benjamin Franklin. When we abandon the ideals of our forefathers it shows that the terrorists are winning
What is the point of enacting measures so as to ensure the safety of the citizens of this country when the very foundations of this country are removed?
So after being given the honor of participating in the Rose Bowl parade this year I'm going to have to effectively be shown naked to someone or be groped? Really?
Given the findings in Terry v. Ohio, does anyone think the burden required of the TSA officers is being met, “…has a reasonable suspicion that the person has committed, is committing, or is about to commit a crime.”?
I am sickened by what is happening here. Our rights as American citizens are being stripped away.
People really need to take a stand against this violation of privacy and dignity - else expect more of it in the future.
Please stop sexually molesting our sons and daughters.
I will no longer fly until these terrible abuses are abolished.
These patdowns would qualify as sexual assault by anyone else, and the scanners are obviously able to store images. As a survivor of sexual abuse, I am disgusted at the very idea of being *forced* to submit to either - especially when it makes us NO safer. I am now avoiding air travel. You have gone too far.
No one should have to get sexually assaulted to travel freely in our own country. This is a violation of our rights.
This is humiliating and will probably be proven to fail at deterring the terrorism they wish to stop anyway. You gain nothing by living in fear.
I will not allow government employees to conduct unreasonable searches of my person through full body scanners or pat downs.
I would go to jail if i took nude pictures or groped the general public ... So why can the TSA?
I'm not giving up my dignity thanks to your greed driven fearmongering
Don't let the terrorists turn the US into a police state. We have to put our resources towards education, and prevention. We need to invest in an future that we want our kids to grow up in.
No more flying for me. This has gone too far.
Hand screen? Sure. Sexual assault? NO. If it's not acceptable for a Terry stop, it's not OK for me to fly.
See US Constitution, Amendment 4.
Nudity or groping? Not acceptable choices to travel by plane.
This is ridiculous. I get the idea of "being safe", but there's a thick line between being safe and being invasive. You're crossing it.
I will never fly again. I won't be stripped of my clothing and dignity or physically assaulted by another person in order to fly. I'd happily go through metal detecters, air puffs, or be near trained law-enforcement dogs who seek out explosives and drugs. I will have to give up my trips to the south until I am given a reasonable third choice in the security line. It is unbelievable to me that this could happen in the US. What have we become?
We do not believe the government has a right to see you naked or aggressively touch you just because you bought an airline ticket!
These full body scanners are totally unnecessary. please adopt Israels policies.
This must stop.
I am horrified at the thought of our 2 young children having to go through this.
I surely don't feel more secure -- money and time for no good reason.
My Note to Alex Jones at InforWars.com
Alex
I was unable to finish listening to
THE ALEX JONES SHOW 11/16/2010: Video: Owen J.J. Stone exposes the horror of TSA reaching into his pants
It left me in a horrible state of agitation, my hands trembling. I was the victim of childhood sexual abuse and I am still, today, dealing with the assault of a TSA employee in August 2010.
I have called both of my Senators; both suggested I fill a complaint with TSA. That wasn't good enough as I left the airport in a state of shock unable to remember the name of the agent.
I called the White House asking who gives TSA their order on how to conduct business. They gave me the phone number for Federal Information. After explaining what happened they gave me a number for the Inspector General at Homeland Security. 800 688 9889
I called and filed a complaint DHS 101117021 ID # 88247.
Every time I have heard of someone else's story I have become very angry; but your interview with Owen left me in tears.
I hope that you will continue to spread the word about this horrible invasion of privacy.
Cheryl
I have and will continue to tell everyone I know about this invasion of my person
Anyone who thinks this will actually help airline security isn't creative enough. The backlogs in security lines make a bigger target than a plane ever could. So the only possibly justification they could ever offer is useless. And no explanation could possibly justify government sanctioned molestation.
The invasive procedures led by the TSA are a gross violation of our 4th amendment rights, completely unethical, and only serves to give the appearance of safety. People of ALL ages are being subjected to backscatter x-ray machines (which take nude photos, and exposes people to harmful radiation) or, if they choose to opt-out, sexually invasive frisking. These ridiculous measures have yielded no results; not one threat has been found by means of them. It's high time we all finally stand up to our government and exercise our civil rights. How much more of our freedom are we going to give up for a false sense of security? It's time for us to live freely, instead of just saying that we are.
SANITY; NOT FEAR.
This is America. Our rights come before all else
Ron Paul's American Traveler Dignity Act will also help in the fight against this unaccountable government entity, the TSA
Give me Liberty or give me Death! I will not give up my freedoms out of fear. I will not let Terrorists win and affect my way of life. I will not surrender to tyranny and opression in the name of "security." I am a patriot and will die for my constitution! I will protect my country against all enemies, foreign and domestic! Don't Tread on Me!
Malo Periculosam Libertatem Quam Quietum Servitium.
the TSA is clearly violating American's 4th amendment rights
I no longer feel comfortable flying. I understand trying to make our airports and skies safer but there must be a better way than to impede on our civil rights but touching us in places I would only have my significant other and doctor touch me or to walk through a radiation box that shows our every curve. Please...find an alternative TSA!
I'm a flight attendant and had to experience this before getting on the plane. I've had quite a background check including fingerprinting. I DREAD going to work now knowing I may have to go through this again!!! Do I have to quit my job to relieve myself of this dread????
Let's see; I'm not eastern or muslim, not a male between 18-35. Sorry I don't fit the profile! I'm retired from both law enforcement and the military. I carry more ID than any 5 people I know. Yet, my wife and I have been subjected to the worst that TSA has to offer on during 4 incidents. Complaints filed after each have gone unanswered. I despise TSA personnel, the airport nazi's, and will not fly unless absolutely necessary. I've had TSA screeners almost cause a passenger panic by yeeling out that there was a weapon in my bag (nail clippers). Then one male TSA suprv was going to pat down my wife after she went thru the metal detector and was wanded without incident. My objection led to me being told by TSA to shut up. Even as her husband I had no say in the matter. Let's see,then while traveling in uniform on military orders, I was made to take apart my uniform because my ribbons and insignias set off the metal detector. Most recently, I now have a disability and travel with a service dog. Because my service dog's colar set of the metal detector, I was searched...and we went thru the machine separately! When I objected, I brought down the rath of TSA on both of us. These people aren't protecting us. They can't, they're the village idiots!
I refuse to fly until a more appropriate method is found.
These genital searches and naked scanners do not increase security. All they do is deter people from flying. TSA should do the same as El Al Airlines, winner of the most secure airline in the world award (Global Traveler magazine, 2008).
I will not fly if these are used.
Security theater makes us compliant cowards. Stop.
How is this okay?
I refuse to fly and have canceled vacation travel plans until this practice is halted.
I have three children. Having them "scanned" is a violation of child pornography law! Subjecting them to a "pat down" is child molestation! This must be stopped! If someone on the street attempted what the TSA is, they would be arrested for sexual assault.
As the pat down change occurred at the same time body scanners were popping up in airports, the TSA clearly wants to make people feel too uncomfortable to opt out of the death ray machines. I encourage anyone who must travel during the holidays to refuse the scanners and bog down the TSA officials with pat downs. We should never give up our liberties for security.
Protect our children! No nude images and no pat downs!
TSA = 'Legalized' Sexual Assault... F That...
Cheaper for the family to drive any anyway.
I will not fly in the US until this policy ends.
Unconstitutional, invasive, offensive, and repugnant to my sensibilities. Even if it wasn't, would Janet Napolitano and John S. Pistole be willing to submit to the "porno scanner" and / or "enhanced pat-down"? I highly doubt it.
What the TSA does would be illegal if it weren't the governement.
My wife, children, and I live in WA. My parents, brothers, and sisters live in TX. And I'm not exposing my 12 yr old daughter to either radiation or groping, so please give me a third option. I'm an American - it cannot be THIS unhealthy to get from one state to another efficiently and with dignity.
[TW] I will not have my body revealed without my consent ("scan") or be sexually assaulted ("pat-down") as a condition of flying.
this is about training the american people to be slaves, not about terrorists AT ALL. This is slave training.
Those who are willing to give up privacy for some temporary security, deserve neither privacy nor security.
You frisked my six year old! I don't believe this system is making us safer. Try some common sense.
Go f**k yourself TSA. What about securing trains and bridges. Put your f**king scanners there. Use some logic and common sense. You are going to have riots on your hands.
These procedures are a small step from government sanctioned rape. What will happen when TSA find out it has sex offenders doing pat downs or people storing images of children from the scanners? If the scanners don't store the pictures, how did they end up online?
Every time I fly until you stop this nonsense, I'm gonna wear a nice dress and no panties. If your hand gets near my crotch I plan on rubbing my junk on it then speculating about what terrible transmittable diseases I'm going to lie about having. Have fun.
I opted out of a body scan and received the new pat down this past Monday. It was incredibly uncomfortable. There was a hand in my crotch 3 times. This new procedure needs to stop immediately.
Being forced to choose between having my body photographed by strangers or having my body touched by strangers in order to travel on an airplane is a disgusting violation of my rights.
True safety resides in just policies at home and abroad: this is security theater, and a big payday for Michael Chertoff.
My family and I will cancel our Christmas flights this year if the policies aren't reversed and the scanners removed. We will not fly until then and we will vote for the politicians that protect our rights.
This is a horrible invasive policy which threatens our privacy and freedom.
I will also petition my members of Congress to introduce legislation expressly prohibiting the TSA from using "Full-Body Scanning Machines" and "pat downs."
Sadly my job requires that I travel every week. I refuse the scanner and opt-out every time. I have to put up with the uncomfortable touching every time.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety" --Ben Franklin
How quickly would the TSA change its policy if everyone opted for a pat down?
I have chosen to go to school in state rather than across the country just so I don't have to fly
I am not a criminal and am very tired of being treated as one.
Those who would sacrifice essential liberties for temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety-Ben Franklin
I will be opting out if I fly and I will opt out for my daughter. I don't want to expose her to the pat down but I am more afraid of cancer.
The TSA's policies are not effective at preventing terrorism. They're effective at SEEMING to prevent terrorism. Israel's practices are far superior!
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." ~Benjamin Franklin
Two years ago we said 'strip searches?! it'll never come to that!'. Yet here we are...
Have been opting out since day 1
This is a disgrace to our freedom.
I'm flying tomorrow, please be gentle. And don't snicker at my naked x-ray, most people only see me naked in the dark. If I would've know you were going to see me naked, I would've started working out months ago.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
-Benjamin Franklin
Why fly when I can drive?
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
It's an outrageous abuse of power.
I won't be buying another plane ticket so long as I would have to subject to these machines and pat downs in order to get on the plane...
Thank you, give our rights back!
I would rather take the train than be "stripped" of my rights.
I will abstain from flying till this is abolished.
Why in the land of the free and home of the brave are we subjective to such invasions?
We need an approach similar to the airport security of Israel, lower cost and more effective.
The constitution gives government the authority to govern, and limits that authority. The TSA has overstepped the bounds of reason and of law. This must end or the terrorists have won a significant victory. Which side are you on?
I feel this is personally invasive and unnecessary. I now worry about my plans to fly next year.
End security theater now.
When this doesnt work, what else will we give up
This is TOTALLY UN-American
It's wrong, and every one of you knows it
I am not an American, but cannot bear to think of those overseas subjected to government approved sexual abuse. This must stop.
The TSA does not provide security - it provides plausible deniability if some other attack occurs. Trying to cover your ass doesn't give you the right to feel up mine.
Why are you exposing the public to extra radiation? The lack of consideration for privacy is extremely disturbing.
Had a tumor. it's gone. Was molested. never again. neither of these for the sake of security. Give me liberty or give me death.
As a deterrent to terrorism, the TSA policies have failed completely.
As a means of removing yet another layer of our rights and dignity, this has to be considered a resounding success.
It is not a criminal act to board an airplane. We should not be treated as criminals.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin
If only our forefathers were here to see how we treat our citizens nowadays.
Unreasonable! What's freedoms must we loose next?
OperationGrabAss in full effect
TSA screening is not what is keeping america safe, cut the bs and let us fly in peace.
When someone sneaks explosives on a plane by hiding them in their anal or genital cavities, will all American citizens be randomly chosen to be finger raped?
this is a fundamental misuse of power - manipulating the public through non-effective aversive behavior is not a security measure.
I haven't flown for years because of these repulsive measures. I sure miss my relatives in Chicago.
I will no longer fly as long as these scanners and pat-downs are screening methods. These are illegal and unnecessary searches.
This is ridiculous!
If I, as a Canadian, travel through the States, I will be subject to these rules, which will affect my decision to travel there. I vote that we opt out and board the plane wearing nothing but our skivvies and do jumping jacks to save them the trouble of a strip search and pat down. Hide something like an explosive device in your rectum and there's no way it's staying in there after a hundred jumping jacks.
I hope this spreads to other areas of our society where dignity is being lost: courts, cops, internet...
This is just another way to chip away at our right to privacy. It IS invasive and unnecessary.
I have to chose between a naked picture of me or a groping? I wouldn't allow this of a date or a doctor, let alone a stranger at the airport, regardless of his or her uniform. I am interviewing for jobs an 18 hour drive away, but I cannot fly because of these procedures. Government sanctioned sexual humiliation is not okay for anyone, not the poorest of third world countries, and it is embarrassing we have come to that here.
Enough's enough. I'm not standing by so that high school drop outs can destroy our Constitutional rights, and molest my family and countrymen. We are becoming our own worst enemy, the 'terrorists' have won. Fix this, or count me out.
If you want to watch born subscribe to a website dont look at me naked!
Please do not subject us to such degrading and demoralizing treatment. I am shocked by the Obama administration.
As a citizen of the United States of America. I do not want anyone to assault me in the name of "security".
Another step for the NWO to treat citizens like cattle or slaves! Stand up against it! Enough is enough!!!
I believe the TSA's policies are violating my body and my civil rights. We should fire the TSA and Homeland Defense leadership for inflicting these policies on an unwilling American public.
The only places where a citizen should be subject to a strip searched are in jails and prisons AFTER they have been presumed to be or have been convicted of a crime. Stop treating us like criminals!
We need to be more proactive in our flight safety, not reactive. Searching cars and luggage before they even enter the airport is more of a deterrent than scanning anything at the airport. That is how the middle east does it, we should too.
TSA is a cruel hoax, a jobs program, a scam. Stop the insanity, I AM NOT AFRAID OF IMAGINARYCAVE DWELLERS, I AM NOT AFRAID TO FLY!!
Imagine my reaction when I discovered that my ELEVEN year old little sister had the choice of going through either a machine that shows a full picture of you without your clothing to someone on the other side of a screen- I can't help but think that has been an upsetting idea for many years- OR having every inch of her small body TOUCHED by some adult she's never seen before in her life.
This is appalling and HAS to stop. To say it is horrifically invasive is a pathetic understatement.
I understand that there are threats. But one guy tries to blow up his shoes, now millions have to take their shoes off. Airport security feels like a tremendous, inefficient waste. I'm not going to blow up a plane, I have taken over 30 flights this year and will take more. At some point, I'd hope that somebody would say "Hey, there's Chad. He's flying today. He'll fly next week. He's fine". Instead, I'm treated randomly, under suspicion, not able to bring a bottle of water on a flight. Someone could use a ballpoint pen as a weapon. Do we start banning pens? When does it stop?
This is the first time in 10 years that I'm driving from Indiana to Florida for Christmas. The violation of my rights in the guise of security is *unconscionable*.
The TSA and their warrantless, causeless searches have been making me feel less secure, not more. It's time to assert our rights as US citizens.
I'm ashamed to say that I live in a country that allows this to occur. This is an unethical dehumanization of our citizens, a complete violation of the liberties this country was founded to protect! In any other circumstance these security measures would be constituted as sexual assault, cut and dry. I can't possibly fathom the idea that our forefathers shed their blood for this. What has happened to our humanity? Have we completely lost touch with that?
I like jobs programs, just give us one that delivers high speed rail, new Space Shuttle, Smart Grid...not more unemployable people wearing badges rifling through luggage and feeling up the traveling public.
These genital searches and naked scanners do not increase security. They only line the pockets of the people selling them!
stop this now!!!!
I have to fly in a few hours and i'm beyond pissed off. I will not be flying again until policies change
We cannot be terrorized by representatives of our own government like this. It is obscene.
if we could get bullet trains in this country already i wouldn't have to bother. until then, GET OFF MY JUNK
The security and safety of our citizens is important, but it should not come at the cost of tremendous loss of civil liberties. The current TSA procedures will likely prove ineffective, because the focus of the TSA is on items rather than intent -- a person with malicious intent need not carry destructive items through security to cause a great deal of harm. In addition to the egregious loss of privacy due to the TSA's new procedures, they may cause physical and emotional harm to our citizens. We do not want to be kept in a state of fear, especially when the threats we face are marginal! The only reason we are scared of terrorism is because we keep being told we should be scared of terrorism.
Finally, the TSA's presence represents a huge financial burden for our country. In addition to the administration and equipment costs to fund the agency, the procedures drain a very significant amount of time from the public -- time that could be better spent producing. If each person flying loses an hour due to unnecessary security procedures, that represents some 3.7 million hours of productivity lost every single day in the United States.
i would be emotionally / psychologically scarred for sure if i had to undergo that kind of personal bodily violation at an airport—it's intense enough at a doctor's office.
As a frequent traveller logging over 100,000 miles per year, I am especially concerned about the harmful effects of repeated exposure to radiation from the scanners.
Government needs to get out of my life. Abide by the Constitution. You are destroying our country with your chaos of laws. Eighty thousand pages per year of the Congressional Record is far, far too much.
Yet another TSA policy that defies common sense. Come on Janet, go on national TV and get patted down! Oh wait, you're probably too busy flying around in a private jet.
I am mainly concerned with the potential health effects of this machine. But also agree with the unwarranted search part & privacy issues. Please get rid of these machines. It's difficult & stressful enough to fly nowadays as it is. I often wonder when they'll tell us we must fly naked!! This issue has made me consider driving rather than flying in the future. I will refuse to go through the machine but at the same time feel like it will be a complete humiliating experience to have the new pat down. We can't win, either way it's bad & I don't feel any safer with this new invasive technology.
I have halted all business, and tourist travel to the United States purely because of the TSA. These latest measures are far beyond what I'm willing to tolerate for the sake of your illusion of safety.
Next time I fly I'll be wearing a kilt.
Will not fly until scanners are removed.
The lack of effectiveness of the TSA is no reason to increase it's invasive procedures.
By groping people, you are leaving us no choice but to opt for the full body scan. Any other place and groping me would be considered sexual assault. Ridiculous. This is a violation of our privacy and is unethical.
"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Ben Franklin
Until the scanners are removed and the groping stops, I will not be flying.
I'm glad i don't own any airline stocks.
As a frequent flyer, I am done with flying until these unconstitutional virtual strip searches and sexual assault-type "pat downs" are done away with. Metal detectors and light pat downs have been good enough for years...they still are.
...and, unless every airport employee with access to the secure area--every cleaner, baggage handler, and coffee barista--is going through the same strip search, then all this is fuss is for nothing. It's not an imbalance between security and privacy, it's just an outright assault on travelers' privacy and privates, with no security gain at all.
From an outraged citizen
Ridiculous abuse of government power and an affront to our constitutional rights.
Enough with the "security" theater. Follow the ElAl example.
I was screened by on of these once, I didn't know what it was or perhaps I would have objected-- it felt TERRIBLE and SO INVASIVE, I hated it so much I went immediately to the supervisor and made a complaint, I was in tears as I explained my complaint and then shaking all the way to my gate. I am not a reactive person, I do not tend to break down. But, I am a healthy person and I understood instantly on a cellular level that I was being violated. Please disband these.
Absolute outrage. I have over a million miles total in my flying lifetime and have never felt more betrayed by my government. I hope every passenger opts out. As far as not dangerous....there are reasons dental and xray techs wear lead protection. 10 years from now I am betting TSA agents will have an unusually high rate of cancer and health problems.
Not only do I find the security measures offensive and inappropriate for myself and my family but I don't believe that the effort and expense results in any meaningful change to our level of security in airports.
an optional comment:
I'm done with flying unless and until this outrageous invasion of privacy stops!
I'm refusing to fly until the scanners are removed. We should never be asked to sacrifice our liberty and privacy.
Enough is enough. We don't need to be molested for safety.
this is not security. the terrorists are winning as they have instilled enough fear that we are now losing privacy and our money. the only thing we should fear is fear itself.
My husband works with radiology on a daily basis. He wears a dosimeter to make sure he does not exceed a specific amount of radiation. These scans add to his total exposure and will reduce the length of time he can work in his field.
I am a pediatrician. I examine people daily with dignity and respect. These atrocities are completely uncalled for. Any medical personnel who treated people this way would be fired. There is no reason for this insanity. How many terrorists has TSA caught anyway??
These procedures do not help to increase safety. They only take away our dignity and dehumanize us.
Though not a citizen of the United States of America, I, too, will be refusing to fly across the border if and when CATSA decides to follow along with this abhorrent violation of our rights.
The ones posing the most danger are none other than yourselves, TSA.
The terrorists goal was to disrupt our way of life. Apparently they have succeeded.
TSA is fighting the last attack, not the next one. Anyone of us can come up with several ways that a different type of attack could be implemented. The groping by TSA "agents" will detect the many ways that an attack could be launched.
Please!
J Pistole is a Nazi.
Please stop the charade. Please screen cargo. I accept the risk when I fly - you cannot make it 100% safe.
These PORNO machines and groping techniques are UNCONSTITUTIONAL. You ought to be in JAIL. Can I feel you up, JANET ?
Tsa is a waste of space. Our airport security should be provided by national guardsman as a regular tour of duty... While carrying intimidating rifles
Until these invasive screenings are removed, I will not be flying. The same goes for my family.
Security theater is not real security. America can do better.
The TSA is a Billion dollar sexual assault operation run by pedophiles. Their measures have no reason, and they should be forfeit - along with the DHS.
Don't be afraid to profile those who have earned it.
This is violation of the 4th amendment of our constitution. The more that the 4th amendment is denigrated the easier it will be for the government to search us without reason.
The TSA must realize that by making these ridiculous policies, they've given the terrorists what they want, correct?
Going through screening on the last two flights I my breasts and thighs were squeezed. I was told that my clothes were too loose and my dress too long (it was mid-calf). In the attempt to make the country look as though it is being protected the old, the young, the innocent, and the infirm are being subjected to what I consider voyeuristic, lurid, and uncivilized actions on the part of TSA.
We train our children to not allow touching of personal areas. What are the children going to think when they see mom and dad being assaulted? It's OK if someone says you have to be assaulted? Parents humiliated before their (and bystander) children is not worth the price. Have you screened for pedophiles as screeners? What about gay screeners - can passengers demand "straight" screeners? What about rape victims? Has anyone had any training on how to scan sensitive persons. What if a woman is wearing a "pad"? Is she then thrown to the ground as a terrorist? How about elderly wearing depends? Has anyone had any training? Where is the specific information covering these questions?
We will no longer stand for government infringing on our natural freedoms. The Bill of Rights exists for a reason, the hold the government back in times such as those we live in today.
I don't want to be radiated or groped. The machines cause eye cancer and they save every picture.
There is no way I will fly if my rights are violated by TSA. There are plenty of cheaper ways to get around.
These "security measures" provide no security. They are only a way of harassing travelers, including US citizens. The scanners AND the body searches are nothing short of assault. This invasion of our personal, bodily autonomy must stop. It is un-American.
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. And will lose both"- Benjamin Franklin
I will only be flying if I absolutely have to until both the enhanced pat down and the body scanners are done away with.
If anyone were to submit the dose calculation for the X-Ray machines in any of the freshman physics courses I've EVER taught -- they'd get an "F-"
Flying for thanksgiving. I don't want my balls grabbed.
Why don't we adopt the system used in Israel. It is highly effective, non-invasive, and the entire process takes under 20 minute to get from your car to your gate. With the current system, we have never caught a terrorist and we will never catch one because the system is updated only after a potential threat/hole is exposed. This system only results in longer lines, more delays, the loss of constitutional rights, and potential medical hazards.
I fly pretty frequently and get to choose my poison each time. This is pointless harassment that doesn't make anyone any safer.
Life protected at the cost of one's dignity is no life at all.
I'm so glad I'm not living on the USA, the land of those that lost their freedom.
I do not intend to fly again until these measures are removed. This is doing nothing to stop potential terrorists, just hurting the airlines. Isn't that the opposite effect that's wanted?
When the technology exists to fully scan every external surface of our bodies and we spend extraordinary amounts of money on it. Terrorists will then begin to implant explosives inside mules, surgically, and all this technology will be for naught.
I have been hearing that flying is a "privilege" One I guess that is denied for those with any sense of modesty or propriety.
Stop the insanity!
I will not be flying unless those machines are removed. Furthermore, I won't be flying until we no longer have to endure the absurdity of removing our shoes at airports.
How the fuck is this legal
Peace before violence. End the oppression.
Land of the free?
This is unconscionable. It seems unreasonable to believe that these policies will not lead to further abuse.
This hysterical response of the government to the threat of terrorism has done precious little to truly enhance security, but it has most certainly obliterated many of the fundamental liberties that supposedly are at the core of the identity of the United States.
In one word, thanks to the actions of the TSA, the terrorists have already won.
Unconstitutional and must be viewed within the larger scope of progress in removal of civil liberties.
I'm from the UK, and I can see our lapdog Government snapping up this procedure for deployment across our airports - Not cool, bro.
Security Theater provides a false sense of security.
Pat downs that involve touching of the genitals might as well be sexual assault, especially in light of the fact there is zero reason to conduct said invasive pat-down.
We should take a hint from El Al Airlines and use psychological profiling and human intelligence to stop threats rather than invasive procedures such as naked body scanners.
I've traveled around the globe, and have never encountered security screening this intrusive, or absurd. I will not fly in the US until this is halted; for my next trip abroad, I'll fly from Canada.
Instead of developing effective methods of scaring away would-be terrorists and having non-invasive non-radiating and non-groping methods of checking passengers, why do the idiots running DHS prefer to spend billions of dollars on technology that very few people find "secure."
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.
Inconclusive safety results for long-term radiation effects on frequent fliers? Government endorsed groping of genitalia? Isn't this supposed to make us safer?
I'm not afraid of terrorists. I am afraid of what America has become in the last 10 years, and the rights that Americans have given up at a breakneck pace with little resistance. Who knew that a single largely psychological blow would have such an effect.. we are truly a nation of sheeple.
No More.
violation of every right possible. and yet we call this a democratic country.
A violation of basic rights.
Hey Washington, Chill the fuck out
Total bullshit. These machines violate rights and strip dignity. I will call every elected official and be a thorn in the TSA's side, before I succumb to these invasive backscatter x-ray searches.
I simply will not fly from or to any airport that conducts these unconstitutional and illegal searches upon my person.
I have no choice but to fly if I want to see my family this Christmas. I guarantee however, within my legal power, observing all rules, I will make this trip through security the most embarrassing I can make it for the TSA. After Christmas (tickets already purchased) I will not fly until the TSA revamps EVERYTHING to mimic the incredibly successful Israeli method of screening passengers.
I'm appalled that I haven't seen this reported in the media and had to read it on Facebook. When this does become widespread, no body will stand for it. Disgusting.
TSA listen to the people!
What is wrong with people.
The US Govt has stepped over the line
Stopgroping young children you perverts
Human dignity.
This is America. Land of the FREE. all of this type of airport security or scrutiny needs to be stopped. metal detectors are enough. stop with harrassing innocent FREE people.
Having been a victim of sexual assault, being forced to be seen essentially nude with the backscatter X-ray machine or to be fondled intimately would certainly bring up memories and feelings that I could not bear to feel and I have many friends who would feel the same based upon their similar experiences. Additionally, forcing children to submit to intimate searches is no different than molestation and may permanently traumatize them.
Enough of the security theater. Please contact real security people before coming up with new "ideas"
There are better ways...does anyone at TSA have enough brain cells to try to THINK of one? These new security measures are the epitome of un-American.
I will not fly if I have to be molested or exposed!
This is disgusting. I do not deserve to be violated just because I wan't to take a flight. No one, regardless of their position of power in the government, should be allowed to touch ANYONE in inappropriate places, it is just sick. I stand for security in our nation, but this is just over the top. Be more proactive in your screening and honestly, just LOOK at the people coming through security. Obviously a 12 year old girl isn't going to have a bomb strapped to her crotch, there is no need to feel her up. If this continues, the TSA will just attract pedophiles and perverts to their work force. This needs to stop. Now.
My wife won't fly because of this search proceedure and I don't get a vacation.
Enough is enough. Security is important, but sexual molestation and revealing named bodies is going too far.
I am deeply disturbed and disappointed with this, and intend to limit my travel heavily as a result. A limitation on travel will only further hurt the economy, jobs, and the general happiness of citizens and guests of this country. I sincerely believe this to be a violation of my rights, and hope to see it undone by any means possible.
Why don't they use the Israeli way... Take a look at this: http://www.vancouversun.com/travel/Full+body+scanners+waste+money+Israeli+expert+says/2941610/story.html
End the sexual assaults by the TSA!! Freedom or Civil War!
Terrorizing the citizens of one's own country is not how one beats terrorists.
Dear US Police State,
I just wanted to let you know that in the future I'll be getting naked and you can have one of your Federal Stormtroopers inspect my nutsack, because I won't be stepping inside your barbecue machine.
Your humble serf,
Paul
What the TSA is doing is completely wrong.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons...against unreasonable searches...shall not be violated
Do like the Israelites do.
There are many places in Alaska where flying is the only option for travel. We do not have even the luxury of choosing alternate transportation to avoid these indignities, with the lack of road systems and the length of time to drive from Alaska to the rest of the country is prohibitive as well. I also question how effective a random search actually is, as opposed to a more directed approach such as verifying identity and background of passengers. I will not EVER submit my children to these indignities.
Once you suggest EVERY piece of cargo to the same rigorous inspection you're giving us passengers then maybe I'll think what you're doing has some point. Right not, it's pointless, since you don't inspect every piece of cargo.
How about a nude flight day. then we can all bypass the scanners.
I would like my human rights back please
I am disabled, obese, and an abuse survivor. There are many reasons I do not want to be touched, including nerve damage and pain. However, because of my other physical conditions, I may not have any choice. I also live about 3000 miles away from my family, and air travel is my only viable option for seeing my elderly parents. If I had a choice, I would stop flying because of this. I honestly don't know what to do. However, I now know what it feels like to be terrorized.
We don't even get an 'opt out' to Backscatter in the UK, our only opt out is to not fly...
This TSA nonsense is not reasonable and I fly all the time. It makes me feel angry and not safer.
Everything being done to address terrorist threats has been completely reactionary. There was a shoe bomber so now we have to take off our shoes. There was underwear bomber, so now they need grope people or expose them to unsafe levels of radiation. So what about what comes next, when the next guy swallows his bomb? What will the TSA subject Americans to after that?
I will not fly again until this changes!
I refuse to fly until these methods are abolished.
I stopped flying a year ago because of this BS.
The TSA doesn't make us safe. What are Ms. Napolitano's credentials for heading this organization? Oh yes, she's a career polititian. Case closed. It's time to shut it down!
This is embarrassing. Seriously.
I will not fly while these procedures are in place.
We are consumed by trying to eliminate ALL risks in life to the point where we are willing to give up our freedoms and dignity. Enough is enough. I will not fly again as long as these policies are in place.
:(
I have already canceled a planned plane trip and will not fly until this is stopped.
Unacceptable. You won't get away with this. The American people will not give in until these practices are curbed.
Enough is enough.
I don't see what my genitals have to do with national security. Leave them alone!
I won't fly unless and until these practices are halted !!
The focus on airport security has become farcical. I beg my country's leaders to stop this blatant violation of my privacy which does little to provide security and much to degrade Americans. The boogie men are winning.
Its dis speakable that people are being searched like that, whats next? Full search on th eway out of the store just to see if you stole something?
Does the TSA hope that running the back of their hand from the top of my fly to the bottom help them catch their very first terrorist?
The security theater of TSA needs to end. The agency needs to be dismantled, with consultants from Israel & Mossad coming in to design a new screening program.
Clearly there is a trade-off between freedom and security but there needs to be some measurable (and checkable) quantification of how much security we are actually getting when we give up bits of freedom.
I will not fly until these policies are changed. The news stories you read about the TSA screeners seem to get more and more alarming.
Why can't we learn from other successful security procedures overseas?
Where does the invasiveness stop if we keep allowing this kind of policy? It's uncomfortable for the passengers, and probably for some of the screeners as well. End the ridiculousness.
TSA can’t even do their simplest job as checking that my passport and the name on my airline ticket matched. I had my name changed in 2001 on my passport after I married and the name change is on the back page. I used to point this out for the first few times and then I decided to see how many TSA workers caught it. Very surprising that it was only a few different times over the last 9 years that it was noticed. I travel very frequently, especially internationally. BTW my passport was re-issued in September 2010 not that it expired but it was full (even though extra pages were inserted), so now I can’t be amused that TSA almost always missed the name change.
I will not use the body scanners what-so-ever; it is a breach of my privacy and a risk to my health as I fly excessively. Who will be continually checking radiation emissions once the machines began working? I have seen some body scan pictures on the internet and it is utterly disgraceful and humiliating. The bottom line is that it is porn!
I have had malignant melanoma (deadly skin cancer) and other skin cancers, and I am VERY concerned about receiving the extra radiation to my skin in backscatter X=Ray!
Please use your brain.
Spend taxpayers' money on intelligence and stopping terrorists before they are able to carry out attacks, instead of stripping us of our rights in the name of "safety."
This is wrong and it's creepy...another move towards Big Brother!
The TSA has become drunk with power, abusive, and oppressive. Even worse, their insulting attitude and invasive illegal searches DO NO GOOD.
I had to go through the scanner on my honeymoon. No reason given, obviously, but it's very humiliating!
I don't know a single person who is actually worried there will be a terrorist on their flight.
It is truly a sad day when we let a need for security override our basic human rights
Please, no full body scanners!!! You know how humiliating this will be to me? In fact, I just won't fly if you do. Do traditional checks. Also, why not use canines for additional security? They have such powerful sense of smell.
I refuse to fly if it means being sexually assaulted. Enough is enough.
I will not fly at all. Period. Done.
I am a frequent flyer and a patriot. I believe in America and Americans. Unfortunatly, the TSA's rules and regulations are as unamerican as borscht and Czars.
I will not fly again until this is remedied. Period.
We will be driving instead of flying this holiday season.
Security theater does not make us safer, it only intrudes upon our privacy. Our government is using fear to control us.
In addition to the affront on our dignity, this just sends a message to the terrorists--YOU ARE WINNING
I am disheartened every time I hear someone say "well, post 9-11 you have to make sacrifices." Dammit, we're awfully quick to hand over rights that generations have fought to preserve.
The new scanners simply don't work. An explosive placed in a body cavity gets by 100% of the time. Once we have 100% screening of baggage and solid background checks of TSA and airport employees (we don't now) maybe we can think about strip searches for passengers. Until then this is just very expensive security theater.
Will not fly until this is stopped.
"Those who sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither." - Ben Franklin
I am an expatriate who flys between Bermuda, Canada and the USA frequently. The state has no right to fondle or irradiate my person. Particularly my genitalia. For flights internal to North America there is no enhanced security as a result of these violations of person. The searches are invasive, expensive, ineffective and simply stupid.
People do not deserve this type of treatment.
I will be driving from CA to KY instead of purchasing 6 plane tickets for my family this Christmas because of these policies.
I used to think that flying was the only way to go. I will NEVER fly again until these intrusive procedures which assault and insult our bodies are done away with FOREVER!!!
I have recently avoided flying for just these reasons. Due to these practices, my family is spending the holiday season closer to home, and is planning all vacations to ensure they do not involve risking health and happiness at your hands.
TSA...read the Constitution please...
These pat downs are just a "legal" sexual assault. These should never be done on a child!! The scanners are just a perverted way for people to see us naked. They say that the images are not kept on file but they sure are everywhere on the internet and it is disgusting!! I would never allow a picture like that taken of me and I would absolutely not allow those types of images of myself to be taken in a very public place - this is just wrong!!
The X-Ray machine and the invasive pat down don't make us any safer. You could just as easily stick something in your anal cavity and neither the scanner or the pat down would detect it.
The only goal of a terrorist is to disrupt normal life and make people fearful. Just like the TSA
I am boycotting air travel to "essential only". Wearing a kilt comando-style when I do have to fly.
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated
This is an appalling over-reach on the part of the TSA.
looking forward to creating a scene and filming it next time I fly.
Seriously! Let's do things that actually make us safer.
I fly at least twice a week and over 200k miles a year. the TSA's assertion that they are trying to keep me safe is an absolute joke. the TSA employees are completely incapable of doing anything except harassing travelers.
If I can't drive there, I won't go. Flying is no longer an option for me.
If we live in fear, the terrorists win...this procedure gives them the game!
I may not have a choice but to submit to this nonsense, but I'll not do it happily.
Stop immediately!
We aren't winning the war on terror if you are terrorizing your own citizens and stomping in their rights. Enough with the theater, enough with the TSA BS!
Please stop eroding our freedoms.
Please end the sexual assault now.
It used to be fun to fly, then it was just okay. Now it's a HORROR!
This is a flagrant disregard for our Human Civil Rights.
I'm not sure which is more embarrassing, cooperating with these procedures or that we have these procedures.
Where does it stop?
I will be voting with my dollars and not flying until this is fixed
"I plan to opt-out the next time and every time I fly." - Agreed.
This is just stupid and will not stop anyone that truly wants to do damage. All it does is allow TSA to cop a feel. If you want to help, then profile as it works. Forget about PC
The machines are a complete waste of money as terrorists will find ways to avoid security. It is the same issue our troops face in the middle east with the enemy constantly changing their tactics as procedures are changed.
I choose not to fly until these machines/invasive procedures are stopped.
Are the TSA agents required to follow a professional oath/code after screening people (naked)? Are they held to the same level of confidentiality as doctors? NO. This is ridculous.
None of the screening techniques the TSA uses have caught any terrorists, there are serious concerns about the callibration of the backscatter machines and the enhanced pat-downs are abusive, triggering for survivors of assault and it's all a tremendous waste of time and productivity while abrogating our civil rights.
Name one time the TSA (Touching Scrotum Association) has stopped any terrorist plot? They failed with the shoe bomber. They failed with the underwear bomber.
These procedures are invasive and dangerous on many levels. This has to stop.
I have a trip coming up and I have decided to drive. Sick of being treated like a criminal!!
I am a business traveler who will not put up with these non-effective methods.
For my six-year-old daughter, who is still learning what "freedom" is supposed to mean.
I refuse to fly until I will be respected as a person and as a mother I cannot, in good conscience, allow such groping to happen to my children. Furthermore, I believe this policy creates an atmosphere that suggested every customer is guilty until proven innocent. I would rather never travel again than be subjected to this. I will be happy to give my business to Amtrak instead of be humiliated.
I don't understand why my government wants me to a) be subjected to dangerous machinery that could lead to health problems that will be a drain on resources this country needs or b) sexually assaulted by federal employees. Can you explain that?
we have entered the age of the dictator...there must be opposition
to human rights abuse
I'd sooner walk across the country than fly.
I don't care about being seen naked. I do care about others wanting to see me naked without reciprocity, for whatever purpose. One is naturism, the other is voyeurism.
Enough! I'm horrified that things have come to this. As an American living abroad, I dread the possibility that the current policies will still be in effect when I visit home. I should be able to look forward to seeing my family instead of dread the humiliation I will have to face in an American airport.
I was subjected to not only the backscatter and view naked, but then a pat-down (felt over my whole chest) in front of everyone else in line. Pure humiliation. This is ridiculous and had I know before hand what I was getting myself into, I would have refused the procedure.
Read the 4th amendment.
What is this country comming to? I am seriously considering driving rather than flying or departing from an airport that doesn't have these scanners. Shame on the government!
Stop the madness. Pat downs on 3 year olds who are screaming "stop touching me"?! This is ridiculous.
I do not want my kid, my wife or myself scanned or inspected in the way that they are doing this. It is wrong and unnecessary. The terrorists have won if we live in terror.
LEAVE US ALONE! What is next...searching me before I set a foot out of my home?
we must begin to define ourselves as a people who do not not allow themselves to be forced in to submission by the fears of the elite. my family and I do not deserve to be radiated and searched. i choose to use other means of transportation. the biggest thing we could all do is STOP FLYING. hit them in the pockets, its the only place they feel anything.
I will not fly or allow my child to fly until this abuse of power stops
I have not seen any evidence that these "enhanced security measures" make flying safer, only more difficult. I do not want my child to be subjected to these procedures. I do not devalue myself so much that I believe I deserve this treatment.
Our family will drive from now on until you guys learn some common sense.
These scanners and invasive searches are disgusting and beyond offensive. As a young woman who has heard about the predatory nature of many of these TSA searches, I am choosing not to fly until things change.
Osama Bin Laden and his kind are laughing at us, and the way we have corrupted our rights and freedoms in the name of security. Don't give the terrorists the satisfaction of doing this to our own citizens.
Congressmen aren't the only people we should be contacting. Airports are allowed to bring in private screening companies. The airline companies have large political sway, and it's their bottom line that would be hurt.
No airline will get my hard-earned money when I travel until these ridiculous and scandalous "security" requirements are discontinued. The goal of terrorism is to fundamentally change the day-to-day lives of the target population. So thanks to the Bush administration and the TSA, the terrorists have won. The "security" measures these troglodytes have implemented are totally reactionary as evidenced by the fact that I now have to remove my shoes, put my shampoo in tiny little bottles, and throw away by bottle of water and my nail clippers (because we all know how dangerous water and nail clippers can be on a plane). I've even had a TSA agent who clearly had a room-temperature IQ (who hires these people, anyway?) open my toothpaste and smell it. Really??!? To rule out what, exactly? A sinister toothpaste bomb? And now these fear mongering reactionary control freaks want me to submit myself to full body radiation and/or a groping that's even illegal for the police to do to me if I am stopped for an actual crime. So the terrorists say "thank you" to Bush, Cheney, the TSA, and everyone who has banded together to take away the very rights that USED to make this country stand alone. The terrorists have won. They have turned the United States into just another banana republic.
"I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it." - Thomas Jefferson
Stop violating my constitutional rights in a symbolic quest for security.
We will not fly at any airport using these TSA techniques.
I think it is wrong to assume consent to new procedures put into place long after tickets were purchased, especially if they are purchased by a 3rd party for someone else.
My family will be opting out and doing so publicly, and will no longer fly after our next trip which we can't cancel because the policies were instituted before we could change our travel arrangements.
As a flight attendant who goes through security checks ALL the time, I find this appalling! I have a steel plate in my arm that goes off when I go through. I don't want to get more radiation by going through the new scanner and I sure don't want to get violated by a pat down, either! TSA hasn't kept any threats from our aircraft...it's been flight attendants and passengers who've kept us safe (i.e. the shoe bomber and the underwear bomber)!
Security theater does nothing to protect any of us. Let's instead consider bringing in real experts from Israel and implementing their techniques. At the point where we're requiring people to take off their shoes (which happened years ago), we already went too far. Today's rules belong in old Soviet Russia, not the US.
It is only up to us as citizens to stop this nonsense.If an extensive boycott of air travel becomes reality, that alone will make the TSA rethink their strategies.
In my regular interactions with the TSA (I work in a port) I am consistently asking myself are these people making us more secure and the conclusion I come to is no. The TSA is an abomination to our constitutional rights and exemplifies the worst in fear mongering here in the this country. I, for one, am sick and tired of all the security theater that is being forced upon us by the "security experts".
I will no longer fly until this practice stops. It is time to profile passengers and stop this stupid "political correctness" nonsense
I am particularly concerned about the effects on people who are recovery from sexual abuse or rape. The costs of this system are far worse than any supposed benefits.
This will save me a lot of money since I won't be flying until this practice is halted. I intend to let American Airlines know every time I decline to attend a conference because of the TSA.
This is as much about the dignity of the airport workers who must carry out these ridiculous scans and patdowns as it is for the travelers. When you're travelling for something like a funeral, the last thing you need is a good groping by a stranger.
Wanting to fly is NOT probable case.
We cancelled our family trip to California and won't be flying and go through this with our young kids.
As someone who flys over 100,000 miles a year, I have never been in the position where the TSA has done anything to make me feel safer. I believe their practices do more to encourage fear and we need to look at international security models that have proven more effective and cease removing liberties from the American public
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. - Benjamin Franklin, 1759
TSA, stop the disgusting security theater.
I had knee replacements 14 y ago..I just flew out of ABQ and was patted down. I was no offered private pat down and had men staring at me from the other lines. Perhaps each one of the TSA agents should be patted down in front of the passengers.
I will no longer fly commercial until the scanners are removed. Even hyper security Israel doesn't do this and doctors have voiced concerns about xray exposure on the skin because of the machines.
"Or at least buy me dinner first."
I have written to my Senators and Congressman to stop this violation of the 4th Amendment. If they try this with me next week, this Grandma will make a scene and have an ACLU atty on speed dial!
While I support a secure transportation system, I firmly oppose a system that assumes every American citizen is the threat. I've heard, "Post-9/11 world" for nine years and it is well beyond the time to innovate a system of security beyond body scanning and groping.
I'm in favor of security, but these aren't the best way. Try bomb sniffers, dogs and profiling (yes, profiling). Also, they have no idea what the long terms effects of the radiation is going to be, no matter what spin they put on it or who in Washington they pay off.
The enhanced pat downs constitute sexual assault under all of the statutes I've looked up. Given the alternatives are an x-ray without shielding or an ,000 fine, consent to a pat down can only be coerced, not legally given. Get the federal government out of the business of sexually assaulting its citizens.
Please stop government sanctioned sexual harassment and child molestation.
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety".
-Benjamin Franklin
It is NOT OKAY to touch our private parts -- nor is it okay to have people look at our naked bodies in the name of 'security.'
The pat downs are vile, demeaning and nothing short of sexual assault. I nor my wife will ever fly again until these liberty stripping practices are changed or abolished.
We need to adopt different security measures. The measures we have implemented now would not have prevented any of the attacks that they were put in place to stop.
There are better ways to ensure our safety.
As a survivor of abuse, I cannot and I will not subject myself or my daughter to these procedures. Are the TSA agents themselves subjected to a rigorous background check that includes accusations of abuse?
“It is acceptable and encouraged that a TSA government official can do something to an American citizen that US military personnel cannot do to a member of the Taliban.”
The erosion of our rights that has been steadily growing since 9/11 makes me sick. We are becoming a nation of COWARDS.
Molestation is not the answer you power tripping TSA psychotic goons.
I refuse to fly until these invasive scanners are removed.
Violation of our constitutional rights!
I refuse to fly if I have to go through an Xray machine and get unnecessary radiation, that could potentially get me sick later in life. IT IS NOT WORTH IT!!
This is nothing but security theater. This is not actual security. This is terrorizing our own citizens. Congratulations, terrorists, mission accomplished. We are scared of everything, and violating our own citizens on your behalf. Why is it that Israel, a country constantly under attack, does not even need to resort to these terrible antics in their airport? Because they are willing to hire capable employees and put them through training, to rely on common sense and human instinct as well as non-invasive security measures. Why can't we follow their lead?
I am more than happy to take the same risks I took while flying in the 80s, 90s, and even after 9/11 compared to the ridiculous security theater we now have to endure. Plastic explosives have existed for a looooong time; this is not a new threat.
A year ago, I had surgery to block an aneurysm in my brain. Who knows if the wire fill will set off metal detectors? X-rays cause cancer - I learned that thru my treatment for the aneurysm. Body groping is sexual molestation. TSA is making criminals out of us, guilty until proven innocent. Stop this madness.
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
This crosses the line. I will vote with my dollars and refuse to travel by air.
I think that the TSA is being too REACTIONARY with their security protocols, and should start being PROACTIVE, and look at the systems that other countries such as Israel are using (which seem to be working!).
Signed. I will be driving until this is fixed. I will also be urging everyone I know to do the same.
I choose not to fly so long as doing so entails a challenge to my basic civil rights.
Freedom to travel without humiliation is purely American.
I will not be flying unless and until these policies are changed. These scanners and invasive pat-downs are an obscene abuse of power under the guise of keeping us safe.
I haven't seen my brother in 4 years and planned on visiting him in the spring in Hawaii. I will not visit him until this practice is removed in the states. I would understand this practice for flights in and out of 3rd world countries but anymore a standard pat down in plain view of others is all that should ever occur. I'm not paying over a thousand dollars for a flight to get molested by security agent that is supposed to be protecting me. I'm sure TSA agents hired for this aren't too keen on having to do this nor able to sleep well at night either. Unless they are hired perverts.
I have 2 young children. I do not want them subjected to more radiation than is absolutely necessary and I will not allow strangers to touch them on their genitals--we have taught our children that their bodies are theirs alone and nobody may touch them.
People fought and died, and continue to fight and die to protect our civil rights, an essential part of being an American and ensconced in our Constitution. For our government to deny us our civil rights is a slap in the face to those who found this country and died for it.
Please stop this madness!
I think it is horrible that we allow the TSA workers to "feel up" passengers. If I was to do that to people, because I wanted to see of the had anything on them, I would be arrested. This is too much. The scanners are an invasion of privacy and I don't see how lawmakers can justify this.
Freedom comes before "Security."
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. Benjamin Franklin.
The range of security inspections I have run into has varied from place to place. Some quite respectful.
Others not in the least. If the goal is to stop the public from flying and bring travel to a standstill I believe these intensified, lurid searches will do the trick.
Janet, I don't expect you to care about our complaints any more than you care about the 4th Amendment.
I do not fly very often, but I have no desire to be violated when I do. That these policies have been implemented is a victory for the terrorists. I am also horrified that a group sanctioned by the US government is being trained in and encouraged to engage in sexual assault.
Fly With Dignity
I am a modest person by nature and would be reduced to tears to have someone seeing me "virtually" naked or "patted down"
This is going too far. An effective balance between personal liberties and security can be found, but this is certainly not it.
Won't fly until the scanners are aggressive pat downs are gone... would prefer the entire TSA itself to go. Not so feminized yet myself that I'll allow folks to look at and/or touch my wife and children.
This is an outrageous invasion of our privacy, and must be stopped.
I refuse to allow myself and my children to be personally violated and will not fly again until the strip searches and enhanced pat downs are stopped.
I feel bad for the Americans whose jobs require them to fly with any regularity. One should not need to have his or her body exposed or touched by a stranger to feed his or her family.
Neither myself, my wife, or my son will fly while these security measures are in place. No one needs to feel my genitalia, see my wife in the nude, or molest my baby in the name of the TSA's "security theater."
I'm boycotting all flights until our Rights are restored!
The safety of the AIT scanners is in question and should be addressed. No amount of radiation is safe. And respected scientists feel the amount of radiation actually being absorbed, particularly by the skin, is significantly more than the amount published by the TSA. Further, how can the United States government really say that people's only choices are potentially harmful radiation which produces a detailed naked picture OR sexual violation? Our country is better than that.
A government should do everything in its power to protect the people, except take power away from the people. Through the implementation of these mandatory pat-downs and body scans, our government has become what it strives to protect us against: terror.
I'd be against these measures even of one plane a week was being taken down. On a separate note, Mr. Chertoff, can you spare a dime please?
Also will not fly until these scanners are removed from use.
This is beyond the scope of what is necessary. It compromises human rights and a person's dignity.
“Those who desire to give up freedom in order to gain security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.”
I for one will not be flying until this madness is halted.
Won't fly until this changes. As great Founding Father Ben Franklin said "They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither safety nor liberty."
I will not be flying at all until these scanners are removed from use. They interfere with my 4th amendment constitutional rights, and if nothing else, the Government should regulate them under the Commerce Clause as they absolutely are significantly impacting interstate commerce.
I am afraid to fly as it is, and require medication to do so. Please don't add further trauma. We may live in a world of danger, but we are still human beings.
I have a boy and two girls and will not subject them to either the scan or pat down. We teach our kids that only doctor's can see and touch their private parts and only when mommy and daddy are in the room. No one else can!
Until you have the tarmack and cargo more securred this is a wasted use of resources... check what is going into the cargo hold... Leave the pilots alone! they have already been prescreened... this is ridiculous for those being "fondled in their private parts" and those having to do the "foundling" the public is not stupid... this is not making us safer than the less invasive pat down...
Won't fly until this policy is changed.
This is already hurting tourism. Get the TSA under control!
Stop unreasonable "safety" measures. The choice to have naked images taken or to be felt up does not seem reasonable to me.
will not fly until this debacle ends
our rights are inalienable, even by the tsa.
I have meekly accepted taking my shoes off, and surrendering my bottled water in the "security theater" of TSA. I will not surrender my dignity, and will not fly until the policy of treating me as a terrorist until proven otherwise is rescinded.
Please stop this violation of our constitutional rights under the 4th amendment. Freedom cannot be sacrificed on the alter of security.
Dreading flying this holiday season.
My family will not be flying as long as they are forced to submit to these scanners and pat-downs.
Hard to say it better than Benjamin Franklin: "They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." If the TSA's new policies aren't a direct assault on our 4th amendment liberties and our dignity, I do not know what is.
I would prefer that the TSA stop running their hands over my vagina ( yes, that happened) and not expose me to cancer-causing radiation unless they want to pay my therapy and medical bills. These methods do not prevent terrorism.
The TSA and all their so-called security measures are a joke. I feel no safer flying on a plane after being groped and x-ray'd. Bring back the flying of a decade ago and suddenly see the economy and flights in general pick up.
The ends do not justify the means. The 4th amendment is in place to protect my privacy. Without a reasonable idea that someone has illegal firearms in their house, we do not execute a search of their property. We don't have a reasonable expectation that everyone going to the airport is concealing illegal weapons, so what makes this any different?
I feel violated every time I go through the security line. These two measures are far beyond violating and do nothing for our security.
I am disgusted at the level of invasion that is taking place here and even more disgusted that this was ever allowed to come to pass.
TSA policy is NOT law. We cannot allow the agency to erode our individual/collective liberties in exchange for a dubious sense of national security. The right to privacy and our right to be protected from illegal search and seizure, once lost, even incrementally, shall be in all estimation, difficult if not impossible to win back.
The TSA policy is wholly reactionary, unethical and governed by politics, profit and the security industry lobby. It is unwarranted! Tragically, such a policy carries the weight of law as its compliance is enforced in part by law enforcement officials. And as such, any questioning or dissent of such an illegal search becomes a challenge to the police state. What has now taken the place of common sense, and diligent work by our intelligence agencies is replaced by intimidation of law enforcement to program into us compliance.
The question is, how effective is a policy in stopping terrorists (specifically with plastic explosives strapped to their groins)—now that they know not to do it? And how does patting down grandma or anyone else reassure the rest of us that of anything but the fact that we are now considered guilty until proven innocent? This is not what this great nation stands for.
In my humble opinion, the hidden agenda is to condition us to passively relinquish our rights little by little; all in the name of 'security'. To let fear control our daily lives is to allow terrorism to win and the imminent growth of the fascist police state. We must not allow that to happen!
Refusing to fly until...
I STRONLY oppose the "backscatter" / full-body scan machines, as well as the very invasive pat-downs. I suggest that if you're going to do a full-body scan that you start using the machines that our allies in Europe are using which only display a "stick figure."
We will remain on the ground until these full body scanners are removed, and the invasive "enhanced pat-downs" are stopped.
RFID tags aren't far behind.
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.
Thank you TSA. The terrorist have won. I no longer have basic privacy.
The appearance of security is NOT security. Most of the activities performed by TSA are purely to make us "feel" safe but are not actually making us safe.
Disgraceful and unconstitutional.
Where do we go from here when someone gets through in spite of the scanners and the pat downs? In past cases it sounds like there were red flags or information out there to alert security but the ball was dropped. That's the real problem...that the dots are not connected...not that the current systems aren't sufficient enough without the scanners and enhanced pat downs. Once I fly on my already purchased ticket I doubt I will fly again under the new guidelines. I will choose to drive from here on out.
Will not fly until these scanners are removed, way to stimulate the economy
"Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
-Benjamin Franklin
as a previously abused person, I do not think I would like to become a vicim again only this time to the government for the same thing.
Those that would give up liberty in the name of safety deserve neither.
2 words: 4th admendment!
I'm flying for Christmas and I plan to decline the naked body scan. Hopefully the TSA agent will be gentle with my testicles.
Don't want to fly around as long as this crap exists. I feel sorry for the people submitting to it. My hearts with you.
It's about time people said enough is enough and this so called security is WAY over the top!
I stopped flying when it became apparent that the airlines no longer were interested in me as a passenger, but only as a revenue stream. When seats got smaller, and tickets became more restrictive (no changes unless a $$$ is paid) and not only no guarantee of getting where you paid to get to on time, but in actual experience almost never happening.
Then came 9/11 and the government stepped in... I would never subject myself to that regimen, let alone the latest iterations of scanners and pat downs. It amazes me what people will put up with before making it unequivocally clear - I'm mad as hell and not going to take it anymore!
I even 50% of the flying public sat out a few months, things WOULD change...
The rest of you "sheeple" can have all the security you think you are getting - and pay for it too...
Oh, and one last note - the MOMENT we changed our way of lives in response to 9/11 - the terrorists have already won.
Would like to see the appropriate procedure for the opt-out pat-down process outlined in detail. I cannot find it, and it would be useful information in knowing whether my assigned TSA employee is crossing the boundary from professional into inappropriate behavior
The terrorists have won.
overly invasive body search in order to force people to accept backscatter scan is abominable
Both the machines, and the "opt-out" groping, are sexual molestation. STOP IT STOP IT STOP IT.
I refuse to fly if doing so is conditioned upon submitting to two flavors of sexual molestation.
I had no idea that these scans took such invasive photos. I should have been informed before I entered the machine. I thought it was a new metal detector. This should be illegal.
I stand by Ron Paul's legislation to end this encroachment on our freedom as Americans!
I'm refusing to fly under current conditions. We are currently considering a flight out of Toronto for our Christmas vacation.
The humiliation of the ill conceived security measures is hardly worth the trouble.
Extremely inappropriate behavior and invasion of privacy. I would dread flying with my children.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and Warrants shall not be issued, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
Don't touch my junk!
the constitution is non negotiable! you will not blast my family with cancer causing DNA transforming radiation, nor feel them up just for profit.
No proof that these new methods are working at all. Instead, our privacy is invaded.
I will not fly unless absolutely necessary... Then I will opt out of the full body scanner!
Don't let the terrorists win. Protect our rights!
I conducted checkpoint security in Iraq, congrats on subjecting American citizens to a more invasive search then possible enemy insurgents
I am willing to comply with rules designed with our safety in mind, but will not submit to having my privacy violated or putting my personal health at risk. I will start chosing to drive extended distances than fly. Often this is faster because security has become so cumbersome, inconsistant bewteen airports and questionably even effective.
This is a clear violation of our rights as humans and American.
The TSA has overstepped their boundaries. They should send their own children through these scanners, or "enhanced patdowns"
I refuse to fly.
I'm not in favor of the backscatter machines due to a) the violation of privacy rights, b) the potential health effects that go with them, and c) the lack of security they provide (they're more for show than for actual security). There are other circumstances as well:
As a person with Type 1 Diabetes (the kind you get by genetics, not by lifestyle), I spend my life tethered to an insulin pump. This pump will be severely damaged by X-ray machines of any sort - I have no choice but to refuse the X-ray machine and go through the metal detector.
No matter what, because of a disease that's outside of my control, I will now be subject to an examination which, if not done by the government, would be considered sexual assault.
While I hate to call on the Americans with Disabilities Act (I don't need any special privileges, thanks, nor do I want them), this new TSA policy obviously illustrates a conflict between government regulations. By having diabetes and an insulin pump, I will be discriminated against here. At the same time, someone who exhibits classic signs of a person who's hiding something can walk through without question.
And we won't even begin to discuss how Congress is unduly burdening interstate travel, which goes against the precedent set by cases such as Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States (1964), in direct reference to the Commerce Clause.
In short, this TSA policy is discriminatory, invasive of privacy, and does little to make the U.S. safer. Instead, it continues the practice of 'security theater' and makes U.S. citizens & non-citizens alike subject to molestation by TSA employees, sanctioned by the federal government.
It is wrong, and it must stop.
I will not fly until these communist procedures are removed.
Xrays are harmful, and searches should be no more thorough then are allowed. Profiling is a valid tool. How about using the body scanners as a "fast lane" or as a 2nd level?
Please Google "TSA finds Explosives". You will see 6 hits, all dealing with 1 incident that turned out to be cosmetics. The TSA has never found explosives. These procedures are merely security theater, made to rob good, law-abiding citizens of their rights and dignity. This must stop.
Being a frequent traveler, I worry about the health concerns
I will not be flying any airlines until these scanners are gone. What gives an organization the right to invade peoples utmost privacy? Whats next? Head scans?
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
This is rediculous!
Huge breach in privacy, transportation security can be implemented better without the use of revealing body scanners, and instead with chemical/bomb sensing(smelling) devices....Recently saw a german tv show where a man hid bomb making materials on his self and the scanner didn't reveal it...what would have stopped this in the first place? a scanner that sensed the ingredients used to make an inextinguishable detonator.....TSA employees are too similar to the ones of fast food and should not be trusted
We are taking the train instead of flying for holiday travel. If enough people did this, maybe the airlines will notice and join in the effort.
Will not fly until these scanners are removed from use and strip searches are completely halted.